SOVIET POLITBURO Survivor - GORBACHEV is a survivor
       |           

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?
April 26, 2024, 12:24:50 PM
News: Election Simulator 2.0 Released. Senate/Gubernatorial maps, proportional electoral votes, and more - Read more

  Talk Elections
  Election Archive
  Election Archive
  Survivor
  SOVIET POLITBURO Survivor - GORBACHEV is a survivor
« previous next »
Pages: 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 [9]
Author Topic: SOVIET POLITBURO Survivor - GORBACHEV is a survivor  (Read 79953 times)
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #200 on: July 26, 2010, 05:03:48 AM »



"Bolsheviks"Sad
Vladimir Ulyanov LENIN (1917-1924)
Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY (1917-1926)
Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ (1919-1946)
Yakov SVERDLOV (1918-1919)
Yelena STASOVA (1917-1918, 1919)
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY (1917-1918, 1920-1921)
Yan RUDZUTAK (1926-1932, 1934-1938)
Stanislav KOSIOR (1927-1939)
Vlas CHUBAR (1926-1938)

"Open bolsheviks"Sad
Lev Rozenfeld KAMENEV (1917-1926)
Grigoriy Radomyslskiy ZINOVYEV (1917-1926)
Nikolay BUKHARIN (1917-1929)
Aleksey RYKOV (1922-1930)
Mikhail TOMSKIY (1922-1930)
Nikolay KRESTINSKIY (1917-1921)
Mikhail FRUNZE (1924-1925)
Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV (1917-1919)
Karl RADEK (-)
Mikhail TUKHACHEVSKIY (-)

"Stalinists"Sad
Iosif Dzhugashvili STALIN (1917-1953)
Vyacheslav Skryabin MOLOTOV (1921-1957)
Kliment VOROSHILOV (1926-1960)
Lazar KAGANOVICH (1926-1957)
Feliks DZERZHINSKIY (1918-1919, 1924-1926)
Andrey ZHDANOV (1935-1948)
Nikolay YEZHOV (1937-1938)
Andrey ANDREYEV (1926-1930, 1932-1952)
Lavrentiy BERIYA (1939-1953)
Andrey VYSHINSKIY (1952-1953)
Pavel POSTYSHEV (1934-1938)
Genrikh YAGODA (-)

"Open stalinists"Sad
Georgiy MALENKOV (1941-1957)
Nikolay BULGANIN (1946-1958)
Anastas MIKOYAN (1926-1966)
Dmitriy SHEPILOV (1956-1957)
Sergey Kostrikov KIROV (1926-1934)
Maksim SABUROV (1952-1957)
Mikhail PERVUKHIN (1952-1961)
Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY (1941-1949)
Georgiy ZHUKOV (1956-1957)
Grigori Sergo ORDZHONIKIDZE (1930-1937)
Valerian KUYBYSHEV (1927-1935)

"Brezhnevians"Sad
Leonid BREZHNEV (1952-1953, 1957-1982)
Konstantin CHERNENKO (1977-1985)
Nikolay TIKHONOV (1978-1985)
Andrey GROMYKO (1973-1988)
Vasiliy KUZNETSOV (1952-1953, 1977-1986)
Mikhail SUSLOV (1952-1953, 1955-1982)
Dmitriy USTINOV (1965-1984)
Andrey GRECHKO (1973-1976)
Vladimir SHCHERBITSKIY (1961-1963, 1965-1989)
Viktor GRISHIN (1961-1986)
Sharaf RASHIDOV (1961-1983)
Boris PONOMAREV (1972-1986)

"Modern conservatives"Sad
Aleksey KOSYGIN (1946-1953, 1957-1980)
Andrey KIRILENKO (1957-1961, 1962-1982)
Grigoriy ROMANOV (1973-1985)
Nikolay RYZHKOV (1985-1990)
Gennadiy YANAYEV (1990-1991)
Anatoliy LUKYANOV (1988-1990)
Yegor LIGACHEV (1985-1990)
Lev ZAYKOV (1986-1990)
Viktor CHEBRIKOV (1983-1989)
Vladimir KRYUCHKOV (1989-1990)
Heidar ALIYEV (1976-1987)
Pyotr SHELEST (1963-1973)
Valentin PAVLOV (-)

"Khrushchevians":
Nikita Sergeyevich KHRUSHCHEV (1938-1964)
Yuriy ANDROPOV (1967-1984)
Nikolay PODGORNIY (1958-1977)
Nikolay SHVERNIK (1939-1966)
Aleksandr SHELEPIN (1964-1975)
Frol KOZLOV (1956-1964)
Fyodor KULAKOV (1971-1978)
Dmitriy POLYANSKIY (1958-1976)
Otto KUUSINEN (1952-1953, 1957-1964)
Mikhail GORBACHEV (1979-1991)
Aleksandr YAKOVLEV (1987-1990)
Eduard SHEVARDNADZE (1978-1990)
Boris YELTSIN (1986-1988)

Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #201 on: July 26, 2010, 05:06:31 AM »

Results:

Round 1:
Kosior 1.67, Lenin 1.33, Trotskiy 1.33, Kalinin 0.67, Sverdlov 0.67, Chubar 0.33
Krestinskiy 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Frunze 1.33, Zinovyev 1.33, Kamenev 0.67, Rykov 0.67, Bukharin 0.33, Sokolnikov 1
Stalin 3.33, Yezhov 1, Postyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Kaganovich 0.33, Yagoda 0.33
Zhukov 1.67 (+ GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.67, Bulganin 1, Malenkov 0.67, Kuybyshev 0.33, Ordzhonikidze 0.33, Shepilov 0.33
Chernenko 2.67, Brezhnev 1.33, Gromyko 0.67, Shcherbitskiy 0.67, Rashidov 0.33, Suslov 0.33
Yanayev 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Aliyev 1.33, Kirilenko 1.33, Kosygin 1.33, Pavlov 0.67, Ryzhkov 0.33
Shvernik 2.67, Polyanskiy 1.67, Khrushchev 0.67, Yeltsin 0.67, Andropov 0.33

Round 2:
Stasova 1.5, Kalinin 1, Troskiy 0.5, Sverdlov 0.5 (-1), Lenin 0.5 (-3)
Zinovyev 1.5, Frunze 1 (-1), Kamenev 1 (-1), Sokolnikov 0.5, Radek 0 (-1)
Yezhov 1.5, Postyshev 1, Beriya 1 (-1), Yagoda 0.5 (-1), Dzerzhinskiy 0 (-1), Zhdanov 0 (-1)
Saburov 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.5 (-1), Kuybyshev 0.5, Voznesenskiy 0.5, Kirov 0 (-1), Ordzhonikidze 0 (-1)
Shcherbitskiy 1 (0), Rashidov 1 (-1), Grechko 0.5, Gromyko 0.5, Brezhnev 0.5 (-1), Tikhonov 0.5 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1)
Aliyev 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Kirilenko 1.5 (-1), Pavlov 1 (-2)
Polyanskiy 2, Khrushchev 1 (-1), Kuusinen 0.5, Shelepin 0.5, Yakovlev 0 (-1), Andropov 0 (-2)

Round 3:
Sverdlov 3, Kalinin 1, Lenin 1
Kamenev 3, Frunze 2
Beriya 1, Kaganovich 1, Postyshev 1, Yagoda 1
Mikoyan 3, Shepilov 1, Voznesensky 1
Brezhnev 2 (1.83 previous vote), Rashidov 2 (1.33 previous vote), Gromyko 1
Pavlov 3, Kirilenko 2
Khrushchev 2, Gorbachev 1, Kuusinen 1, Shelepin 1

