there is "winning the debate" and then there is changing voters minds...
PPP (D) says my the metric of changing votes, Romney won HUGE among independants.
More/Less Likely to Vote Obama?
Independants - More = 32%, Less = 48% => net negative of 16%
More/Less Likely to Vote Romney?
Independants - More = 47%, less = 35% => Net Positive of12%
28 Point differnetial for Romney
http://www.publicpolicypolling.com/pdf/2011/1022PostDebatePoll.pdf
And again Obama leads with indies by 10 points and overall by 5 points. But hey, great post.