1993: Burt Reynolds, Cop and a Half
1994: Everyone, North
1995: Tommy Lee Jones, Batman Forever
1996: Marlon Brando, Island of Doctor Moreau
1997: George Clooney, Batman & Robin
1998: Jackie Chan, Rush Hour
1999: Kenneth Brannagh, Wild Wild West
2000: Forest Whitaker, Battlefield Earth
2001: Chris Rock, AI: Artificial Intelligence
2002: Eddie Murphy, Adventures of Pluto Nash
2003: Alec Baldwin, Cat in the Hat
2004: Halle Berry, Catwoman
2005: A
2006: Jeremy Irons, Eragon
2007: Eddie Murphy, Norbit
2008: Everyone except The Hot Dog Guy, The Happening
2009: John Turturro, Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen
2010: Aasif Mandvi, The Last Airbender
2011: Al Pacino, Jack & Jill
2012: Cary Elwes, Oogieloves
2013: Everyone, Movie 43
2014: Nicolas Cage, Left Behind
2015: Peter Dinklage, Pixels
2016: Henry Cavill, Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice
2017: Patrick Stewart, The Emoji Movie
2018: John C. Reilly, Holmes & Watson
2019: Bruce Willis, Glass
The Adventures of Pluto Nash was reportedly god-awful, but at least an "honor" equal for Eddie Murphy, and arguably a joint award for Dudley Moore, was a mid eighties Bomb called best defense. The two stars I don't think ever shared a single scene together because, reasons. I remember seeing Murphy on The Tonight Show a year or two later where he out and out said, and I quote, the movie sucked.