I'm surprised no one's made a map for this one yet.
Red = Silver/Quinn (D) - 365
Blue = Smith/Harris (R) - 28
Green = Hubbard/Cruise (I, or maybe S for Scientology?) - 58
Yellow = Mohammed/Bakr (I) - 38
And yes I'm stretching reality a bit so that everyone can have at least a couple states somehow. 'Michigan = Large Islamic community actively campaigning for their guy + Romney working hard for his guy reducing Silver's votes
Penn. = Similar vote splitting somehow... actually no clue
California = Scientology is big there right? Add in enough alternative culture to split the rest and there you go.
Alaska = Maybe Palin converts to Scientology in order to prevent either Silver of Smith or Mohmmaed winning there
Its also a coincidence that 365 is also how many EVs Obama got. Didn't notice until I had almost posted this thing.
I do enjoy these crazy hypotheticals.