Round 4:
Kalinin 1.6, Chubar 1, Trotskiy 0.8, Lenin 0.6
Frunze 1.4 (4.33 previous votes), Sokolnikov 1.4 (1.5 previous votes), Radek 1, Tukhachevskiy 0.2
Yagoda 1.4, Kaganovich 1.2, Postyshev 0.8, Vyshinskiy 0.4, Zhdanov 0.2
Voznesesnkiy 1.2, Ordzhonikidze 0.8, Shepilov 0.8, Pervukhin 0.6, Malenkov 0.4, Kuybyshev 0.2
Tikhonov 1.4, Rashidov 1.2, Kuznetsov 0.6, Grechko 0.4, Gromyko 0.4
Kryuchkov 1.6, Kirilenko 0.8, Romanov 0.8, Chebrikov 0.6, Kosygin 0.2
Kuusinen 1.4, Kozlov 1.2, Podgorniy 1, Shelepin 0.4

Round 5:
Trotskiy 3, Lenin 2
Sokolnikov 1
Postyshev 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Shepilov 1 (2.13 previous votes), Malenkov 1 (1.07 previous vote)
Rashidov 2 (4.53 previous votes), Grechko 2 (0.9 previous vote)
Chebrikov 4, Romanov 3
Shelepin 2 (1.9 previous vote), Kozlov 2 (1.2 previous vote)

Round 6:
Lenin 2
Radek 2, Bukharin 1, Rykov 1
Vyshinskiy 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Pervukhin 2, Malenkov 1
Kuznetsov 2, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1
Romanov 4, Zaykov 2, Kirilenko 1
Kozlov 2, Podgorniy 1

Round 7:
Chubar 2.5, Preobrazhenskiy 1.25, Rudzutak 0.25
Bukharin 2, Rykov 1.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.75
Kaganovich 2.25, Andreyev 0.75, Dzerzhinskiy 0.75, Molotov 0.25
Bulganin 3, Malenkov 1
Ustinov 1.75, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1, Suslov 0.25
Kirilenko 1.5, Kosygin 1.25, Zaykov 1, Shelest 0.25
Podgorniy 2.5, Shevardnadze 0.75, Yeltsin 0.75

Round 8:
Andreyev 0.5, Zaykov 0.5, Grechko 0.33 (4.9 previous votes), Gromyko 0.33 (4.57 previous votes), Malenkov 0.33 (4.07 previous votes), Preobrazhenskiy 0.33 (1.25 previous vote), Molotov 0.33 (0.25 previous vote), Dzerzhinskiy 0.17, Zhdanov 0.17

Round 9:
Kosygin 0.5, Malenkov 0.5, Preobrazhenskiy 0.5, Tomskiy 0.17, Voroshilov 0.17, Zhdanov 0.17, Dzerzhinskiy 0.17 (-1), Molotov 0.17 (-1), Yeltsin 0 (-1), Grishin -0.17 (-1), Lukyanov -0.17 (-1), Shevardnadze -0.17 (-1), Suslov -0.17 (-1), Tukhachevskiy -0.17 (-2)

Round 10:
Dzerzhinskiy 0.5 (5.75 previous votes), Zhdanov 0.5 (1.04 previous vote), Molotov 0.5 (0.92 previous vote), Tomskiy 0.5 (0.17 previous vote), Gorbachev 0.25, Kirov 0.25, Kulakov 0.25, Ordzhonikidze 0.25, Ponomarev 0.25, Rykov 0.25, Suslov 0.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.25

Round 11:
Ordzhonikidze 1.33, Molotov 1, Rudzutak 0.5, Yeltsin 0.5, Tomskiy 0.33, Voroshilov 0.33

Round 12:
Tomskiy 0.5, Molotov 0 (-2), Rudzutak 0 (-2), Gorbachev 0 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1), Yeltsin 0 (-1), Kirov -0.5 (-1)

Round 13:
Suslov 3, Molotov 2

Round 14: bring back round
Lenin 13 (7 handicap points), Beriya 7 (10 handicap points), Brezhnev 5, Dzerzhinskiy 5, Shelepin 5, Suslov 5, Trotskiy 2, Kozlov 1, Stalin 1

Round 15:
Rudzutak 1.33 (0.75 previous vote), Ponomarev 1.33 (0.25 previous vote), Kuybyshev 1, Molotov 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Lenin 0.33

Round 16:
Ponomarev 1.1, Beriya 0.8, Molotov 0.8, Kuybyshev 0.4, Voroshilov 0.4, Kirov 0.2, Lenin 0.2, Rykov 0.1

Round 17:
Voroshilov 1, Kuybyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33 (-2), Grishin 0.33, Yeltsin 0.33, Molotov 0 (-2), , Lenin 0 (-1)

Round 18:
Grishin 1.5, Kuybyshev 1, Molotov 1, Yeltsin 0.5

Round 19:
Beriya 1 (10 handicap points), Molotov 1 (7.56 previous points), Kuybyshev 0.7, Lenin 0.4, Gorbachev 0.3, Yeltsin 0.3, Ryzhkov 0.2, Tukhachevskiy 0.1

Round 20:
Yeltsin 0.5, Molotov 0 (-2), Lenin -0.5 (-2)

Round 21:
Molotov 1, Ligachev 0.87, Kuybyshev 0.75, Lukyanov 0.75, Lenin 0.5, Tukhachevskiy 0.5, Kulakov 0.37, Kirov 0.25

Round 22:
Ligachev 1.5, Lenin 1, Kuybyshev 0.75, Tukhachevskiy 0.75, Kirov 0.25, Lukyanov 0.25, Rykov 0.25, Ryzhkov 0.25

Round 23:
Tukhachevskiy 3, Kuybyshev 2

Round 24:
Kuybyshev 1.4, Kirov 0.8, Rykov 0.8, Ryzhkov 0.8, Kulakov 0.2, Lenin 0.4, Lukyanov 0.4

Round 25:
Rykov 2, Lenin 1.67, Kulakov 1, Lukyanov 0.33

Round 26:
Ryzhkov 2, Kirov 1.5, Lenin 0.5 (-2), Lukyanov -1.5 (-3)

Round 27:
Kirov 1.8, Lenin 1.2, Lukyanov 0.8, Shelest 0.6, Gorbachev 0.4, Andropov 0.2

Round 28:
Lenin 4

Round 29:
Shelest 2, Lukyanov 1.5, Kulakov 1, Shevardnadze 0.5

Round 30:
Lukyanov 2.5 (3 negative votes), Shevardnadze -0.5 (1 negative vote), Andropov -0.5, Kulakov -0.5, Gorbachev -1 (1 negative vote)

Round 31:
Kulakov 1.2, Andropov 1, Shevardnadze 1, Gorbachev 0.4, Yakovlev 0.4

Rules are different in each round: please read the rules before voting.
The Politburo member who receives the biggest total of votes or points is purged.
In case of a tie, the Politburo member who has received the biggest total of previous votes is purged.
In case of a new tie, I, GenSek of this survivor, decide who is purged.

ROUND 32 IS OPEN !

Beware !In this round, you vote to eliminate 1 Politburo member and to keep 1 other member.
The Politburo member who receive the biggest total of points will be eliminated.

Beware !
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #202 on: July 26, 2010, 05:12:15 AM »

From a moral viewpoint, this is fine that Kulakov is ousted now, but, well, he was the last "failed" potential number 1. And you know now that I like them: Kirov, Beria, Shelepin, Suslov, Kirilenko, Romanov...
He was doomed by very bad harvests of the mid-1970s, but, more importantly, he... died too early.
He was more a modern brezhnevian than a real khrushchevian, but Andropov too and my category is of course artificial.
But he had one very important role: by dying, he allowed the young first secretary of the PC of the oblast of Stavropol to rise in the secretariat... Gorby began to emerge !

Well, now that my "dark" favourites are out, let"s go for a more classical and "moral" vote and let's kill Andropov, Hungary's butcher, Afghanistan hawk (contrary to the legend he managed to spread, it was him -and the "political" Brezhnevians-, not the Brezhnevians from the military apparatus, who pleaded for this action), failed modernizer.

