Who would win this hypothetical election? What would the map look like?

[bagelman]

I think the Christian would win because the silent majority of the country is socially conservative and fiscally center-left. It would be close either way though, as young whites would probably be more for the other side. The Hispanic vote would strongly swing towards the Christian candidate. College counties would swing the other way.

As for me, if I'm doing well enough financially I would find it easier to vote for the atheist candidate out of gay self preservation.