Who is the greatest quarterback of all time?

[Bugs]

Y. A.  Tittle should be on this list, but you won't ever satisfy everyone.  Some of those QBs were good in their day, but not year after year after year like Tittle, Staubach, Elway and Marino.  Montana was good, and I was a big Bradshaw fan, but Unitas was the best ever.

[Bugs]

Another point in favor of Elway in the Elway/Marino debate:
The Broncos went to all those Super Bowls with Elway because he could play north of Mason-Dixon outdoors in winter.  The Dolphins always faded in December because they couldn't win in Pittsburg, Buffalo, Denver, etc.

Peyton needs to prove himself outside the dome before he can be truely great.  If he somehow wins in Pitt and N.E. this year, he'll have my respect.

I always wondered how Marino would have done if he would have played for someone like the Bills or Steelers.