Eliminate ANDROPOV

Keep GORBACHEV
Logged
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,329
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #203 on: July 26, 2010, 09:07:33 AM »

Eliminate ANDROPOV

Keep GORBACHEV
Logged
Hans-im-Glück
Franken
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,970
Germany


Political Matrix
E: -5.94, S: -3.30

Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #204 on: July 26, 2010, 11:46:20 AM »

Eliminate SHEVARDNADZE

Keep ANDROPOV
Logged
Edu
Ufokart
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,870
Argentina


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #205 on: July 26, 2010, 12:08:57 PM »

Eliminate Eduard SHEVARDNADZE
Keep Yuriy ANDROPOV
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #206 on: July 27, 2010, 05:51:09 AM »



"Bolsheviks"Sad
Vladimir Ulyanov LENIN (1917-1924)
Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY (1917-1926)
Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ (1919-1946)
Yakov SVERDLOV (1918-1919)
Yelena STASOVA (1917-1918, 1919)
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY (1917-1918, 1920-1921)
Yan RUDZUTAK (1926-1932, 1934-1938)
Stanislav KOSIOR (1927-1939)
Vlas CHUBAR (1926-1938)

"Open bolsheviks"Sad
Lev Rozenfeld KAMENEV (1917-1926)
Grigoriy Radomyslskiy ZINOVYEV (1917-1926)
Nikolay BUKHARIN (1917-1929)
Aleksey RYKOV (1922-1930)
Mikhail TOMSKIY (1922-1930)
Nikolay KRESTINSKIY (1917-1921)
Mikhail FRUNZE (1924-1925)
Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV (1917-1919)
Karl RADEK (-)
Mikhail TUKHACHEVSKIY (-)

"Stalinists"Sad
Iosif Dzhugashvili STALIN (1917-1953)
Vyacheslav Skryabin MOLOTOV (1921-1957)
Kliment VOROSHILOV (1926-1960)
Lazar KAGANOVICH (1926-1957)
Feliks DZERZHINSKIY (1918-1919, 1924-1926)
Andrey ZHDANOV (1935-1948)
Nikolay YEZHOV (1937-1938)
Andrey ANDREYEV (1926-1930, 1932-1952)
Lavrentiy BERIYA (1939-1953)
Andrey VYSHINSKIY (1952-1953)
Pavel POSTYSHEV (1934-1938)
Genrikh YAGODA (-)

"Open stalinists"Sad
Georgiy MALENKOV (1941-1957)
Nikolay BULGANIN (1946-1958)
Anastas MIKOYAN (1926-1966)
Dmitriy SHEPILOV (1956-1957)
Sergey Kostrikov KIROV (1926-1934)
Maksim SABUROV (1952-1957)
Mikhail PERVUKHIN (1952-1961)
Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY (1941-1949)
Georgiy ZHUKOV (1956-1957)
Grigori Sergo ORDZHONIKIDZE (1930-1937)
Valerian KUYBYSHEV (1927-1935)

"Brezhnevians"Sad
Leonid BREZHNEV (1952-1953, 1957-1982)
Konstantin CHERNENKO (1977-1985)
Nikolay TIKHONOV (1978-1985)
Andrey GROMYKO (1973-1988)
Vasiliy KUZNETSOV (1952-1953, 1977-1986)
Mikhail SUSLOV (1952-1953, 1955-1982)
Dmitriy USTINOV (1965-1984)
Andrey GRECHKO (1973-1976)
Vladimir SHCHERBITSKIY (1961-1963, 1965-1989)
Viktor GRISHIN (1961-1986)
Sharaf RASHIDOV (1961-1983)
Boris PONOMAREV (1972-1986)

"Modern conservatives"Sad
Aleksey KOSYGIN (1946-1953, 1957-1980)
Andrey KIRILENKO (1957-1961, 1962-1982)
Grigoriy ROMANOV (1973-1985)
Nikolay RYZHKOV (1985-1990)
Gennadiy YANAYEV (1990-1991)
Anatoliy LUKYANOV (1988-1990)
Yegor LIGACHEV (1985-1990)
Lev ZAYKOV (1986-1990)
Viktor CHEBRIKOV (1983-1989)
Vladimir KRYUCHKOV (1989-1990)
Heidar ALIYEV (1976-1987)
Pyotr SHELEST (1963-1973)
Valentin PAVLOV (-)

"Khrushchevians":
Nikita Sergeyevich KHRUSHCHEV (1938-1964)
Yuriy ANDROPOV (1967-1984)
Nikolay PODGORNIY (1958-1977)
Nikolay SHVERNIK (1939-1966)
Aleksandr SHELEPIN (1964-1975)
Frol KOZLOV (1956-1964)
Fyodor KULAKOV (1971-1978)
Dmitriy POLYANSKIY (1958-1976)
Otto KUUSINEN (1952-1953, 1957-1964)
Mikhail GORBACHEV (1979-1991)
Aleksandr YAKOVLEV (1987-1990)
Eduard SHEVARDNADZE (1978-1990)
Boris YELTSIN (1986-1988)
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #207 on: July 27, 2010, 05:54:54 AM »

Results:

Round 1:
Kosior 1.67, Lenin 1.33, Trotskiy 1.33, Kalinin 0.67, Sverdlov 0.67, Chubar 0.33
Krestinskiy 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Frunze 1.33, Zinovyev 1.33, Kamenev 0.67, Rykov 0.67, Bukharin 0.33, Sokolnikov 1
Stalin 3.33, Yezhov 1, Postyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Kaganovich 0.33, Yagoda 0.33
Zhukov 1.67 (+ GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.67, Bulganin 1, Malenkov 0.67, Kuybyshev 0.33, Ordzhonikidze 0.33, Shepilov 0.33
Chernenko 2.67, Brezhnev 1.33, Gromyko 0.67, Shcherbitskiy 0.67, Rashidov 0.33, Suslov 0.33
Yanayev 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Aliyev 1.33, Kirilenko 1.33, Kosygin 1.33, Pavlov 0.67, Ryzhkov 0.33
Shvernik 2.67, Polyanskiy 1.67, Khrushchev 0.67, Yeltsin 0.67, Andropov 0.33

Round 2:
Stasova 1.5, Kalinin 1, Troskiy 0.5, Sverdlov 0.5 (-1), Lenin 0.5 (-3)
Zinovyev 1.5, Frunze 1 (-1), Kamenev 1 (-1), Sokolnikov 0.5, Radek 0 (-1)
Yezhov 1.5, Postyshev 1, Beriya 1 (-1), Yagoda 0.5 (-1), Dzerzhinskiy 0 (-1), Zhdanov 0 (-1)
Saburov 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.5 (-1), Kuybyshev 0.5, Voznesenskiy 0.5, Kirov 0 (-1), Ordzhonikidze 0 (-1)
Shcherbitskiy 1 (0), Rashidov 1 (-1), Grechko 0.5, Gromyko 0.5, Brezhnev 0.5 (-1), Tikhonov 0.5 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1)
Aliyev 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Kirilenko 1.5 (-1), Pavlov 1 (-2)
Polyanskiy 2, Khrushchev 1 (-1), Kuusinen 0.5, Shelepin 0.5, Yakovlev 0 (-1), Andropov 0 (-2)

Round 3:
Sverdlov 3, Kalinin 1, Lenin 1
Kamenev 3, Frunze 2
Beriya 1, Kaganovich 1, Postyshev 1, Yagoda 1
Mikoyan 3, Shepilov 1, Voznesensky 1
Brezhnev 2 (1.83 previous vote), Rashidov 2 (1.33 previous vote), Gromyko 1
Pavlov 3, Kirilenko 2
Khrushchev 2, Gorbachev 1, Kuusinen 1, Shelepin 1

