I really liked the second season, but it really went downhill after that imo
Pretty much this.
I gave Coven and Freak show legitimate chances, and at some times it seemed like it was getting back in it's groove, but then fell flat. Hotel was a dumpster fire. I didn't even bother with Roanoke.
Roanoke was horrible. All my roommates and I have a "We don't talk about Roanoke" policy lmao
But honestly Cult (the most recent completed season) was incredible. Asylum was my favorite season by far, but Cult comes in second until we see how Apocalypse goes. I really really am enjoying this season though, it's really good.
Murder House, Asylum, and Coven were classics. Freak Show, Hotel, and Roanoke sucked. But Cult and Apocalypse are getting back to the quality of the first three or so seasons in my opinion.