Depends on whether the poster takes more after Arthur or Douglas.I
Arthur MacArthur was a FF, but his son Douglas was generally an HP, whose sole redeeming feature is that he probably was the best choice to govern Occupied Japan.
Arthur's leadership at the Battle of Missionary Ridge was incredible, Douglas was an as**ole who admonished General Wainwright for surrendering Corregidor even after he had run out of food, water, and ammunition. General Wainwright was the real hero of the Philippines not MacArthur.