If we had a Parliamentary system, there could be room for more than two parties, but while that works well in places like Germany, in Israel it has resulted in a party that gets 28% of the vote controlling the country's entire destiny. I could easily see a Trump rump of Republicans controlling everything by dividing and splintering everyone who opposed them. A 35% plurality would be forever in the driver's seat.
Uh, no it wouldn't? In Israel a party with 28% of the vote controls the country because the rest of parliament lets them do so.
But there are plenty of examples in parliamentary systems of a party with a large plurality not being in the driver's seat (let alone being there forever). New Zealand is a good example, since National got a huge plurality of 44.5% yet it was Labor who ended up ruling the country.
West Germany in the 1960s and 1970s also offers anothe example, where the CDU got pluralities in all elections except 1972; yet it was the SPD who ended up ruling the country.
If the "Trumpist party" ended up controlling the country with a 35% plurality forever it'd be because the rest of parliament lets them
Not to mention, if the US kept FPTP, the 2 party system, while weakened, would not go fully away. Just look at the UK.