Reelected Senators in the 2012 US Senate election: Jon Tester is the Survivor

[Unimog]

Polls are closed now.

Results:

McCaskill -3 (5-5-3)
Manchin  -3 (-5+2)
Wicker 8 (5+3)
Brown 6 (-5 +5 +2-2+2+4)
Tester -10 (-5-2-3)
Sanders 1 (3-3+3-2)
Cardin 1 (1) (invalid)

We eliminate Wicker and Brown.

Round 6

You have 6 votes to eliminate, which you have to cast 3-2-1

We eliminate 2 Senators.

Voting is open for 36 hours.

[Unimog]

Carper 3
Nelson 2
Manchin 1

[Gass3268]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best Senators?

Joe Manchin D-WV 3
Dianne Feinstein D-CA 2
Tom Carper 1

[Antonio the Sixth]

3 Carper
2 Manchin
1 Cantwell

[Donerail]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best worst Senators?

Fixed that for you.

3 Feinstein
2 Nelson
1 Stabenow

[Talleyrand]

3 Carper
2 Manchin
1 Cantwell

[Antonio the Sixth]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best Senators?

Yeah, it's a pity. But to be fair, I planned to eliminate him in 4-5 rounds. His electoral performance was pretty disappointing.

[Gass3268]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best worst Senators?

Fixed that for you.

Are you a Wall Street Shill?

[Donerail]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best worst Senators?

Fixed that for you.

Are you a Wall Street Shill?

No, just a shill for a free and open Internet, a lack of indefinite detention of US citizens, and no war with Iran.

[Gass3268]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best worst Senators?

Fixed that for you.

Are you a Wall Street Shill?

No, just a shill for a free and open Internet, a lack of indefinite detention of US citizens, and no war with Iran.

I would agree that his co-sponsorship of the Protect-IP Act was disappointing, but other than that his record has been stellar and I doubt that someone that was consistently against the war in Iraq would support a war in Iran. 

[Donerail]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best worst Senators?

Fixed that for you.

Are you a Wall Street Shill?

No, just a shill for a free and open Internet, a lack of indefinite detention of US citizens, and no war with Iran.

I would agree that his co-sponsorship of the Protect-IP Act was disappointing, but other than that his record has been stellar and I doubt that someone that was consistently against the war in Iraq would support a war in Iran. 

Then why did he vote for HR 1540 and S. Res. 380? He may have been anti-Iraq, but being consistently against the war in Iraq doesn't mean you're anti-war, not by any measurement (the current President can attest to that by his own actions).

[Antonio the Sixth]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best worst Senators?

Fixed that for you.

Are you a Wall Street Shill?

No, just a shill for a free and open Internet, a lack of indefinite detention of US citizens, and no war with Iran.

I would agree that his co-sponsorship of the Protect-IP Act was disappointing, but other than that his record has been stellar and I doubt that someone that was consistently against the war in Iraq would support a war in Iran. 

Then why did he vote for HR 1540 and S. Res. 380? He may have been anti-Iraq, but being consistently against the war in Iraq doesn't mean you're anti-war, not by any measurement (the current President can attest to that by his own actions).

How does supporting things that an overwhelming majority of the Senate supported make you "one of the worst Senators", exactly?

[politicus]

Manchin 3
Nelson 2
Carper 1

[Donerail]

Did we really just eliminate one of our best worst Senators?

Fixed that for you.

Are you a Wall Street Shill?

No, just a shill for a free and open Internet, a lack of indefinite detention of US citizens, and no war with Iran.

I would agree that his co-sponsorship of the Protect-IP Act was disappointing, but other than that his record has been stellar and I doubt that someone that was consistently against the war in Iraq would support a war in Iran. 

Then why did he vote for HR 1540 and S. Res. 380? He may have been anti-Iraq, but being consistently against the war in Iraq doesn't mean you're anti-war, not by any measurement (the current President can attest to that by his own actions).

How does supporting things that an overwhelming majority of the Senate supported make you "one of the worst Senators", exactly?

An overwhelming majority of the Senate backed PIPA? And if he's some kind of leftist superhero, isn't he supposed to oppose things the majority of the Senate does (a la Sanders)?

[Antonio the Sixth]

If you are deeming him "one of the worst Senators", he'd have to have done at least one thing that is both bad and significantly far from the Senate mainstream.

[Donerail]

If you are deeming him "one of the worst Senators", he'd have to have done at least one thing that is both bad and significantly far from the Senate mainstream.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PROTECT_IP_Act

[Antonio the Sixth]

If you are deeming him "one of the worst Senators", he'd have to have done at least one thing that is both bad and significantly far from the Senate mainstream.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PROTECT_IP_Act

You must be logged in to read this quote.

Thanks for proving my point.

[Niemeyerite]

3 Manchin
2 Carper
1 Cantwell

[Donerail]

If you are deeming him "one of the worst Senators", he'd have to have done at least one thing that is both bad and significantly far from the Senate mainstream.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PROTECT_IP_Act

You must be logged in to read this quote.

Thanks for proving my point.

41<50.

[Antonio the Sixth]

If you are deeming him "one of the worst Senators", he'd have to have done at least one thing that is both bad and significantly far from the Senate mainstream.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PROTECT_IP_Act

You must be logged in to read this quote.

Thanks for proving my point.

41<50.

So Brown is (according to your ludicrous logic) one of the 41 worst Senators. Such a big deal.

[Donerail]

If you are deeming him "one of the worst Senators", he'd have to have done at least one thing that is both bad and significantly far from the Senate mainstream.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PROTECT_IP_Act

You must be logged in to read this quote.

Thanks for proving my point.

41<50.

So Brown is (according to your ludicrous logic) one of the 41 worst Senators. Such a big deal.

We haven't touched on his stance on trade, or his anti-2nd Amendment crazyness.

[Antonio the Sixth]

OK...

[Unimog]

Polls are closed now.

Results:

Manchin        14
Carper          13
Nelson            6
Feinstein         5
Cantwell          3
Stabenow        1

We eliminate Manchin and Carper.

Round 7

 You have one vote to eliminate; we eliminate one Senator; Voting is open for 36 hours.

[Unimog]

Eliminate Feinstein

[Antonio the Sixth]

Eliminate Cantwell (basically the same as Feinstein, except anyone from SF deserves a special treatment ).