Make a SCOTUS with only Atlas members.

[Kuumo]

The left:
Badger (Chief Justice)
Crane
Nathan
brucejoel99

The median:
GeorgiaModerate

The right:
Averroes
North Carolina Yankee
Dr. RI

The libertarian wild-card:
John Dule

[Santander]

Badger (Chief Justice)

I would hope he gets a human being to write down his opinions.

[OSR stands with Israel]

Regente
Mr. Reactionary
PIT
TJ in Oregon
North Carolina Yankee
Harry S Truman
True Federalist
Western Dem
Illiniwek

[Vice President Christian Man]

Conservative:
Dr. RI Trustbuster
Gregthegreat
Fuzzy Bear  
DPKDebator

Pure tossup:
Chips

Liberals:
Olwankandi (Chief Justice)
Abdullah
Western Democrat
Ye

[MarkD]

I'm honored and touched! I'm about to have a Sally Field moment!

Here's my list:

Ernest/True Federalist
brucejoel99
Torie
lfromnj (returning the honor)
Wulfric/Dwarven Dragon
NOVA Green
Calthrina950
Muon
538Electoral

That's 3 red avatars, 2 blue, and 4 others.

I hereby revise this list in order to remove brucejoel99 from it. I don't know, yet, who else on Atlas I could choose to put on this list to replace him, but as of now I sure as blazes do not want bj99 to be on the Supreme Court.
About 2 hours ago, bj99 posted an argument about the 9th Amendment that is absolutely the worst piece of drivel I've ever seen from, in particular, him. Whatever respect I used to have for his legal acumen, he just washed it away completely.

[brucejoel99]

Chief Justice: True Federalist
Associate Justice: Nathan
Associate Justice: SteveRogers
Associate Justice: Mr. Reactionary
Associate Justice: windjammer
Associate Justice: Old School Republican
Associate Justice: MarkD
Associate Justice: brucejoel99
Associate Justice: lfromnj

I hereby revise this list in order to remove MarkD from it. I don't know, yet, who else on Atlas I could choose to put on this list to replace him, but as of now I sure as blazes do not want MarkD to be on the Supreme Court. About 14 hours ago, MarkD posted an argument about my clapback of originalism's hypocritical 9th Amendment interpretation that is absolutely the worst piece of drivel I've ever seen from, in particular, him. Whatever respect I used to have for what I thought was his obviously idiosyncratic but, at least hitherto now, consistently objective legal acumen, he just washed it away completely.

[Grumpier Than Uncle Joe]

The Left -

Nathan
Georgia Moderate
Badger
Sir Mohamed

The Center -

Torie - I'm teetering on him being center.

The Right -

Fuzzy
Mr. Reactionary
OSR
Me  

[Sir Mohamed]

From liberal to conservative:

- Xing
- Western Democrat
- Parrotguy
- President Johnson
- GeorgiaModerate
- Penn Quaker Girl
- Goldwater
- That Conservative Guy
- GregtheGreat657

Couldn't decide on the CJ, anyone of these would be fine. Think this SCOTUS would be relatively balanced and function well, because all of these are appear rational, calm and grown-up.

[Progressive Pessimist]

-Chief Justice: YE.
-Scott.
-Xing.
-Texasgurl.
-Progressive Moderate.
-Flying Mongoose.
-John Dule.
-North Carolina Yankee.
-Penn Quaker Girl.

I think this is a pretty balanced and rational court with diverse backgrounds.