Ill do 1896 and 1980(The economic situation is what it was then , and with a hostage crises, only difference is there is no USSR) and wont adjust percentages in each state.
1896:
McKinley 270 49.6%
Bryan 268 50.1%
1980:
Reagan 392 58%
Carter 146 41%
Carter only wins Georgia and West Virginia cause I dont think its possible for Carter to lose either of those states
Now 1912(there is not going to be light shade on here since i wont adjust for percentage )
Taft 252 35.3%
Wilson 168 33.3%
Teddy Roosevelt 118 30.9%