Round 4:
Kalinin 1.6, Chubar 1, Trotskiy 0.8, Lenin 0.6
Frunze 1.4 (4.33 previous votes), Sokolnikov 1.4 (1.5 previous votes), Radek 1, Tukhachevskiy 0.2
Yagoda 1.4, Kaganovich 1.2, Postyshev 0.8, Vyshinskiy 0.4, Zhdanov 0.2
Voznesesnkiy 1.2, Ordzhonikidze 0.8, Shepilov 0.8, Pervukhin 0.6, Malenkov 0.4, Kuybyshev 0.2
Tikhonov 1.4, Rashidov 1.2, Kuznetsov 0.6, Grechko 0.4, Gromyko 0.4
Kryuchkov 1.6, Kirilenko 0.8, Romanov 0.8, Chebrikov 0.6, Kosygin 0.2
Kuusinen 1.4, Kozlov 1.2, Podgorniy 1, Shelepin 0.4

Round 5:
Trotskiy 3, Lenin 2
Sokolnikov 1
Postyshev 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Shepilov 1 (2.13 previous votes), Malenkov 1 (1.07 previous vote)
Rashidov 2 (4.53 previous votes), Grechko 2 (0.9 previous vote)
Chebrikov 4, Romanov 3
Shelepin 2 (1.9 previous vote), Kozlov 2 (1.2 previous vote)

Round 6:
Lenin 2
Radek 2, Bukharin 1, Rykov 1
Vyshinskiy 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Pervukhin 2, Malenkov 1
Kuznetsov 2, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1
Romanov 4, Zaykov 2, Kirilenko 1
Kozlov 2, Podgorniy 1

Round 7:
Chubar 2.5, Preobrazhenskiy 1.25, Rudzutak 0.25
Bukharin 2, Rykov 1.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.75
Kaganovich 2.25, Andreyev 0.75, Dzerzhinskiy 0.75, Molotov 0.25
Bulganin 3, Malenkov 1
Ustinov 1.75, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1, Suslov 0.25
Kirilenko 1.5, Kosygin 1.25, Zaykov 1, Shelest 0.25
Podgorniy 2.5, Shevardnadze 0.75, Yeltsin 0.75

Round 8:
Andreyev 0.5, Zaykov 0.5, Grechko 0.33 (4.9 previous votes), Gromyko 0.33 (4.57 previous votes), Malenkov 0.33 (4.07 previous votes), Preobrazhenskiy 0.33 (1.25 previous vote), Molotov 0.33 (0.25 previous vote), Dzerzhinskiy 0.17, Zhdanov 0.17

Round 9:
Kosygin 0.5, Malenkov 0.5, Preobrazhenskiy 0.5, Tomskiy 0.17, Voroshilov 0.17, Zhdanov 0.17, Dzerzhinskiy 0.17 (-1), Molotov 0.17 (-1), Yeltsin 0 (-1), Grishin -0.17 (-1), Lukyanov -0.17 (-1), Shevardnadze -0.17 (-1), Suslov -0.17 (-1), Tukhachevskiy -0.17 (-2)

Round 10:
Dzerzhinskiy 0.5 (5.75 previous votes), Zhdanov 0.5 (1.04 previous vote), Molotov 0.5 (0.92 previous vote), Tomskiy 0.5 (0.17 previous vote), Gorbachev 0.25, Kirov 0.25, Kulakov 0.25, Ordzhonikidze 0.25, Ponomarev 0.25, Rykov 0.25, Suslov 0.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.25

Round 11:
Ordzhonikidze 1.33, Molotov 1, Rudzutak 0.5, Yeltsin 0.5, Tomskiy 0.33, Voroshilov 0.33

Round 12:
Tomskiy 0.5, Molotov 0 (-2), Rudzutak 0 (-2), Gorbachev 0 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1), Yeltsin 0 (-1), Kirov -0.5 (-1)

Round 13:
Suslov 3, Molotov 2

Round 14: bring back round
Lenin 13 (7 handicap points), Beriya 7 (10 handicap points), Brezhnev 5, Dzerzhinskiy 5, Shelepin 5, Suslov 5, Trotskiy 2, Kozlov 1, Stalin 1

Round 15:
Rudzutak 1.33 (0.75 previous vote), Ponomarev 1.33 (0.25 previous vote), Kuybyshev 1, Molotov 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Lenin 0.33

Round 16:
Ponomarev 1.1, Beriya 0.8, Molotov 0.8, Kuybyshev 0.4, Voroshilov 0.4, Kirov 0.2, Lenin 0.2, Rykov 0.1

Round 17:
Voroshilov 1, Kuybyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33 (-2), Grishin 0.33, Yeltsin 0.33, Molotov 0 (-2), , Lenin 0 (-1)

Round 18:
Grishin 1.5, Kuybyshev 1, Molotov 1, Yeltsin 0.5

Round 19:
Beriya 1 (10 handicap points), Molotov 1 (7.56 previous points), Kuybyshev 0.7, Lenin 0.4, Gorbachev 0.3, Yeltsin 0.3, Ryzhkov 0.2, Tukhachevskiy 0.1

Round 20:
Yeltsin 0.5, Molotov 0 (-2), Lenin -0.5 (-2)

Round 21:
Molotov 1, Ligachev 0.87, Kuybyshev 0.75, Lukyanov 0.75, Lenin 0.5, Tukhachevskiy 0.5, Kulakov 0.37, Kirov 0.25

Round 22:
Ligachev 1.5, Lenin 1, Kuybyshev 0.75, Tukhachevskiy 0.75, Kirov 0.25, Lukyanov 0.25, Rykov 0.25, Ryzhkov 0.25

Round 23:
Tukhachevskiy 3, Kuybyshev 2

Round 24:
Kuybyshev 1.4, Kirov 0.8, Rykov 0.8, Ryzhkov 0.8, Kulakov 0.2, Lenin 0.4, Lukyanov 0.4

Round 25:
Rykov 2, Lenin 1.67, Kulakov 1, Lukyanov 0.33

Round 26:
Ryzhkov 2, Kirov 1.5, Lenin 0.5 (-2), Lukyanov -1.5 (-3)

Round 27:
Kirov 1.8, Lenin 1.2, Lukyanov 0.8, Shelest 0.6, Gorbachev 0.4, Andropov 0.2

Round 28:
Lenin 4

Round 29:
Shelest 2, Lukyanov 1.5, Kulakov 1, Shevardnadze 0.5

Round 30:
Lukyanov 2.5 (3 negative votes), Shevardnadze -0.5 (1 negative vote), Andropov -0.5, Kulakov -0.5, Gorbachev -1 (1 negative vote)

Round 31:
Kulakov 1.2, Andropov 1, Shevardnadze 1, Gorbachev 0.4, Yakovlev 0.4

Round 32:
Shevardnadze 2, Andropov 0, Gorbachev -2

Rules are different in each round: please read the rules before voting.
The Politburo member who receives the biggest total of votes or points is purged.
In case of a tie, the Politburo member who has received the biggest total of previous votes is purged.
In case of a new tie, I, GenSek of this survivor, decide who is purged.

ROUND 33 IS OPEN !

Beware !In this round, you vote to eliminate 2 Politburo members.
The Politburo member who receive the biggest total of points will be eliminated.

