SR 110-07: The Don't Violate the Terms of Service Amendment (Failed)

[SevenEleven]

Nay.

[Joseph Cao]

Due to the controversial nature of this bill and its impracticality, I motion to table this legislation.

As there may be posts in this thread that I haven't seen for laggy laptop reasons, would anyone like to fill me in on whether the tabling motion has been seconded? Would be a shame to have started this vote for nothing.

[Devout Centrist]

Due to the controversial nature of this bill and its impracticality, I motion to table this legislation.

As there may be posts in this thread that I haven't seen for laggy laptop reasons, would anyone like to fill me in on whether the tabling motion has been seconded? Would be a shame to have started this vote for nothing.

Mr. Reactionary added an ‘Aye’ on the motion to table before the vote began. Presumably he was seconding Spark’s motion?

[Saint Milei]

aye

[Mr. Reactionary]

Due to the controversial nature of this bill and its impracticality, I motion to table this legislation.

As there may be posts in this thread that I haven't seen for laggy laptop reasons, would anyone like to fill me in on whether the tabling motion has been seconded? Would be a shame to have started this vote for nothing.

Mr. Reactionary added an ‘Aye’ on the motion to table before the vote began. Presumably he was seconding Spark’s motion?

Yes. I'll say second in the future to avoid confusion.

Aye on tabling.

[AGA]

Aye

[S019]

Pre-Emptive Vote on Final Bill: Aye

[Senator-elect Spark]

Tabling vote

AYE: Spark, WM, Utah, DeadPrez, Mr. R, AGA (6)
NAY: WB, S019, WD, rpryor, Sev (5)
ABSTAIN:

Motion to table fails and debate resumes.

[Senator-elect Spark]

Motioning for a final vote, Senators have 24 hours to object.

[S019]

Cough

[GM Team Member and Senator WB]

With no objections a final vote is open on this for 96 hours.

To prevent confusion here is the full text:

Senate Resolution

To amend the Constitution to solve the constitutional question regarding legislation that is removed for violations of the Terms of Service.

Be it Resolved in the Atlasian Senate Assembled, that upon ratification by 2/3rds of the Regions, the constitution shall be amended as follows:

The Don't Violate the Terms of Service Amendment

Article VIII, Section 2, shall read as follows:

Section 4. Supremacy of the Atlas Forum
1. Actions taken by Administrators or Moderators of the Atlas Forum are separate and distinct from their actions as citizens of Atlasia and they shall not be restricted, nor obstructed by Atlasian constitutional or statutory provision, in their enforcement of the Terms of Service by Atlasian constitutional or statutory provision.
2. Nothing in this section shall be construed as to provide immunity to moderators who violate any statutory provision that does not conflict with or obstruct enforcement of the terms of service.
3. Any federal or regional legislation enacted after the date of January 1, 2022 that has been removed from the forum by a moderator due to violations of the Terms of Service or other forum policies shall be considered unenforceable.

[Mr. Reactionary]

Nay, as this unfairly applies ex post facto and risks overloading Yankee with hundreds of frivolous reports of old content.

[rpryor03]

Aye

[West_Midlander]

Nay, as this unfairly applies ex post facto and risks overloading Yankee with hundreds of frivolous reports of old content.

[AGA]

Nay

[Senator-elect Spark]

No

[Saint Milei]

Nay

[OSR stands with Israel]

Nay

[Utah Neolib]

Nay

[GM Team Member and Senator WB]

Abstain

[Southern Senator North Carolina Yankee]

Abstain

[SevenEleven]

Abstain.

[S019]

Aye

[Senator-elect Spark]

24 hours to vote or change votes.

[Senator-elect Spark]

Final vote

AYE: rpryor, S019 (2)
NAY: Mr. R, WM, AGA, Spark, DeadPrez, OSR, Utah ( 7 )
ABSTAIN:WB, NCY, Sev (4)

In a vote of 2-7-4, this bill fails.