RRH Elections Deep Dive into the 1860 election results

[StateBoiler]

https://rrhelections.com/index.php/2021/02/12/rrh-elections-special-feature-abraham-lincoln-and-the-election-of-1860/

Doing this as a special for President's Day. It heavily focuses on precinct results in 13 major cities of the day.

-A fusion slate of Douglas/Breckenridge/Bell won New York City (Manhattan Island only) over Lincoln 65-35. It's thought Lincoln only won 7 of the city's 217 precincts.
-Brooklyn, then a separate city, the Fusion slate won 56-44.
-Lincoln won Buffalo 52-48.
-Lincoln won Philadelphia 51, Reading ticket 28, Douglas 12, Bell 9
-Lincoln won Pittsburgh 66, Reading ticket 26, Douglas 6, Bell 2
-Breckenridge won Baltimore 50, Bell 42, Douglas 5, Lincoln 4
-Bell won Louisville 52, Douglas 36, Breckenridge 12, Lincoln 1
-Lincoln won St. Louis 41, Douglas 37, Bell 20, Breckenridge 3
-Bell won New Orleans 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 24
-Lincoln won Cincinnati 46, Douglas 42, Bell 11, Breckinridge 1
-Lincoln won Chicago 57, Douglas 43
-Lincoln won Boston 48, Bell 25, Douglas 23, Breckinridge 4
-Lincoln won San Francisco 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 18, Bell 7

Has links to source information and maps are there also of the ward/precinct results.

[Calthrina950]

https://rrhelections.com/index.php/2021/02/12/rrh-elections-special-feature-abraham-lincoln-and-the-election-of-1860/

Doing this as a special for President's Day. It heavily focuses on precinct results in 13 major cities of the day.

-A fusion slate of Douglas/Breckenridge/Bell won New York City (Manhattan Island only) over Lincoln 65-35. It's thought Lincoln only won 7 of the city's 217 precincts.
-Brooklyn, then a separate city, the Fusion slate won 56-44.
-Lincoln won Buffalo 52-48.
-Lincoln won Philadelphia 51, Reading ticket 28, Douglas 12, Bell 9
-Lincoln won Pittsburgh 66, Reading ticket 26, Douglas 6, Bell 2
-Breckenridge won Baltimore 50, Bell 42, Douglas 5, Lincoln 4
-Bell won Louisville 52, Douglas 36, Breckenridge 12, Lincoln 1
-Lincoln won St. Louis 41, Douglas 37, Bell 20, Breckenridge 3
-Bell won New Orleans 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 24
-Lincoln won Cincinnati 46, Douglas 42, Bell 11, Breckinridge 1
-Lincoln won Chicago 57, Douglas 43
-Lincoln won Boston 48, Bell 25, Douglas 23, Breckinridge 4
-Lincoln won San Francisco 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 18, Bell 7

Has links to source information and maps are there also of the ward/precinct results.

I've read this, and it's an utterly fascinating project. I've remarked before that McClellan almost won New York State in 1864 because of demolishing Lincoln in New York City. It would be reasonable to assume that McClellan probably got close to 70% of the vote there.

[cinyc]

https://rrhelections.com/index.php/2021/02/12/rrh-elections-special-feature-abraham-lincoln-and-the-election-of-1860/

Doing this as a special for President's Day. It heavily focuses on precinct results in 13 major cities of the day.

-A fusion slate of Douglas/Breckenridge/Bell won New York City (Manhattan Island only) over Lincoln 65-35. It's thought Lincoln only won 7 of the city's 217 precincts.
-Brooklyn, then a separate city, the Fusion slate won 56-44.
-Lincoln won Buffalo 52-48.
-Lincoln won Philadelphia 51, Reading ticket 28, Douglas 12, Bell 9
-Lincoln won Pittsburgh 66, Reading ticket 26, Douglas 6, Bell 2
-Breckenridge won Baltimore 50, Bell 42, Douglas 5, Lincoln 4
-Bell won Louisville 52, Douglas 36, Breckenridge 12, Lincoln 1
-Lincoln won St. Louis 41, Douglas 37, Bell 20, Breckenridge 3
-Bell won New Orleans 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 24
-Lincoln won Cincinnati 46, Douglas 42, Bell 11, Breckinridge 1
-Lincoln won Chicago 57, Douglas 43
-Lincoln won Boston 48, Bell 25, Douglas 23, Breckinridge 4
-Lincoln won San Francisco 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 18, Bell 7

Has links to source information and maps are there also of the ward/precinct results.

It's a special for Lincoln's 212th birthday on 2/12, not specifically Presidents' Day. Lincoln's Birthday is still a state holiday in some states, including New York.

