How would the 2016 election go if this fictional character was the Republican nominee?

[Blow by blow, the passion dies]

Ed Donnell, a fictional 38 year old Senator for Virginia. He supports a flat tax and Balanced Budget Amendment to the US Constitution, free trade and low tariffs as long as they benefit America (Donnell supports renegotiating NAFTA and TPP), an activist foreign policy that avoids reckless foreign interventions, protecting the First, Second and Fourth Amendments, mandatory rehabilitation for drug addicts, school choice and trade schools, malpractice reform and cutting red tape for private insurers, ending late-term abortions and funding for Planned Parenthood, slashing regulations that only help corporations, fighting climate change through cap and trade and developing advanced technology, campaign finance reform, no cuts for Medicare and Social Security, and providing healthcare vouchers for low-income families. His running mate is Mike Pence, and the Democratic ticket consists of Hillary Clinton and Tim Kaine as in OTL.

[Chips]

Honestly it could go either of two ways:

He would either win with a map that looks like this:



or fall flat on his face with a map that looks similar to 2012, only flipping his home state.

[Blow by blow, the passion dies]

My first thread on Atlas