- Manning, Nickel, and Jackson have a near zero chance of staying with a mandatory redraw and a hack SCONC.
- Davis is slightly trickier since there has been a Black-influenced seat in NE North Carolina basically forever and the current one kind of still functions, although probably not for long. You could hypothetically land yourself in hot water federally if you're too blatant. I tend to think they will draw a district that Davis could win in 2024 and maybe 2026 but almost certainly not after that.
- Kaptur and Sykes really depend on what extractions the OH Dems actually got out of Stephens (after Kaptur's performance there's a small chance Rs may just not want to bother with her anymore as well). I think it's very likely that they both survive or both get the axe.
- Landsman is almost certainly safe, now that Chabot's out they don't really have a reason to draw a grotesque gerrymander for at best a Tilt D seat anyway.
If the OH GOP is not forced to compromise at all, it’s very easy to draw a seat that Kaptur would likely lose even after accounting for her 2022 performance. You can draw a Trump +14 seat with all of Lucas County. Same with Landsman. Cincinnati + Clermont + some 75-25 rurals gets a Trump +4 district with negligible trends. Sykes is tougher but you can also get her into a Trump +5 or so seat.
If there’s any need to compromise, then Landsman and Kaptur will be fine. Sykes will remain in a competitive seat.