ACLU backs NRA (for 1A reasons, not 2A)

[dead0man]

link-ACLU

You must be logged in to read this quote.

[KingSweden]

1A is more in the ACLU’s wheelhouse

[Former Dean Phillips Supporters for Haley (I guess???!?) 👁️]

As much fun as it is to pile on the NRA, this is probably the right move here.

If NRA had actually done things to actually merit getting shut down by the government, the way to do that is through actual prosecution, like with RICO. Given the Butina saga, it is possible there could actually be some there there, but if so it is something that should be pursued through the legal system, with the defendant organization having the right to a fair trial, not through strong-arming from the executive branch of the NY State Government.

[Torie]

Kudos to the ACLU on this one. I am no fan of the INRA (yeah, I am even less of a fan of the IRA, although I assume it is out of business these days ), and do favor more strict controls of guns, but what Cuomo is doing is outrageous and offensive here, and I would be very surprised if the courts do not agree to put on end to it.

[Koharu]

As much fun as it is to pile on the NRA, this is probably the right move here.

If NRA had actually done things to actually merit getting shut down by the government, the way to do that is through actual prosecution, like with RICO. Given the Butina saga, it is possible there could actually be some there there, but if so it is something that should be pursued through the legal system, with the defendant organization having the right to a fair trial, not through strong-arming from the executive branch of the NY State Government.

Yep. I hate the NRA, but they are entitled to their rights, including the first amendment.

[Cold War Liberal]

As much fun as it is to pile on the NRA, this is probably the right move here.

If NRA had actually done things to actually merit getting shut down by the government, the way to do that is through actual prosecution, like with RICO. Given the Butina saga, it is possible there could actually be some there there, but if so it is something that should be pursued through the legal system, with the defendant organization having the right to a fair trial, not through strong-arming from the executive branch of the NY State Government.

Yep. I hate the NRA, but they are entitled to their rights, including the first amendment.

[Rules for me, but not for thee]

Kudos to the ACLU on this one. I am no fan of the IRA, and do favor more strict controls of guns, but what Cuomo is doing is outrageous and offensive here, and I would be very surprised if the courts do not agree to put on end to it.

IRA? Lol intentional there?

But yes, I'm solid-pro-gun and I won't support the NRA because they have lost the plot (as an Englishman might put it).  But they do have 1st amendment rights.

[Person Man]

As much fun as it is to pile on the NRA, this is probably the right move here.

If NRA had actually done things to actually merit getting shut down by the government, the way to do that is through actual prosecution, like with RICO. Given the Butina saga, it is possible there could actually be some there there, but if so it is something that should be pursued through the legal system, with the defendant organization having the right to a fair trial, not through strong-arming from the executive branch of the NY State Government.

Yep. I hate the NRA, but they are entitled to their rights, including the first amendment.

[KingSweden]

Kudos to the ACLU on this one. I am no fan of the IRA, and do favor more strict controls of guns, but what Cuomo is doing is outrageous and offensive here, and I would be very surprised if the courts do not agree to put on end to it.

IRA? Lol intentional there?

But yes, I'm solid-pro-gun and I won't support the NRA because they have lost the plot (as an Englishman might put it).  But they do have 1st amendment rights.

I’d be curious to hear a critique of the NRA from a staunch 2A supporter

[Progressive Pessimist]

This is why the ACLU don't deserve the hatred they get from the right. They would still defend your rights even as you curse them.

[NewYorkExpress]

Bad move by the ACLU. They've just left my Holiday card list.

The NRA is a terrorist organization and therefore does not deserve first amendment rights...just like Al-Qaeda or ISIS.

[Antonio the Sixth]

As much fun as it is to pile on the NRA, this is probably the right move here.

If NRA had actually done things to actually merit getting shut down by the government, the way to do that is through actual prosecution, like with RICO. Given the Butina saga, it is possible there could actually be some there there, but if so it is something that should be pursued through the legal system, with the defendant organization having the right to a fair trial, not through strong-arming from the executive branch of the NY State Government.

Yep. I hate the NRA, but they are entitled to their rights, including the first amendment.

This.

[GM Team Member and Senator WB]

As much fun as it is to pile on the NRA, this is probably the right move here.

If NRA had actually done things to actually merit getting shut down by the government, the way to do that is through actual prosecution, like with RICO. Given the Butina saga, it is possible there could actually be some there there, but if so it is something that should be pursued through the legal system, with the defendant organization having the right to a fair trial, not through strong-arming from the executive branch of the NY State Government.

Yep. I hate the NRA, but they are entitled to their rights, including the first amendment.

This.

[pbrower2a]

The First Amendment, and not the Second, protect the rest.  Free speech includes the freedom of speech for the despicable as protection against becoming defenseless,

[mencken]

Thank goodness the people in this thread are generally more sensible that this drivel.

[Sestak]

Bad move by the ACLU. They've just left my Holiday card list.

The NRA is a terrorist organization and therefore does not deserve first amendment rights...just like Al-Qaeda or ISIS.

lmao

[OneJ]

As much fun as it is to pile on the NRA, this is probably the right move here.

If NRA had actually done things to actually merit getting shut down by the government, the way to do that is through actual prosecution, like with RICO. Given the Butina saga, it is possible there could actually be some there there, but if so it is something that should be pursued through the legal system, with the defendant organization having the right to a fair trial, not through strong-arming from the executive branch of the NY State Government.

Yep. I hate the NRA, but they are entitled to their rights, including the first amendment.

This.

[President Punxsutawney Phil]

Bad move by the ACLU. They've just left my Holiday card list.

The NRA is a terrorist organization and therefore does not deserve first amendment rights...just like Al-Qaeda or ISIS.

lmao

[Atlas Has Shrugged]

Bad move by the ACLU. They've just left my Holiday card list.

The NRA is a terrorist organization and therefore does not deserve first amendment rights...just like Al-Qaeda or ISIS.

nobody cares

[Antonio the Sixth]

Thank goodness the people in this thread are generally more sensible that this drivel.

Just because we don't think the NRA should be the target of political prosecution doesn't mean we won't cheer if it dies off for unrelated reasons.

[mencken]

Thank goodness the people in this thread are generally more sensible that this drivel.

Just because we don't think the NRA should be the target of political prosecution doesn't mean we won't cheer if it dies off for unrelated reasons.

"Unrelated reasons" meaning that businesses (read:banks and insurance companies) in New York state will not do business with the NRA, likely due to the strong-arm tactics of New York's state government which the ACLU is combating. Seems pretty related to me.

[Ban my account ffs!]

I tend to believe the ACLU is almost always on the right side of things.

[Co-Chair Bagel23]

American Conservative League Upholders

[Dr. MB]

American Conservative League Upholders

...

[pbrower2a]

The ACLU has stated officially that if the government ever tried to squelch Christian Protestant fundamentalism, it would stand behind the free-speech rights of Christian Protestant fundamentalists.

The NRA obviously has the right to say what it wants, even of that includes exempting people from consequences of criminal use of firearms even to the extent of murder. Freedom of expression includes the defense of absurd, unpopular, and even insane speech. It's up to us as a free people to decide what expressions we are willing to hear.