How would you have voted in past presidential elections without third parties?

[RINO Tom]

1789: George Washington (NP-VA)
1792: George Washington (NP-VA)
1796: Adams (F-MA)
1800: Adams (F-MA)
1804: Pinckney (F-SC)
1808: Madison (DR-VA)
1812: Madison (DR-VA)
1816: King (F-NY)
1820: Monroe (DR-VA)
1824: Quincy Adams (DR-MA)
1828: Quincy Adams (DR-MA)
1832: Clay (NR-KY)
1836: Harrison (W-OH)
1840: Harrison (W-OH)
1844: Clay (W-KY)
1848: Taylor (W-LA)
1852: Scott (W-NJ)
1856: Fremont (R-CA)
1860: Lincoln (R-IL)
1864: Lincoln (NU-IL)
1868: Grant (R-IL)
1872: Grant (R-IL)
1876: Hayes (R-OH)
1880: Garfield (R-OH)
1884: Blaine (R-ME)
1888: Harrison (R-IN)
1892: Harrison (R-IN)
1896: McKinley (R-OH)
1900: McKinley (R-OH)
1904: Roosevelt (R-NY)
1908: Taft (R-OH)
1912: Taft (R-OH)
1916: Hughes (R-ME)
1920: Harding (R-OH)
1924: Coolidge (R-MA)
1928: Hoover (R-CA)
1932: Hoover (R-CA)
1936: Landon (R-KS)
1940: Willkie (R-NY)
1944: Roosevelt (D-NY)
1948: Dewey (R-NY)
1952: Eisenhower (R-KS)
1956: Eisenhower (R-KS)
1960: Nixon (R-CA)
1964: Johnson (D-TX)
1968: Nixon (R-CA)
1972: Nixon (R-CA)
1976: Ford (R-MI)
1980: Reagan (R-CA)
1984: Reagan (R-CA)
1988: Bush (R-TX)
1992: Bush (R-TX)
1996: Dole (R-KS)
2000: Bush (R-TX)
2004: Bush (R-TX)
2008: McCain (R-AZ)
2012: Romney (R-MA)
2016: Clinton (D-NY)

My party registration would be pretty simple: Federalist until they collapsed, Whig from their inception to their collapse and Republican ever since.  TRUE Republican hackery likely would have started to wane between 1994 and 2000, though Trump is the first modern nominee to ever not have my vote fairly safely in the bag.