This hypothetical only works if he was, say, the teacher of an eighth grade class and everybody else the students, and you had brought in the DVD for the class to watch on the last day of school. Sure, he'd be horrified once the movie started, but you should hear his language when subsequently describing you in the teachers' lounge.
How dare you... I'm practically a Saint. I only watch G-rated movies. My favorite movies are Beauty and the Beast and the Lion King. I would like Aladin, except it promotes stealing, which goes against my morals.
,...and everyone but the Gennie is Brown.