The event of October 7 and its aftermath can strain relationships.

[Upper Canada Tory]

As a Jew I don't think I would want a friend who fully supports a cause that wants me killed, but that's just my opinion.

[Upper Canada Tory]

As a Jew I don't think I would want a friend who fully supports a cause that wants me killed, but that's just my opinion.

You are misrepresenting my position.

I said that Palestinians who were displaced during Nakba should be compensated or allowed to return to Israel.

I didn't say anything about wanting anyone killed.

I didn't say you personally want anyone killed. I said you support a cause that does so, and this is clearly true, because this is the position of every large 'pro-Palestine' organization with power and weapons in the Middle East (Hamas, Hezbollah, Palestinian Islamic Jihad, et al), whether publicly or implicitly.

You live in a fantasy world where Palestinians will 'return' to the homes of their grandparents because of their intergenerational refugee status that only applies to them, but not Mizrahi Jews who were forced out of the Arab and Muslim world in the 1940s. That is your right to believe that. But you cannot force others to ignore the consequences of giving Palestinians in the region selective rights that Jews don't have.

People with your political ideology put next to zero effort to ensure that the rights of Jews in the Middle East are protected, even though their rights in the region are violated regularly, while reflexively believing every false fanatical claim about what Israel does ('Israel is committing apartheid, ethnic cleansing, genocide!!!').

[Upper Canada Tory]

As a Jew I don't think I would want a friend who fully supports a cause that wants me killed, but that's just my opinion.

You are misrepresenting my position.

I said that Palestinians who were displaced during Nakba should be compensated or allowed to return to Israel.

I didn't say anything about wanting anyone killed.

I didn't say you personally want anyone killed. I said you support a cause that does so, and this is clearly true, because this is the position of every large 'pro-Palestine' organization with power and weapons in the Middle East (Hamas, Hezbollah, Palestinian Islamic Jihad, et al), whether publicly or implicitly.

You live in a fantasy world where Palestinians will 'return' to the homes of their grandparents because of their intergenerational refugee status that only applies to them, but not Mizrahi Jews who were forced out of the Arab and Muslim world in the 1940s. That is your right to believe that. But you cannot force others to ignore the consequences of giving Palestinians in the region selective rights that Jews don't have.

People with your political ideology put next to zero effort to ensure that the rights of Jews in the Middle East are protected, even though their rights in the region are violated regularly, while reflexively believing every false fanatical claim about what Israel does ('Israel is committing apartheid, ethnic cleansing, genocide!!!').

I didn't say that "Palestinians will 'return' to the homes of their grandparents". I said that they should be allowed to return to Israel if they choose. Whether they can find a place to live or not is another matter.

Also, I don't pretend that I am happy with the rights given in the Muslim world. I certainly am not.

And the Palestinians are hardly unique in not giving up their struggle for self-determination. How many people under colonial rule - because this is what Israel's rule in Palestine amounts to in practice - have given up the struggle for independence? So while one can certainly deplore Palestinian terrorism, it's preposterous to claim the Palestinians are somehow sick for not giving up their desire for self-determination.

Palestinians don’t have to give up their struggle for independence, they need to accept that they lost in 1948 and that they will not get that land back ever. If Palestinians limited their terrorism to West Bank settlers and soldiers only with the clear demand that “terrorism will only stop when you leave the West Bank” that would be one thing. But the Palestinian demand is that Israel stops existing. They need to accept that they lost in 1948 and this will not be corrected in any way. Imagine if the Algerians demanded not just that the French leave Algeria but that they also leave France. That is what Palestinians demand, and they use terrorism to pursue this fundamentally impossible goal.

Palestinians should be given Israeli citizenship as part of the amended Law of Return.

The whole point of Israel having a Jewish majority is so the country is a safe haven for Jews. If you let Palestinians become the majority, they will slaughter millions of Jews if Hamas’ behavior is any example so far. Now I know you don’t really care about what happens but a lot of people do.

Nakba is Israel's original sin.

It's time for Israel to atone by taking back the Palestinians.

If the Jewish "majority" is so afraid that the Palestinians would do to them what they are doing to the Palestinians right now, they should establish the rights of minorities right now in case they are ever in the minority.

In your previous posts you have mocked legitimate Jewish concerns about the Arabs' treatment of the Jewish population. The 'Jews should establish minority rights so they don't get killed by Palestinians' (Israel already has minority rights, discrimination based on ethnicity and religion is  already illegal in Israel, it certainly isn't illegal in the PA, Gaza and elsewhere in MENA).

Would you argue alternatively that Gaza, Lebanon, etc. should pass anti-discrimination law to protect Jews and Christians in order to avoid having their population being killed by Israel? Your right to live as a civilian depends on whether or not your government grants minority rights?

