Only if they actually believe in the tenets of their religion.
Conversely, only people who identify as culturally (insert religion here) should be allowed to serve on juries.
imo all juries should consist of three christmas-and-easter boomer catholics, three secular jews, three "it's a philosophy, not a religion" buddhists, and three agnostic intersectional feminist second-generation pakistani-american women who wear hijab to own the deplorables
tbh imho christians are too privileged already, you should substitute the boomer catholics with three agnostic indian-americans who like diwali celebrations jao