You can't have a "Christian" country that doesn't care about morality, lol. There is nothing inherently moral about high taxation, and interpreting the Bible as an economic guide is misguided, at best. Everything about the first society is full of self-contradictions.
At least the Randian America isn't self-contradictory or a one-party state. Give me freedom any day.
The morality of the first country is not on "body issues" (homosexuals, abortion, etc) the way we've been trained to think about morality.
Morality in this case means being a good person, or being a "Christian" (in the old sense of the word) which implies charity, generosity, being kind... and it really has no bearing on abortion or gays or anything of that nature.
I really do feel in the U.S. with the rise of the religious right wing and all of those televangelists and organizations like "Focus on the Family" that we have a very twisted view of what moral values are - and that we've placed entirely too much emphasis on sexual purity and sexual conformity to the exclusion of so much else that makes a person moral.
Also , I'd like to add that right-wing, free market, classical liberalism at its most excessive doesn't sound to me at all like Gospel, and in fact it sounds like something very dark and very cold and very hard to grasp for me, who was raised Catholic. The idea that the government would be completely in the hands of people who were stone-cold libertarians that had no belief that taxpayer dollars should be used to exemplify Christ-like values strikes me as rather vicious. That's not to say that conservatism is mean or cruel, but yes - Martin Luther King's America (or Tammy Faye Bakker's America) sounds a lot nicer to live in than Paul Ryan or Ayn Rand or Donald Trump's America, where the elites use libertarian philosophy to get exactly what they want: control of the economic system to benefit themselves.