Moderate Dem Nominees Versus Liberal Dem Nominees

[後援会]

Hey, I wonder what sparked this inquiry? No worries of course.

Anyways, I don't think being a moderate is useful unless you're in a REALLY right-wing district or a REALLY small area (like Montana, ND, or whatever). I also wouldn't read too much into Dukakis, Mondale, and etc. The Democratic Party was /very/ different back then.

I mean, in 2010, I think there were several indications. Halter always polled much better than Blanche Lincoln, and Sestak always polled much better than Specter. And that NC Democrat (can't remember his name) was doomed from the start for this reason even though he was in a very Republican district. And Tom Barrett didn't poll any better than his leftist primary rival. And Baldwin, despite being way more leftist than all of our competitors, didn't do any worse in the polls.

Of course, I don't have any solid numbers to back me up, so you can take this with a grain of salt. But I have just have seen very few examples of Democrats being punished for being too liberal. And I feel it's easier to be an electorally successful moderate Republican than a moderate Democrat. After all, the GOP nominated MITT ROMNEY and are even excited.

[後援会]

How in god's name is Mitt Romney a moderate in this day and age?

See: everything he has ever done as an elected official.

[後援会]

Who performs better in general elections? Moderates like Bill Clinton, Schwietzer or Warner would attract a lot of GOP-leaders and independents. But they wouldn't get as much base excitement as liberals like Dukakis, Dean, or Obama. Who, historically, have performed better on the nation level?

As a MA resident during Dukakis' term as Gov I can tell you he was no more liberal than Clinton. He was basically a technocrat. What is true is that he was unable to deflect that charge of liberalism from the well executed '88 campaign of GHWB.

Whoops, didn't catch it. But this is very true. On what basis do people call Dukakis a liberal? Besides being against the death penalty, which is stupid regardless of your political ideology.

In fact, I really like Dukakis. Enough to vote for him over the man who defeated him. He was a type of Democrat we don't get today. Someone who didn't just believe government could work, but who actually made it work.