"South Africa must always remain a White state." - white supremacist
"The United States must always preserve its White majority." - white supremacist
"Israel must always remain a Jewish state/preserve its Jewish majority." - noooo that's not Jewish supremacist!!!
It really is telling, innit?
You're not interested in good faith debate on the issue so I'm not answering for you, but rather for other people.
The Jews are a unique cultural and religious group that existed for thousands of years. After facing the most horrible persecution and genocide that any group experienced in documented history, they've decided to seek a nation state for Jews- just like many other groups have their own nation states. Where will Jews turn to if France or the United Kingdom or Russia or the United States elect an antisemitic authoritarian leader? Can they trust other countries to accept them, after during the holocaust German Jews were turned away in many countries? No, we clearly can't trust non-Jews to protect us.
This is why Israel and zionism are necessary, and this is why (unlike criticisms of Israel's actions), denying the very existence of Israel is antisemitic. And this is why comparing the necessity to keep a Jewish majority in Israel- the only way to ensure Jews have their own country- to neo-nazism and white supremacism is deploreable and filthy.
With all due respect, a White nationalist (or any other form of ethno-supremacism) could reason the same way.
These are some serious mental gymnastics you have to go through to argue in favor of perpetual racialism
No, they simply could not. There is absolutely no connection between the two and the fact that you keep name-dropping white supremacists in connection to a project started because Jews were slaughtered en masse by their ideological fathers without help from non Jewish countries is offensive.
Ah, I see, so because certain members of the ethnic group in question suffered brutality at the hands of others, that gives them the right to brutalize members of another nation by cutting them off, robbing them of their homes and resources, denying them a state, and forcefully maintaining the primacy of said ethnic group through ideology and demographic numbers. Sound logic sir.
