Which of these countries should have permanent UNSC seats?

[NewYorkExpress]

The New Security Council would consist of;

The U.S
India
China
Germany
Russia
Saudi Arabia
South Africa
Brazil
Britain
Australia
Japan

There is no veto power, and Ties are broken by the Secretary-General

[NewYorkExpress]

The New Security Council would consist of;

The U.S
India
China
Germany
Russia
Saudi Arabia
South Africa
Brazil
Britain
Australia
Japan

There is no veto power, and Ties are broken by the Secretary-General

Saudi Arabia?  Hell no.

Why Australia?

For the Saudi's I'd rather have no one from that part of the world... But I figured I had to have somebody, and it was either Saudi's or the Iranians and I see the Saudis as (currently) the lesser of two evils). As for Australia, I was tempted to give that spot to Argentina, Mexico or South Korea... and I guess replacing the Saudis with someone from that trio still makes sense.

[NewYorkExpress]

The New Security Council would consist of;

The U.S
India
China
Germany
Russia
Saudi Arabia
South Africa
Brazil
Britain
Australia
Japan

There is no veto power, and Ties are broken by the Secretary-General

No France?

India replaces France "officially" unofficially I was choosing between France, The U.K and Germany... and I only wanted three European Countries (counting Russia).