1968:
George Romney vs.
Hubert Humphrey1972:
Richard Nixon vs.
George McGovern1976:
Gerald Ford vs.
Scoop Jackson1980:
John Anderson vs.
Jimmy Carter1984:
Ronald Reagan vs.
Walter Mondale1988:
Pat Robertson vs.
Paul Simon1992:
George HW. Bush vs.
Tom Harkin1996:
Pat Buchanan vs.
Bill Clinton2000:
Gary Bauer vs.
Al Gore2004:
George W. Bush vs.
Howard Dean2008:
Mike Huckabee vs.
Hillary Clinton2012:
Donald Trump vs.
Barack Obama2016:
Donald Trump vs.
Bernie Sanders2020:
Donald Trump vs.
Bernie Sanders For my list, I'm using declared candidates that were either nominated or had a realistic shot at being the nominee. Bolded candidate is the candidate that I would want to win in said match up and I have maps as I don't have the time. Will provide further elaboration for some elections:
1968: George Romney vs. Hubert Humphrey
1972: Richard Nixon vs. Edmund Muskie
1976: Ronald Reagan vs. Scoop Jackson
1980: George HW Bush vs. Jimmy Carter
1984: Ronald Reagan vs. Gary Hart
1988: George HW. Bush vs. Dick Gephardt
1992: George HW. Bush vs. Tom Harkin
1996: Pat Buchanan vs. Bill Clinton
2000: George W. Bush vs. Al Gore
2004: George W. Bush vs. John Kerry
2008: Mitt Romney vs. Hillary Clinton
2012: Rick Santorum vs. Barack Obama
2016: Ted Cruz vs. Hillary Clinton
2020: Donald Trump vs. Joe Biden (though by a much larger margin that in Real life)
Why Scoop Jackson for 1976 and why Dick Gephardt for 1988?