In an unabashed attempt to recreate the Warren court:
Mr. X
Lief
Joe Republic (whine about him being a meanie to conservatives if you want, he researches what he posts better Then the large majority of posters here, and Is better than pretty much any conservative poster).
Georgia Moderate (a perfect "MINO" To earn me wholly undeserved bi partisan cred)
Virginia ( 1st female Chief Justice).
Texas Gurl ( Although having 2 women on the court is hardly balanced overall, for Atlas it's practically a gynocracy)
Afleitch ( Not simply filling The Secret requirement of having a token gay Scotsman at the highest levels of government, though he performs that task well too)
Brittain33
Gass ( In case I haven't sucked up to the mod's enough)
Honorable mention:
North Carolina Yankee. Only downside as he would probably shift conservative again from being in the constant minority among liberals, and hes much more effective outside the court trying, however hopeless a battle, to install even a modicum of sanity and respect for democratic values in the trump era or Republican party. He'd be a waste on the court.
Torie In addition to his streak of economic conservatism that led him to support Romney in 2012, I'd mostly be concerned he would Die too soon after appointment.
Chief court sketch artist: John Dule.