How has CARLHAYDEN affected your opinion of amnesty for illegal immigrants?

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

FAR more in favor. I used to not care. Now I strongly support full and unconditional amnesty for all illegals.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

I just wish people like CARLHAYDEN and StatesRights would be brave enough to say what they really think.

We all know they are both very afraid of millions of brown people (brown people who speak a different language!!) coming into our country. That is at the center of all their hatred towards illegal immigrants... their own petty racism and elitism.

That's pretty much what I've gathered, and what's mostly altered my position.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

I think ag simply summed CARL up the best:

If you only knew how much most of your ramblings would fit the Volkischer Beobachter from the 1930s. You are a true national-sociallist, no question of that - and I am increasingly convinced that your type would fit better in Germany, not in Italy.  Unfortunately, I've known too many people like you (I grew up in a place where many people are proud Nazis), I can't mistake the type. As they say in Russia (I always loved Reagan's habit of using Russian proverbs left and right ), the hunchback can only be cured by being burried in a grave - moral hunchbacks like you are equally incorrigible.  You are outside human morality, that's what the problem with you.

I don't really have time, nor energy to react to all the venom you've been spouting, so I will not react to this anymore - I will just ignore your existence from now on.  Mercifully, the US is a strong country - the scum lilke you will forever be marginal there. That is why I love the US.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

FAR more in favor. I used to not care. Now I strongly support full and unconditional amnesty for all illegals.

I suppose murderers, rapists, and thieves should be pardoned of their crimes as well?

Murderers, rapists and thieves have crimes that actually hurt people. The only thing 'illegal' immigrants are guilty of is a law that shouldn't be there in the first place.

Regardless, we live in a 'law and order' society (supposedly) and because we have immigration laws, they need enforcing.  No they don't directly hurt people in the same way, but they do deplete state resources that could be given to citizens.

That doesn't seem like a very libertarian position. Libertarians hate laws, and are against distributing state resources.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

Read up CARL:

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/sarcasm

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

Hmmm, old thread.

I actually like CARLHAYDEN now, because the main target of his vitrol is the despicable, disgusting pile of human trash that is John McCain.