Should GMac, jaichind, Vosem, and Yellowhammer have been banned?

[AtorBoltox]

I don't really know because I, like everyone else, only ever saw and retained a small % of their posts, especially the stuff that got removed, but the moderator team, compromised of hard-working professionals across the political spectrum, has earned all of our trust on matters like this, so I'll have faith and say Yes/Yes/Yes/Yes.

'Hard-working moderator of online forum' is an oxymoron

[AtorBoltox]

The bans given were tough (maybe tougher on at least GMac than I would've been), but ultimately fair in context. Voted Yes on all.

Pretty much this. I can see an argument for giving GMac a lighter sentence, much as we butt heads he can make good points sometimes.

This is a fair point if this was an isolated incident, but this was his fourth or so moderator action. Mods take that into account when determining punishment length, particularly since repeated infractions indicate a lack of ability to course correct. (edit: sorry, didn't see your edit before I responded. To be clear I am in agreement with you)

G-Mac has said he’s not coming back until the forum mods apologizes for calling him racist

I hope he reconsiders