The Grand Compromise of 2019: Banning Abortion for Amnesty

[100% pro-life no matter what]

Abortion becomes illegal in exchange for amnesty and citizenship for everyone in the country.  This is done via constitutional amendment, so neither are likely to be changed for a long, long time.  Do you take this deal?

[Alabama_Indy10]

There is no way this happens.

[courts]

this is literally the opposite of my views

[Santander]

This is retarded and not even worth theorizing about.

[here2view]

I'd probably say no to any type of "compromise" you make regarding abortion.

[Karpatsky]

Very few people in the country want either of those, and the subset who want either probably aren't the type to compromise on the other.

[DC Al Fine]

In a heartbeat.

[Skunk]

Are you like, an actual person?

[Santander]

Are you like, an actual person?

[Boobs]

Arguably the only upside to an abortion ban is to not ever hear ExtremeConservative talk about abortion again, but even that's not guaranteed.

[Unconditional Surrender Truman]

ExtremeUnionist ExtremeWhig YaBB God ★★★★★ Posts: 10163

The Grand Compromise of 1863: Banning Secession for Slavery « on: January 15, 1863, 6:07:46 pm »Secession becomes illegal in exchange for the legally protected right to own slaves everywhere in the country.  This is done via constitutional amendment, so neither are likely to be changed for a long, long time.  Do you take this deal?

[OSR stands with Israel]

ExtremeUnionist ExtremeWhig YaBB God ★★★★★ Posts: 10163

The Grand Compromise of 1863: Banning Secession for Slavery « on: January 15, 1863, 6:07:46 pm »Secession becomes illegal in exchange for the legally protected right to own slaves everywhere in the country.  This is done via constitutional amendment, so neither are likely to be changed for a long, long time.  Do you take this deal?

You know this comparison compares


Abortion to Secession
and Amnesty to Slavery

[OSR stands with Israel]

I dont support Amnesty and I dont support a complete Abortion Ban Either(I support a 20 week ban and banning funding for it)

[Attorney General & PPT Dwarven Dragon]

I'm not going to consent to this obvious attempt to divide the Atlasian Left and the Atlasian Center, and therefore I vote Present. ExtremeConservative needs to find better things to do with his time.

[Unconditional Surrender Truman]

ExtremeUnionist ExtremeWhig YaBB God ★★★★★ Posts: 10163

The Grand Compromise of 1863: Banning Secession for Slavery « on: January 15, 1863, 6:07:46 pm »Secession becomes illegal in exchange for the legally protected right to own slaves everywhere in the country.  This is done via constitutional amendment, so neither are likely to be changed for a long, long time.  Do you take this deal?

You know this comparison compares


Abortion to Secession
and Amnesty to Slavery

Did I make everyone mad, then? Excellent!

I mean, obviously I'm poking fun of "grand bargains" as a concept rather than making specific comparisons between these things, but whatever.

[Del Tachi]

this is literally the opposite of my views

[Catholics vs. Convicts]

this is literally the opposite of my views a win-win for me

[Blue3]

lol

[Chunk Yogurt for President!]

In a heartbeat.

[Clark Kent]

this is literally the opposite of my views a win-win for me

In a heartbeat.

[thumb21]

No

[🦀🎂🦀🎂]

This is probably a worse deal for the Republicans: you can quite easily "undo" an abortion ban, but you can't undo amnesty.

[Devout Centrist]

Lmao

[America Needs R'hllor]

Are you like, an actual person?

[MasterJedi]

Better option: abortion is kept legal the way it is and fully expanded into all states. ED Medication needs to have written consent by your spouse to be able to be received, not covered by insurance.