Which has produced better music: Fall Out Boy or Catholicism?

[John Dule]

BRTD's insecurity about his own beliefs and taste drive him to overcompensate by obnoxiously inflicting those opinions on others so that he can blame the widespread social rejection of his foul preferences on his behavior rather than the preferences themselves.

[Joe Republic]

I rarely laugh out loud while reading this forum, but seeing this thread title did it for me.  Good job.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

BRTD's insecurity about his own beliefs and taste drive him to overcompensate by obnoxiously inflicting those opinions on others so that he can blame the widespread social rejection of his foul preferences on his behavior rather than the preferences themselves.

The funny thing is most people I know in real life who aren't into my music like my co-workers or older people at my church tend to assume I actually have great taste in music because I go to shows all the time and have such a huge record collection and it's usually bands they've never heard of so they assume I'm some sort of esoteric connoisseur or something.

[Utah Neolib]

One band vs a many centuries long religion. Somewhat unbalanced comparison.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

This is just Patrick Stump and not the whole band but oh holy sh!t does this blow any Catholic music out of the water.

Also Andy Hurley's earlier band is absolutely legendary: