I think she looks very cute in this photo, though she reminds me an awful lot of those over-achieving but slightly crazy nerdy-girl-students who can become strangely obsessed with a professor. I don't mean in a sexual way, but its still scary when it happens.
Something I mean, everything is wrong with your mind.
What? You seriously don't see the cuteness? Look at those big eyes, cute little mouth slightly apart, the cute (though slightly troubled) expression! Also she's quite slim..
I think you guys are just too picky. Girls can be cute and moderately attractive without being 'hot'.