I have to agree with Alcon - where else is this guy going to go? He's got to live somewhere.
As far as how I view the priest, well, he seems to be following that whole "forgiveness" creed that Christians are supposed to be big on, so he's probably not a hypocrite. Reading a few more articles on this suggests that:
"Pinckney stands by his position of forgiveness and says that too many people don’t understand how Christ can change a person, and offer renewal and forgiveness." (supposedly the killer found Jesus in 1993)
Here's another article:
http://www.unionleader.com/article.aspx?headline=Pastor+tells+why+he+took+in+killer&articleId=176f2193-7b7b-47b6-a741-1fbeb06c229bSome important details:
So he's taking more precautions than the law requires just in case.
I'm going to vote "Great" since this pastor actually seems to practice what his religion preaches but is also being smart about it.