Should American Citizens Who Became Daesh Brides Be Allowed Back Home?

[Co-Chair Bagel23]

This is a growing problem with the collapse of the physical territories of Daesh. Thousands of women, including some Americans, went to Syria and Iraq to join them, and now that they don't have hardly any turf left, a lot of them want to come home. This is a growing issue, I saw this story like two days ago.

https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/20/americas/isis-bride-alabama-wants-to-return-intl/index.html

And I saw this other one from the UK who has no remorse at all. I don't think they should be allowed back in, with hardly any exceptions. Just no.

[Big Abraham]

I can't think of anything good that would come about as a result of letting them back in.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

Yes, and then charge them accordingly under the relevant laws for supporting terrorism.

[PSOL]

Yes, and then charge them accordingly under the relevant laws for supporting terrorism.

[Stranger in a strange land]

Yes, and then charge them accordingly under the relevant laws for supporting terrorism.

[Reaganfan Democrat]

Citizenship is citizenship. If they don't return to America, they will become another country's problem, which is unacceptable.

Charge them with treason when they come home and execute them.

[Former President tack50]

Only if they don't have any other nationality (if they are dual citizens, strip them of American citizenship).

Also if they do go home they should be sent inmediately to jail.

[Yellowhammer]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

[OSR stands with Israel]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

[Yellowhammer]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

[OSR stands with Israel]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

[Yellowhammer]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

If they didn't kill anybody, then they should not be punished in either of those ways.

[Co-Chair Bagel23]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

If they didn't kill anybody, then they should not be punished in either of those ways.

I’d be ok with execution for treason

[courts]

no

[OSR stands with Israel]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

If they didn't kill anybody, then they should not be punished in either of those ways.

Her decision to join ISIS is equivalent to an American during WW2 joining the Nazis, and that crime deserves the harshest sentences possible

[Yellowhammer]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

If they didn't kill anybody, then they should not be punished in either of those ways.

Her decision to join ISIS is equivalent to an American during WW2 joining the Nazis, and that crime deserves the harshest sentences possible

Not in my opinion. The death penalty should generally be reserved for those who have themselves killed. Becoming an ISIS bride is nowhere near as bad as being, say, an abortion "doctor."

Treason is often a very good thing, so I would hesitate to ever execute anyone for "treason" alone.

[OSR stands with Israel]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

If they didn't kill anybody, then they should not be punished in either of those ways.

Her decision to join ISIS is equivalent to an American during WW2 joining the Nazis, and that crime deserves the harshest sentences possible

Not in my opinion. The death penalty should generally be reserved for those who have themselves killed. Becoming an ISIS bride is nowhere near as bad as being, say, an abortion "doctor."

Treason is often a very good thing, so I would hesitate to ever execute anyone for "treason" alone.

How does the issue of Abortion have anything to do with this , And yes becoming an ISIS bride is equivalent  to joining ISIS .


Is your opinion on Treason because you support the Confederacy

[Yellowhammer]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

If they didn't kill anybody, then they should not be punished in either of those ways.

Her decision to join ISIS is equivalent to an American during WW2 joining the Nazis, and that crime deserves the harshest sentences possible

Not in my opinion. The death penalty should generally be reserved for those who have themselves killed. Becoming an ISIS bride is nowhere near as bad as being, say, an abortion "doctor."

Treason is often a very good thing, so I would hesitate to ever execute anyone for "treason" alone.

How does the issue of Abortion have anything to do with this , And yes becoming an ISIS bride is equivalent  to joining ISIS .


Is your opinion on Treason because you support the Confederacy

No, it's because when the thing you are "betraying" is evil, then treason can be an obvious and objective good. Betraying the United States is not necessarily bad.

[OSR stands with Israel]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

If they didn't kill anybody, then they should not be punished in either of those ways.

Her decision to join ISIS is equivalent to an American during WW2 joining the Nazis, and that crime deserves the harshest sentences possible

Not in my opinion. The death penalty should generally be reserved for those who have themselves killed. Becoming an ISIS bride is nowhere near as bad as being, say, an abortion "doctor."

Treason is often a very good thing, so I would hesitate to ever execute anyone for "treason" alone.

How does the issue of Abortion have anything to do with this , And yes becoming an ISIS bride is equivalent  to joining ISIS .


Is your opinion on Treason because you support the Confederacy

No, it's because when the thing you are "betraying" is evil, then treason can be an obvious and objective good. Betraying the United States is not necessarily bad.

So you believe the United States is evil, if so you really shouldnt call your self patriotic

[Yellowhammer]

No. Sentencing them to live in Syria or Iraq for the rest of their lives is probably a greater punishment than whatever slap on the wrist they would probably receive upon coming back.

Life in Prison or the Death Penalty is not a slap in the wrist

Both of those punishments are much too harsh imo.

Why if they joined ISIS that means they are terrorists

If they didn't kill anybody, then they should not be punished in either of those ways.

Her decision to join ISIS is equivalent to an American during WW2 joining the Nazis, and that crime deserves the harshest sentences possible

Not in my opinion. The death penalty should generally be reserved for those who have themselves killed. Becoming an ISIS bride is nowhere near as bad as being, say, an abortion "doctor."

Treason is often a very good thing, so I would hesitate to ever execute anyone for "treason" alone.

How does the issue of Abortion have anything to do with this , And yes becoming an ISIS bride is equivalent  to joining ISIS .


Is your opinion on Treason because you support the Confederacy

No, it's because when the thing you are "betraying" is evil, then treason can be an obvious and objective good. Betraying the United States is not necessarily bad.

So you believe the United States is evil, I mean if you think that you really shouldnt call your self patriotic

I believe that the United States is not necessarily good in its current and long-standing state. I definitely wouldn't call myself patriotic either. I refuse to say the pledge of allegiance; I haven't said it in years.

[Sprouts Farmers Market ✘]

Trump has finally made America woke again.

[Reaganfan Democrat]

Her decision to join ISIS is equivalent to an American during WW2 joining the Nazis, and that crime deserves the harshest sentences possible

It's not the same, because the US has not formally declared war on ISIS, but Yellowhammer is obviously being absurd by saying things like "treason is sometimes good" and the "US is not necessarily good", especially when we're talking relative to f**king ISIS here.

[Okay, maybe Mike Johnson is a competent parliamentarian.]

Yes, and then charge them accordingly under the relevant laws for supporting terrorism.

[RFayette 🇻🇦]

Yes, and then charge them accordingly under the relevant laws for supporting terrorism.

[DavidB.]

Hard no.