1912
I was Taft.
Results
William H. Taft-Republican 16,213,865 (28%) 88 Electoral Votes
Woodrow Wilson-Democratic 15,869,180 (27%) 199 Electoral Votes
Theodore "Teddy" Roosevelt-Progressive 15,604,322 (27%) 231 Electoral Votes
Eugene V. Debs-Socialist (Moron Party) 9,787,175 (17%) 13 Electoral Votes
266 Needed to Win-Congress Chose Wilson
Wilson underperformed big time in the south, and Taft was close to him in most states (within 10 points)
Does anyone know the composition of the house delgations in Jan 1913? And if majority Republican, who do you think would have won?