I would like to know more about the weird history of how Scott has had two accounts which later got merged into one... I guess he'll come with an asterisk.
Anyway, further update:
Atlas MVP Awards2003: Al
2004: Adam Griffin
2005: Bacon King
2006: Polnut
2007: The Mikado
2008: Sprouts
2009: Kalwejt
2010: Nathan
2011: Flo
2012: Maxwell
2013: ElectionsGuy
2014: CrabCake
2015: Virginia
2016: Southern Gothic
2017: Not awarded (yet)
2018: Not awarded (yet)
2019: Not awarded (yet)
2020: Battista Minola 1616
Atlas Runner-up Awards2003: BRTD
2004: muon2/Mr. Morden
2005: Torie
2006: Hashemite
2007: dead0man
2008: evergreen
2009: Antonio V
2010: Cath
2011: TJ
2012: DC Al Fine
2013: TDAS04
2014: Harry S Truman
2015: LLR
2016: Scott*
2017: Not awarded (yet)
2018: Not awarded (yet)
2019: Not awarded (yet)
2020: CraneHusband
My top four posters are all there. Right now, as the Coldplay song says, God put a smile upon my face.