Beware !
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #208 on: July 27, 2010, 05:56:47 AM »

Until the end, it's difficult for me... Wink

Well, with this outrageous rule at this stage:

ANDROPOV
YAKOVLEV
Logged
Hans-im-Glück
Franken
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,970
Germany


Political Matrix
E: -5.94, S: -3.30

Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #209 on: July 27, 2010, 09:05:17 AM »

GORBACHEV
YAKOVLEV
Logged
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,329
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #210 on: July 27, 2010, 09:45:47 AM »

Until the end, it's difficult for me... Wink

Well, with this outrageous rule at this stage:

ANDROPOV
YAKOVLEV
Logged
Edu
Ufokart
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,870
Argentina


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #211 on: July 27, 2010, 02:05:09 PM »

Yuriy ANDROPOV
Mikhail GORBACHEV
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #212 on: July 28, 2010, 04:24:28 AM »



"Bolsheviks"Sad
Vladimir Ulyanov LENIN (1917-1924)
Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY (1917-1926)
Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ (1919-1946)
Yakov SVERDLOV (1918-1919)
Yelena STASOVA (1917-1918, 1919)
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY (1917-1918, 1920-1921)
Yan RUDZUTAK (1926-1932, 1934-1938)
Stanislav KOSIOR (1927-1939)
Vlas CHUBAR (1926-1938)

"Open bolsheviks"Sad
Lev Rozenfeld KAMENEV (1917-1926)
Grigoriy Radomyslskiy ZINOVYEV (1917-1926)
Nikolay BUKHARIN (1917-1929)
Aleksey RYKOV (1922-1930)
Mikhail TOMSKIY (1922-1930)
Nikolay KRESTINSKIY (1917-1921)
Mikhail FRUNZE (1924-1925)
Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV (1917-1919)
Karl RADEK (-)
Mikhail TUKHACHEVSKIY (-)

"Stalinists"Sad
Iosif Dzhugashvili STALIN (1917-1953)
Vyacheslav Skryabin MOLOTOV (1921-1957)
Kliment VOROSHILOV (1926-1960)
Lazar KAGANOVICH (1926-1957)
Feliks DZERZHINSKIY (1918-1919, 1924-1926)
Andrey ZHDANOV (1935-1948)
Nikolay YEZHOV (1937-1938)
Andrey ANDREYEV (1926-1930, 1932-1952)
Lavrentiy BERIYA (1939-1953)
Andrey VYSHINSKIY (1952-1953)
Pavel POSTYSHEV (1934-1938)
Genrikh YAGODA (-)

"Open stalinists"Sad
Georgiy MALENKOV (1941-1957)
Nikolay BULGANIN (1946-1958)
Anastas MIKOYAN (1926-1966)
Dmitriy SHEPILOV (1956-1957)
Sergey Kostrikov KIROV (1926-1934)
Maksim SABUROV (1952-1957)
Mikhail PERVUKHIN (1952-1961)
Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY (1941-1949)
Georgiy ZHUKOV (1956-1957)
Grigori Sergo ORDZHONIKIDZE (1930-1937)
Valerian KUYBYSHEV (1927-1935)

"Brezhnevians"Sad
Leonid BREZHNEV (1952-1953, 1957-1982)
Konstantin CHERNENKO (1977-1985)
Nikolay TIKHONOV (1978-1985)
Andrey GROMYKO (1973-1988)
Vasiliy KUZNETSOV (1952-1953, 1977-1986)
Mikhail SUSLOV (1952-1953, 1955-1982)
Dmitriy USTINOV (1965-1984)
Andrey GRECHKO (1973-1976)
Vladimir SHCHERBITSKIY (1961-1963, 1965-1989)
Viktor GRISHIN (1961-1986)
Sharaf RASHIDOV (1961-1983)
Boris PONOMAREV (1972-1986)

"Modern conservatives"Sad
Aleksey KOSYGIN (1946-1953, 1957-1980)
Andrey KIRILENKO (1957-1961, 1962-1982)
Grigoriy ROMANOV (1973-1985)
Nikolay RYZHKOV (1985-1990)
Gennadiy YANAYEV (1990-1991)
Anatoliy LUKYANOV (1988-1990)
Yegor LIGACHEV (1985-1990)
Lev ZAYKOV (1986-1990)
Viktor CHEBRIKOV (1983-1989)
Vladimir KRYUCHKOV (1989-1990)
Heidar ALIYEV (1976-1987)
Pyotr SHELEST (1963-1973)
Valentin PAVLOV (-)

"Khrushchevians":
Nikita Sergeyevich KHRUSHCHEV (1938-1964)
Yuriy ANDROPOV (1967-1984)
Nikolay PODGORNIY (1958-1977)
Nikolay SHVERNIK (1939-1966)
Aleksandr SHELEPIN (1964-1975)
Frol KOZLOV (1956-1964)
Fyodor KULAKOV (1971-1978)
Dmitriy POLYANSKIY (1958-1976)
Otto KUUSINEN (1952-1953, 1957-1964)
Mikhail GORBACHEV (1979-1991)
Aleksandr YAKOVLEV (1987-1990)
Eduard SHEVARDNADZE (1978-1990)
Boris YELTSIN (1986-1988)
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #213 on: July 28, 2010, 04:28:08 AM »

Results:

Round 1:
Kosior 1.67, Lenin 1.33, Trotskiy 1.33, Kalinin 0.67, Sverdlov 0.67, Chubar 0.33
Krestinskiy 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Frunze 1.33, Zinovyev 1.33, Kamenev 0.67, Rykov 0.67, Bukharin 0.33, Sokolnikov 1
Stalin 3.33, Yezhov 1, Postyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Kaganovich 0.33, Yagoda 0.33
Zhukov 1.67 (+ GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.67, Bulganin 1, Malenkov 0.67, Kuybyshev 0.33, Ordzhonikidze 0.33, Shepilov 0.33
Chernenko 2.67, Brezhnev 1.33, Gromyko 0.67, Shcherbitskiy 0.67, Rashidov 0.33, Suslov 0.33
Yanayev 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Aliyev 1.33, Kirilenko 1.33, Kosygin 1.33, Pavlov 0.67, Ryzhkov 0.33
Shvernik 2.67, Polyanskiy 1.67, Khrushchev 0.67, Yeltsin 0.67, Andropov 0.33

Round 2:
Stasova 1.5, Kalinin 1, Troskiy 0.5, Sverdlov 0.5 (-1), Lenin 0.5 (-3)
Zinovyev 1.5, Frunze 1 (-1), Kamenev 1 (-1), Sokolnikov 0.5, Radek 0 (-1)
Yezhov 1.5, Postyshev 1, Beriya 1 (-1), Yagoda 0.5 (-1), Dzerzhinskiy 0 (-1), Zhdanov 0 (-1)
Saburov 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.5 (-1), Kuybyshev 0.5, Voznesenskiy 0.5, Kirov 0 (-1), Ordzhonikidze 0 (-1)
Shcherbitskiy 1 (0), Rashidov 1 (-1), Grechko 0.5, Gromyko 0.5, Brezhnev 0.5 (-1), Tikhonov 0.5 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1)
Aliyev 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Kirilenko 1.5 (-1), Pavlov 1 (-2)
Polyanskiy 2, Khrushchev 1 (-1), Kuusinen 0.5, Shelepin 0.5, Yakovlev 0 (-1), Andropov 0 (-2)

Round 3:
Sverdlov 3, Kalinin 1, Lenin 1
Kamenev 3, Frunze 2
Beriya 1, Kaganovich 1, Postyshev 1, Yagoda 1
Mikoyan 3, Shepilov 1, Voznesensky 1
Brezhnev 2 (1.83 previous vote), Rashidov 2 (1.33 previous vote), Gromyko 1
Pavlov 3, Kirilenko 2
Khrushchev 2, Gorbachev 1, Kuusinen 1, Shelepin 1

Round 4:
Kalinin 1.6, Chubar 1, Trotskiy 0.8, Lenin 0.6
Frunze 1.4 (4.33 previous votes), Sokolnikov 1.4 (1.5 previous votes), Radek 1, Tukhachevskiy 0.2
Yagoda 1.4, Kaganovich 1.2, Postyshev 0.8, Vyshinskiy 0.4, Zhdanov 0.2
Voznesesnkiy 1.2, Ordzhonikidze 0.8, Shepilov 0.8, Pervukhin 0.6, Malenkov 0.4, Kuybyshev 0.2
Tikhonov 1.4, Rashidov 1.2, Kuznetsov 0.6, Grechko 0.4, Gromyko 0.4
Kryuchkov 1.6, Kirilenko 0.8, Romanov 0.8, Chebrikov 0.6, Kosygin 0.2
Kuusinen 1.4, Kozlov 1.2, Podgorniy 1, Shelepin 0.4

