Do You Believe in the 'Great Replacement Theory'?

[Antonio the Sixth]

"The great replacement theory" works like many recent conservative propaganda tactics (the CRT and Gender Ideology panics work in much the same way, for example), where the use of a short, quippy slogan is used to convey a set of logical propositions that range from "trivially true" to "deranged conspiratorial lunacy". If accused of propagating the latter, they can always retreat to the former, and use it to act like their opponents are the crazy ones. It's a really ingenious and pernicious use of semantic ambiguity.

[Antonio the Sixth]

Yes, but I'm in favor of it.

Honestly, this is the take I want to go with sometimes.

[Antonio the Sixth]

Yes, but I'm in favor of it.

Honestly, this is the take I want to go with sometimes.

I know we'll be of vastly different minds on this, but I hope you can appreciate the humor in the prospect of pro-immigration rightists hoping people from the developing world can swamp out secular, liberal white voters. AFAIK it's only a phenomenon so far on the Internet or maybe in Canada(?).

Arguably the most successful (well, "successful") example of that is Israel. Although that's often an aspect of Israeli society that's overlooked because it doesn't fit into either Side's narrative.

But frankly, I'll take the values of your average Mexican Catholic any day over your average White American heretic who thinks God is all for cutting welfare, destroying the environment and mass incarceration.