I don't really see it. Carter was the last hurrah of the old New Deal workers' rights alignment. Trump is an attempt at something very new and different. The analogy would work a lot better were Jeb Bush the R nominee.
My working theory right now is that Trump = Bryan 1896/1900 and Clinton beats him by 2.5 with the EC looking particularly lopsided. Then Cruz = Parker 1904 and Clinton beats him by 12 in 2020, after which the Trumpists take full control of the party and start purging neocons and movement conservatives. One more National Review type sneaks through a primary circa 2028-36, but he gets crushed in the general and then the realignment is complete.
Dems wont be in power that long
My prediction is this is how the election is like
Clinton = Nixon
Bush = Carter
Obama = Ronald Reagan
Clinton= HW Bush