Round 5:
Trotskiy 3, Lenin 2
Sokolnikov 1
Postyshev 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Shepilov 1 (2.13 previous votes), Malenkov 1 (1.07 previous vote)
Rashidov 2 (4.53 previous votes), Grechko 2 (0.9 previous vote)
Chebrikov 4, Romanov 3
Shelepin 2 (1.9 previous vote), Kozlov 2 (1.2 previous vote)

Round 6:
Lenin 2
Radek 2, Bukharin 1, Rykov 1
Vyshinskiy 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Pervukhin 2, Malenkov 1
Kuznetsov 2, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1
Romanov 4, Zaykov 2, Kirilenko 1
Kozlov 2, Podgorniy 1

Round 7:
Chubar 2.5, Preobrazhenskiy 1.25, Rudzutak 0.25
Bukharin 2, Rykov 1.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.75
Kaganovich 2.25, Andreyev 0.75, Dzerzhinskiy 0.75, Molotov 0.25
Bulganin 3, Malenkov 1
Ustinov 1.75, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1, Suslov 0.25
Kirilenko 1.5, Kosygin 1.25, Zaykov 1, Shelest 0.25
Podgorniy 2.5, Shevardnadze 0.75, Yeltsin 0.75

Round 8:
Andreyev 0.5, Zaykov 0.5, Grechko 0.33 (4.9 previous votes), Gromyko 0.33 (4.57 previous votes), Malenkov 0.33 (4.07 previous votes), Preobrazhenskiy 0.33 (1.25 previous vote), Molotov 0.33 (0.25 previous vote), Dzerzhinskiy 0.17, Zhdanov 0.17

Round 9:
Kosygin 0.5, Malenkov 0.5, Preobrazhenskiy 0.5, Tomskiy 0.17, Voroshilov 0.17, Zhdanov 0.17, Dzerzhinskiy 0.17 (-1), Molotov 0.17 (-1), Yeltsin 0 (-1), Grishin -0.17 (-1), Lukyanov -0.17 (-1), Shevardnadze -0.17 (-1), Suslov -0.17 (-1), Tukhachevskiy -0.17 (-2)

Round 10:
Dzerzhinskiy 0.5 (5.75 previous votes), Zhdanov 0.5 (1.04 previous vote), Molotov 0.5 (0.92 previous vote), Tomskiy 0.5 (0.17 previous vote), Gorbachev 0.25, Kirov 0.25, Kulakov 0.25, Ordzhonikidze 0.25, Ponomarev 0.25, Rykov 0.25, Suslov 0.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.25

Round 11:
Ordzhonikidze 1.33, Molotov 1, Rudzutak 0.5, Yeltsin 0.5, Tomskiy 0.33, Voroshilov 0.33

Round 12:
Tomskiy 0.5, Molotov 0 (-2), Rudzutak 0 (-2), Gorbachev 0 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1), Yeltsin 0 (-1), Kirov -0.5 (-1)

Round 13:
Suslov 3, Molotov 2

Round 14: bring back round
Lenin 13 (7 handicap points), Beriya 7 (10 handicap points), Brezhnev 5, Dzerzhinskiy 5, Shelepin 5, Suslov 5, Trotskiy 2, Kozlov 1, Stalin 1

Round 15:
Rudzutak 1.33 (0.75 previous vote), Ponomarev 1.33 (0.25 previous vote), Kuybyshev 1, Molotov 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Lenin 0.33

Round 16:
Ponomarev 1.1, Beriya 0.8, Molotov 0.8, Kuybyshev 0.4, Voroshilov 0.4, Kirov 0.2, Lenin 0.2, Rykov 0.1

Round 17:
Voroshilov 1, Kuybyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33 (-2), Grishin 0.33, Yeltsin 0.33, Molotov 0 (-2), , Lenin 0 (-1)

Round 18:
Grishin 1.5, Kuybyshev 1, Molotov 1, Yeltsin 0.5

Round 19:
Beriya 1 (10 handicap points), Molotov 1 (7.56 previous points), Kuybyshev 0.7, Lenin 0.4, Gorbachev 0.3, Yeltsin 0.3, Ryzhkov 0.2, Tukhachevskiy 0.1

Round 20:
Yeltsin 0.5, Molotov 0 (-2), Lenin -0.5 (-2)

Round 21:
Molotov 1, Ligachev 0.87, Kuybyshev 0.75, Lukyanov 0.75, Lenin 0.5, Tukhachevskiy 0.5, Kulakov 0.37, Kirov 0.25

Round 22:
Ligachev 1.5, Lenin 1, Kuybyshev 0.75, Tukhachevskiy 0.75, Kirov 0.25, Lukyanov 0.25, Rykov 0.25, Ryzhkov 0.25

Round 23:
Tukhachevskiy 3, Kuybyshev 2

Round 24:
Kuybyshev 1.4, Kirov 0.8, Rykov 0.8, Ryzhkov 0.8, Kulakov 0.2, Lenin 0.4, Lukyanov 0.4

Round 25:
Rykov 2, Lenin 1.67, Kulakov 1, Lukyanov 0.33

Round 26:
Ryzhkov 2, Kirov 1.5, Lenin 0.5 (-2), Lukyanov -1.5 (-3)

Round 27:
Kirov 1.8, Lenin 1.2, Lukyanov 0.8, Shelest 0.6, Gorbachev 0.4, Andropov 0.2

Round 28:
Lenin 4

Round 29:
Shelest 2, Lukyanov 1.5, Kulakov 1, Shevardnadze 0.5

Round 30:
Lukyanov 2.5 (3 negative votes), Shevardnadze -0.5 (1 negative vote), Andropov -0.5, Kulakov -0.5, Gorbachev -1 (1 negative vote)

Round 31:
Kulakov 1.2, Andropov 1, Shevardnadze 1, Gorbachev 0.4, Yakovlev 0.4

Round 32:
Shevardnadze 2, Andropov 0, Gorbachev -2

Round 33:
Andropov 1.5 (1.03 previous points), Yakovlev 1.5 (0.4 previous point), Gorbachev 1

Rules are different in each round: please read the rules before voting.
The Politburo member who receives the biggest total of votes or points is purged.
In case of a tie, the Politburo member who has received the biggest total of previous votes is purged.
In case of a new tie, I, GenSek of this survivor, decide who is purged.

ROUND 34 IS OPEN !

Beware !In this round, you vote to eliminate 1 Politburo member.
The Politburo member who receive the biggest total of points will be eliminated.

Beware !
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #214 on: July 28, 2010, 04:30:37 AM »

Eliminate Yakovlev

Gorbachev for the win


A logical final round, in which I vote for the one who did things, not for the one who thought them.

Gorbachev was the one who took the order to refrain from using force in Eastern and Central Europe and (mostly) onside the USSR.
Logged
Chancellor Tanterterg
Mr. X
Moderators
Atlas Star
*****
Posts: 26,329
United States


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #215 on: July 28, 2010, 10:49:32 AM »

Eliminate Yakovlev

Gorbachev for the win


A logical final round, in which I vote for the one who did things, not for the one who thought them.

Gorbachev was the one who took the order to refrain from using force in Eastern and Central Europe and (mostly) onside the USSR.
Logged
Hans-im-Glück
Franken
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,970
Germany


Political Matrix
E: -5.94, S: -3.30

Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #216 on: July 28, 2010, 11:55:10 AM »

Eliminate Yakovlev

Gorbachev for the win
Logged
Edu
Ufokart
Junior Chimp
*****
Posts: 7,870
Argentina


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #217 on: July 28, 2010, 12:23:08 PM »

Eliminate Mikhail GORBACHEV

Aleksandr YAKOVLEV for Survivor


I must say it was a very interesting and fun survivor this one, thanks fab Smiley
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #218 on: July 29, 2010, 02:48:42 AM »

Eliminate Mikhail GORBACHEV

Aleksandr YAKOVLEV for Survivor


I must say it was a very interesting and fun survivor this one, thanks fab Smiley

Thank you, Edu.
Sorry for having bother you all with my complaints... Wink
It was part of the game !