I would have included Newark (11th-largest), but I couldn't find results. NJ was fascinating because it split its electoral votes due to a break down in electoral fusion.

Albany, NY was 13th largest, DC 14th (not a state & I'm not sure whether they had a presidential straw poll back then) and Providence 16th. Those cities are too small today to really map, but I didn't look into it. Finding info and maps to make the 13 was difficult enough.

Enjoy!

[cinyc]

https://rrhelections.com/index.php/2021/02/12/rrh-elections-special-feature-abraham-lincoln-and-the-election-of-1860/

Doing this as a special for President's Day. It heavily focuses on precinct results in 13 major cities of the day.

-A fusion slate of Douglas/Breckenridge/Bell won New York City (Manhattan Island only) over Lincoln 65-35. It's thought Lincoln only won 7 of the city's 217 precincts.
-Brooklyn, then a separate city, the Fusion slate won 56-44.
-Lincoln won Buffalo 52-48.
-Lincoln won Philadelphia 51, Reading ticket 28, Douglas 12, Bell 9
-Lincoln won Pittsburgh 66, Reading ticket 26, Douglas 6, Bell 2
-Breckenridge won Baltimore 50, Bell 42, Douglas 5, Lincoln 4
-Bell won Louisville 52, Douglas 36, Breckenridge 12, Lincoln 1
-Lincoln won St. Louis 41, Douglas 37, Bell 20, Breckenridge 3
-Bell won New Orleans 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 24
-Lincoln won Cincinnati 46, Douglas 42, Bell 11, Breckinridge 1
-Lincoln won Chicago 57, Douglas 43
-Lincoln won Boston 48, Bell 25, Douglas 23, Breckinridge 4
-Lincoln won San Francisco 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 18, Bell 7

Has links to source information and maps are there also of the ward/precinct results.

I've read this, and it's an utterly fascinating project. I've remarked before that McClellan almost won New York State in 1864 because of demolishing Lincoln in New York City. It would be reasonable to assume that McClellan probably got close to 70% of the vote there.

Thanks! I haven't looked for or compiled the 1864 vote. Maybe next year!

[Calthrina950]

https://rrhelections.com/index.php/2021/02/12/rrh-elections-special-feature-abraham-lincoln-and-the-election-of-1860/

Doing this as a special for President's Day. It heavily focuses on precinct results in 13 major cities of the day.

-A fusion slate of Douglas/Breckenridge/Bell won New York City (Manhattan Island only) over Lincoln 65-35. It's thought Lincoln only won 7 of the city's 217 precincts.
-Brooklyn, then a separate city, the Fusion slate won 56-44.
-Lincoln won Buffalo 52-48.
-Lincoln won Philadelphia 51, Reading ticket 28, Douglas 12, Bell 9
-Lincoln won Pittsburgh 66, Reading ticket 26, Douglas 6, Bell 2
-Breckenridge won Baltimore 50, Bell 42, Douglas 5, Lincoln 4
-Bell won Louisville 52, Douglas 36, Breckenridge 12, Lincoln 1
-Lincoln won St. Louis 41, Douglas 37, Bell 20, Breckenridge 3
-Bell won New Orleans 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 24
-Lincoln won Cincinnati 46, Douglas 42, Bell 11, Breckinridge 1
-Lincoln won Chicago 57, Douglas 43
-Lincoln won Boston 48, Bell 25, Douglas 23, Breckinridge 4
-Lincoln won San Francisco 48, Douglas 28, Breckinridge 18, Bell 7

Has links to source information and maps are there also of the ward/precinct results.

I've read this, and it's an utterly fascinating project. I've remarked before that McClellan almost won New York State in 1864 because of demolishing Lincoln in New York City. It would be reasonable to assume that McClellan probably got close to 70% of the vote there.

Thanks! I haven't looked for or compiled the 1864 vote. Maybe next year!

You're welcome. That certainly would be fascinating to see, if you ever do get to it.

[Southern Senator North Carolina Yankee]

I have never seen the city results before, very fascinating and thanks for your efforts on this.

Lincoln doing so well in Boston and winning St. Louis owes a lot to him opposing the more nativist impulses in the Republican Party and his ability to balance appeals to both business interests and of course working class voters. Later Republicans very quickly would forget all of this.

[H. Ross Peron]

Interesting Bell got second in Boston. I guess part of it was the favourite son effect for Everett but also Boston having been a Whig stronghold previously.

[Southern Senator North Carolina Yankee]

Interesting Bell got second in Boston. I guess part of it was the favorite son effect for Everett but also Boston having been a Whig stronghold previously.

All the rich Whig elites and New England Aristocrats.