BRTD's myopic, obsessive hatred of Catholics continues.
The fact that people find this very notion actually offensive (as opposed to "it'll never happen" but not being actually bothered by the premise) is kind of a bizarre quirk of Atlas that isn't found elsewhere.
As per usual, you miss the point. It's not the notion of religious conversion that's problematic, it's your constant posting about it that's considered problematic. Constantly fantasizing about how you want public figures x, y, and z to change their religion to one you like is pretty weird.
It's also not an "Atlas quirk" that people are bothered by this, it's that this is an Atlas-only phenomenon by its nature. Nobody in real life goes around saying "Man I really wish that Joe Biden would convert to Protestant. Wouldn't it be so much better if he wasn't a Catholic?" and constantly talking about how much they wished their favorite politicians weren't Catholic. If you did this in real life (or elsewhere on the internet for the matter), plenty of non-Atlasians would think that it was weird.