I plan a similar Chinese one (not before September), but I'm less knowledgeable on the Chinese Politburo, so I'm still hesitating on its size.
Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #219 on: July 29, 2010, 02:50:03 AM »



"Bolsheviks"Sad
Vladimir Ulyanov LENIN (1917-1924)
Lev Bronstein TROTSKIY (1917-1926)
Mikhail Ivanovich KALININ (1919-1946)
Yakov SVERDLOV (1918-1919)
Yelena STASOVA (1917-1918, 1919)
Yevgeniy PREOBRAZHENSKIY (1917-1918, 1920-1921)
Yan RUDZUTAK (1926-1932, 1934-1938)
Stanislav KOSIOR (1927-1939)
Vlas CHUBAR (1926-1938)

"Open bolsheviks"Sad
Lev Rozenfeld KAMENEV (1917-1926)
Grigoriy Radomyslskiy ZINOVYEV (1917-1926)
Nikolay BUKHARIN (1917-1929)
Aleksey RYKOV (1922-1930)
Mikhail TOMSKIY (1922-1930)
Nikolay KRESTINSKIY (1917-1921)
Mikhail FRUNZE (1924-1925)
Grigoriy Brilliant SOKOLNIKOV (1917-1919)
Karl RADEK (-)
Mikhail TUKHACHEVSKIY (-)

"Stalinists"Sad
Iosif Dzhugashvili STALIN (1917-1953)
Vyacheslav Skryabin MOLOTOV (1921-1957)
Kliment VOROSHILOV (1926-1960)
Lazar KAGANOVICH (1926-1957)
Feliks DZERZHINSKIY (1918-1919, 1924-1926)
Andrey ZHDANOV (1935-1948)
Nikolay YEZHOV (1937-1938)
Andrey ANDREYEV (1926-1930, 1932-1952)
Lavrentiy BERIYA (1939-1953)
Andrey VYSHINSKIY (1952-1953)
Pavel POSTYSHEV (1934-1938)
Genrikh YAGODA (-)

"Open stalinists"Sad
Georgiy MALENKOV (1941-1957)
Nikolay BULGANIN (1946-1958)
Anastas MIKOYAN (1926-1966)
Dmitriy SHEPILOV (1956-1957)
Sergey Kostrikov KIROV (1926-1934)
Maksim SABUROV (1952-1957)
Mikhail PERVUKHIN (1952-1961)
Nikolay VOZNESENSKIY (1941-1949)
Georgiy ZHUKOV (1956-1957)
Grigori Sergo ORDZHONIKIDZE (1930-1937)
Valerian KUYBYSHEV (1927-1935)

"Brezhnevians"Sad
Leonid BREZHNEV (1952-1953, 1957-1982)
Konstantin CHERNENKO (1977-1985)
Nikolay TIKHONOV (1978-1985)
Andrey GROMYKO (1973-1988)
Vasiliy KUZNETSOV (1952-1953, 1977-1986)
Mikhail SUSLOV (1952-1953, 1955-1982)
Dmitriy USTINOV (1965-1984)
Andrey GRECHKO (1973-1976)
Vladimir SHCHERBITSKIY (1961-1963, 1965-1989)
Viktor GRISHIN (1961-1986)
Sharaf RASHIDOV (1961-1983)
Boris PONOMAREV (1972-1986)

"Modern conservatives"Sad
Aleksey KOSYGIN (1946-1953, 1957-1980)
Andrey KIRILENKO (1957-1961, 1962-1982)
Grigoriy ROMANOV (1973-1985)
Nikolay RYZHKOV (1985-1990)
Gennadiy YANAYEV (1990-1991)
Anatoliy LUKYANOV (1988-1990)
Yegor LIGACHEV (1985-1990)
Lev ZAYKOV (1986-1990)
Viktor CHEBRIKOV (1983-1989)
Vladimir KRYUCHKOV (1989-1990)
Heidar ALIYEV (1976-1987)
Pyotr SHELEST (1963-1973)
Valentin PAVLOV (-)

"Khrushchevians":
Nikita Sergeyevich KHRUSHCHEV (1938-1964)
Yuriy ANDROPOV (1967-1984)
Nikolay PODGORNIY (1958-1977)
Nikolay SHVERNIK (1939-1966)
Aleksandr SHELEPIN (1964-1975)
Frol KOZLOV (1956-1964)
Fyodor KULAKOV (1971-1978)
Dmitriy POLYANSKIY (1958-1976)
Otto KUUSINEN (1952-1953, 1957-1964)
Mikhail GORBACHEV (1979-1991)
Aleksandr YAKOVLEV (1987-1990)
Eduard SHEVARDNADZE (1978-1990)
Boris YELTSIN (1986-1988)

Logged
big bad fab
filliatre
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 13,344
Ukraine


Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #220 on: July 29, 2010, 02:56:55 AM »

Results:

Round 1:
Kosior 1.67, Lenin 1.33, Trotskiy 1.33, Kalinin 0.67, Sverdlov 0.67, Chubar 0.33
Krestinskiy 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Frunze 1.33, Zinovyev 1.33, Kamenev 0.67, Rykov 0.67, Bukharin 0.33, Sokolnikov 1
Stalin 3.33, Yezhov 1, Postyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Kaganovich 0.33, Yagoda 0.33
Zhukov 1.67 (+ GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.67, Bulganin 1, Malenkov 0.67, Kuybyshev 0.33, Ordzhonikidze 0.33, Shepilov 0.33
Chernenko 2.67, Brezhnev 1.33, Gromyko 0.67, Shcherbitskiy 0.67, Rashidov 0.33, Suslov 0.33
Yanayev 1.33 (+ GenSek's decision), Aliyev 1.33, Kirilenko 1.33, Kosygin 1.33, Pavlov 0.67, Ryzhkov 0.33
Shvernik 2.67, Polyanskiy 1.67, Khrushchev 0.67, Yeltsin 0.67, Andropov 0.33

Round 2:
Stasova 1.5, Kalinin 1, Troskiy 0.5, Sverdlov 0.5 (-1), Lenin 0.5 (-3)
Zinovyev 1.5, Frunze 1 (-1), Kamenev 1 (-1), Sokolnikov 0.5, Radek 0 (-1)
Yezhov 1.5, Postyshev 1, Beriya 1 (-1), Yagoda 0.5 (-1), Dzerzhinskiy 0 (-1), Zhdanov 0 (-1)
Saburov 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Mikoyan 1.5 (-1), Kuybyshev 0.5, Voznesenskiy 0.5, Kirov 0 (-1), Ordzhonikidze 0 (-1)
Shcherbitskiy 1 (0), Rashidov 1 (-1), Grechko 0.5, Gromyko 0.5, Brezhnev 0.5 (-1), Tikhonov 0.5 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1)
Aliyev 1.5 (-1 + GenSek's decision), Kirilenko 1.5 (-1), Pavlov 1 (-2)
Polyanskiy 2, Khrushchev 1 (-1), Kuusinen 0.5, Shelepin 0.5, Yakovlev 0 (-1), Andropov 0 (-2)

Round 3:
Sverdlov 3, Kalinin 1, Lenin 1
Kamenev 3, Frunze 2
Beriya 1, Kaganovich 1, Postyshev 1, Yagoda 1
Mikoyan 3, Shepilov 1, Voznesensky 1
Brezhnev 2 (1.83 previous vote), Rashidov 2 (1.33 previous vote), Gromyko 1
Pavlov 3, Kirilenko 2
Khrushchev 2, Gorbachev 1, Kuusinen 1, Shelepin 1