Part of the source of the conflict, which you support, is unequal refugee rights - Palestinians get intergenerational refugee status even when many of them are now citizens of Jordan, while Jews forced out of MENA don't get any refugee status. Israel has to be overwhelmed by Palestinians because they were displaced 75 years ago and grant them citizenship, while the Arab and Muslim world doesn't have to do the same thing with Jews displaced from MENA 75 years ago.

[Upper Canada Tory]

As a Jew I don't think I would want a friend who fully supports a cause that wants me killed, but that's just my opinion.

You are misrepresenting my position.

I said that Palestinians who were displaced during Nakba should be compensated or allowed to return to Israel.

I didn't say anything about wanting anyone killed.

I didn't say you personally want anyone killed. I said you support a cause that does so, and this is clearly true, because this is the position of every large 'pro-Palestine' organization with power and weapons in the Middle East (Hamas, Hezbollah, Palestinian Islamic Jihad, et al), whether publicly or implicitly.

You live in a fantasy world where Palestinians will 'return' to the homes of their grandparents because of their intergenerational refugee status that only applies to them, but not Mizrahi Jews who were forced out of the Arab and Muslim world in the 1940s. That is your right to believe that. But you cannot force others to ignore the consequences of giving Palestinians in the region selective rights that Jews don't have.

People with your political ideology put next to zero effort to ensure that the rights of Jews in the Middle East are protected, even though their rights in the region are violated regularly, while reflexively believing every false fanatical claim about what Israel does ('Israel is committing apartheid, ethnic cleansing, genocide!!!').

I didn't say that "Palestinians will 'return' to the homes of their grandparents". I said that they should be allowed to return to Israel if they choose. Whether they can find a place to live or not is another matter.

Also, I don't pretend that I am happy with the rights given in the Muslim world. I certainly am not.

And the Palestinians are hardly unique in not giving up their struggle for self-determination. How many people under colonial rule - because this is what Israel's rule in Palestine amounts to in practice - have given up the struggle for independence? So while one can certainly deplore Palestinian terrorism, it's preposterous to claim the Palestinians are somehow sick for not giving up their desire for self-determination.

Palestinians don’t have to give up their struggle for independence, they need to accept that they lost in 1948 and that they will not get that land back ever. If Palestinians limited their terrorism to West Bank settlers and soldiers only with the clear demand that “terrorism will only stop when you leave the West Bank” that would be one thing. But the Palestinian demand is that Israel stops existing. They need to accept that they lost in 1948 and this will not be corrected in any way. Imagine if the Algerians demanded not just that the French leave Algeria but that they also leave France. That is what Palestinians demand, and they use terrorism to pursue this fundamentally impossible goal.

Palestinians should be given Israeli citizenship as part of the amended Law of Return.

The whole point of Israel having a Jewish majority is so the country is a safe haven for Jews. If you let Palestinians become the majority, they will slaughter millions of Jews if Hamas’ behavior is any example so far. Now I know you don’t really care about what happens but a lot of people do.

Nakba is Israel's original sin.

It's time for Israel to atone by taking back the Palestinians.

If the Jewish "majority" is so afraid that the Palestinians would do to them what they are doing to the Palestinians right now, they should establish the rights of minorities right now in case they are ever in the minority.

In your previous posts you have mocked legitimate Jewish concerns about the Arabs' treatment of the Jewish population. The 'Jews should establish minority rights so they don't get killed by Palestinians' (Israel already has minority rights, discrimination based on ethnicity and religion is  already illegal in Israel, it certainly isn't illegal in the PA, Gaza and elsewhere in MENA).

Would you argue alternatively that Gaza, Lebanon, etc. should pass anti-discrimination law to protect Jews and Christians in order to avoid having their population being killed by Israel? Your right to live as a civilian depends on whether or not your government grants minority rights?

Part of the source of the conflict, which you support, is unequal refugee rights - Palestinians get intergenerational refugee status even when many of them are now citizens of Jordan, while Jews forced out of MENA don't get any refugee status. Israel has to be overwhelmed by Palestinians because they were displaced 75 years ago and grant them citizenship, while the Arab and Muslim world doesn't have to do the same thing with Jews displaced from MENA 75 years ago.

Letting millions of Palestinians return to Israel would simply result in the slaughter of Jews. This group is so radicalized and undoing this will take years. Plus, these are two different peoples with different ideas in terms of governing customs. A binational state makes zero sense.

The proper way to handle it is have the Palestinians recognize Israel in something resembling 1967 lines and in return Israel withdraws from the entire West Bank (minus the settlements right on the green line that are annexed to Israel and Israel gives comparable land in the northern or southern end of West Bank to the Palestinians). Israel should dismantle the settlements 20 miles inside the West Bank.

The point of Israel is to be a safe refuge for Jews and allowing millions of violent Arabs into its borders defeats the point.

Lastly, most societies around the world can NOT integrate different cultures and religions the way America has.

Exactly the point I'm trying to convey to pppolitics. Thank you.