Round 4:
Kalinin 1.6, Chubar 1, Trotskiy 0.8, Lenin 0.6
Frunze 1.4 (4.33 previous votes), Sokolnikov 1.4 (1.5 previous votes), Radek 1, Tukhachevskiy 0.2
Yagoda 1.4, Kaganovich 1.2, Postyshev 0.8, Vyshinskiy 0.4, Zhdanov 0.2
Voznesesnkiy 1.2, Ordzhonikidze 0.8, Shepilov 0.8, Pervukhin 0.6, Malenkov 0.4, Kuybyshev 0.2
Tikhonov 1.4, Rashidov 1.2, Kuznetsov 0.6, Grechko 0.4, Gromyko 0.4
Kryuchkov 1.6, Kirilenko 0.8, Romanov 0.8, Chebrikov 0.6, Kosygin 0.2
Kuusinen 1.4, Kozlov 1.2, Podgorniy 1, Shelepin 0.4

Round 5:
Trotskiy 3, Lenin 2
Sokolnikov 1
Postyshev 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Shepilov 1 (2.13 previous votes), Malenkov 1 (1.07 previous vote)
Rashidov 2 (4.53 previous votes), Grechko 2 (0.9 previous vote)
Chebrikov 4, Romanov 3
Shelepin 2 (1.9 previous vote), Kozlov 2 (1.2 previous vote)

Round 6:
Lenin 2
Radek 2, Bukharin 1, Rykov 1
Vyshinskiy 3, Dzerzhinskiy 2
Pervukhin 2, Malenkov 1
Kuznetsov 2, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1
Romanov 4, Zaykov 2, Kirilenko 1
Kozlov 2, Podgorniy 1

Round 7:
Chubar 2.5, Preobrazhenskiy 1.25, Rudzutak 0.25
Bukharin 2, Rykov 1.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.75
Kaganovich 2.25, Andreyev 0.75, Dzerzhinskiy 0.75, Molotov 0.25
Bulganin 3, Malenkov 1
Ustinov 1.75, Grechko 1, Gromyko 1, Suslov 0.25
Kirilenko 1.5, Kosygin 1.25, Zaykov 1, Shelest 0.25
Podgorniy 2.5, Shevardnadze 0.75, Yeltsin 0.75

Round 8:
Andreyev 0.5, Zaykov 0.5, Grechko 0.33 (4.9 previous votes), Gromyko 0.33 (4.57 previous votes), Malenkov 0.33 (4.07 previous votes), Preobrazhenskiy 0.33 (1.25 previous vote), Molotov 0.33 (0.25 previous vote), Dzerzhinskiy 0.17, Zhdanov 0.17

Round 9:
Kosygin 0.5, Malenkov 0.5, Preobrazhenskiy 0.5, Tomskiy 0.17, Voroshilov 0.17, Zhdanov 0.17, Dzerzhinskiy 0.17 (-1), Molotov 0.17 (-1), Yeltsin 0 (-1), Grishin -0.17 (-1), Lukyanov -0.17 (-1), Shevardnadze -0.17 (-1), Suslov -0.17 (-1), Tukhachevskiy -0.17 (-2)

Round 10:
Dzerzhinskiy 0.5 (5.75 previous votes), Zhdanov 0.5 (1.04 previous vote), Molotov 0.5 (0.92 previous vote), Tomskiy 0.5 (0.17 previous vote), Gorbachev 0.25, Kirov 0.25, Kulakov 0.25, Ordzhonikidze 0.25, Ponomarev 0.25, Rykov 0.25, Suslov 0.25, Tukhachevskiy 0.25

Round 11:
Ordzhonikidze 1.33, Molotov 1, Rudzutak 0.5, Yeltsin 0.5, Tomskiy 0.33, Voroshilov 0.33

Round 12:
Tomskiy 0.5, Molotov 0 (-2), Rudzutak 0 (-2), Gorbachev 0 (-1), Suslov 0 (-1), Yeltsin 0 (-1), Kirov -0.5 (-1)

Round 13:
Suslov 3, Molotov 2

Round 14: bring back round
Lenin 13 (7 handicap points), Beriya 7 (10 handicap points), Brezhnev 5, Dzerzhinskiy 5, Shelepin 5, Suslov 5, Trotskiy 2, Kozlov 1, Stalin 1

Round 15:
Rudzutak 1.33 (0.75 previous vote), Ponomarev 1.33 (0.25 previous vote), Kuybyshev 1, Molotov 0.67, Beriya 0.33, Lenin 0.33

Round 16:
Ponomarev 1.1, Beriya 0.8, Molotov 0.8, Kuybyshev 0.4, Voroshilov 0.4, Kirov 0.2, Lenin 0.2, Rykov 0.1

Round 17:
Voroshilov 1, Kuybyshev 0.67, Beriya 0.33 (-2), Grishin 0.33, Yeltsin 0.33, Molotov 0 (-2), , Lenin 0 (-1)

Round 18:
Grishin 1.5, Kuybyshev 1, Molotov 1, Yeltsin 0.5

Round 19:
Beriya 1 (10 handicap points), Molotov 1 (7.56 previous points), Kuybyshev 0.7, Lenin 0.4, Gorbachev 0.3, Yeltsin 0.3, Ryzhkov 0.2, Tukhachevskiy 0.1

Round 20:
Yeltsin 0.5, Molotov 0 (-2), Lenin -0.5 (-2)

Round 21:
Molotov 1, Ligachev 0.87, Kuybyshev 0.75, Lukyanov 0.75, Lenin 0.5, Tukhachevskiy 0.5, Kulakov 0.37, Kirov 0.25

Round 22:
Ligachev 1.5, Lenin 1, Kuybyshev 0.75, Tukhachevskiy 0.75, Kirov 0.25, Lukyanov 0.25, Rykov 0.25, Ryzhkov 0.25

Round 23:
Tukhachevskiy 3, Kuybyshev 2

Round 24:
Kuybyshev 1.4, Kirov 0.8, Rykov 0.8, Ryzhkov 0.8, Kulakov 0.2, Lenin 0.4, Lukyanov 0.4

Round 25:
Rykov 2, Lenin 1.67, Kulakov 1, Lukyanov 0.33

Round 26:
Ryzhkov 2, Kirov 1.5, Lenin 0.5 (-2), Lukyanov -1.5 (-3)

Round 27:
Kirov 1.8, Lenin 1.2, Lukyanov 0.8, Shelest 0.6, Gorbachev 0.4, Andropov 0.2

Round 28:
Lenin 4

Round 29:
Shelest 2, Lukyanov 1.5, Kulakov 1, Shevardnadze 0.5

Round 30:
Lukyanov 2.5 (3 negative votes), Shevardnadze -0.5 (1 negative vote), Andropov -0.5, Kulakov -0.5, Gorbachev -1 (1 negative vote)

Round 31:
Kulakov 1.2, Andropov 1, Shevardnadze 1, Gorbachev 0.4, Yakovlev 0.4

Round 32:
Shevardnadze 2, Andropov 0, Gorbachev -2

Round 33:
Andropov 1.5 (1.03 previous points), Yakovlev 1.5 (0.4 previous point), Gorbachev 1

Round 34:
Yakovlev 3, Gorbachev 1


Mikhail Sergeyevich GORBACHEV is the Survivor !




I'm happy he won something after all.
It was so difficult to do what he did...
Historical judgement is a bit harsh with him. In the realm of possible, he did what he could.Few political leaders have achieved the same amount of things, even though Russia was left very low; but how could it have been different with such a past ?
At least, Germany is reunited peacefully and quickly, Central and Eastern Europe is democratic and in peace, Ukraine is chaotically independent and free, etc.

Thank you for taking part in it !

I just regret Kalwejt hasn't voted in it until the end.
He could have made weird choices like me Grin
Logged
Dr. MB
MB
Atlas Politician
Atlas Icon
*****
Posts: 15,862
Libyan Arab Jamahiriya



Show only this user's posts in this thread
« Reply #221 on: May 18, 2019, 03:38:59 AM »

Logged
Pages: 1 ... 4 5 6 7 8 [9]  
« previous next »
Jump to:  


Login with username, password and session length

Terms of Service - DMCA Agent and Policy - Privacy Policy and Cookies

Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines

Page created in 0.2 seconds with 12 queries.