Entire Atlas R population competing in a primary:

[Grassroots]

Can I get some maps for this please? (Mapchart)

[America Needs a 13-6 Progressive SCOTUS]

Reaganfan would probably win.

[Yellowhammer]

I wouldn’t win any states.

[TPIG]

That primary would be such a jumble, I can't even imagine how it would look. I feel like I'd probably win GA, with my home-state advantage, and maybe Utah with my Romney love, but that's about it.

Whoever does actually make a map, you're a hero.

[DPKdebator]

Should we count R-leaning independents?

[Grassroots]

Should we count R-leaning independents?

For simplicity sake, I would just include R, C, and L avatars, but you can do whatever you want.

[RFayette]

Someone else can make a map, but let me list all the people (from the US, so excluding DC Al Fine, clash, Liam, etc.):
-TJ
-Old School Republican
-ThatConservativeGuy
-Fuzzy Bear
-RINO Tom
-Grassr00ts
-Whitesox
-NC Yankee
-fhtagn
-ExtremeConservative
-Thomas from NJ
-PiT
-TexasConservative
-UlmerFudd
-RFayette
-Carpetbagger
-Badger
-Liam
-OldiesFreak
-muon2
-Chancellor
-krazen
-Classic Conservative
-Mumph

I'm sure there are others active, but this is a good start IMO and it'd be interesting to see what people come up with just with this list.

[Alabama_Indy10]

^^ And me

[OSR stands with Israel]

The median Atlas Republican is to the left of the median Democrat in the country

Hahahahahaha no

[Beet]

Well if others are going to protest their exclusion, so am I.

[YE]

I'd root for Fuzzy Bear but my guess is Reaganfan would win. Maybe Grassroots. TCG would have a chance if this was 8-10 years ago but not Trumpy enough.

[OSR stands with Israel]

It would come down to

ThatConservativeGuy vs Sunrise vs RFayette vs Grassroots

[Dr. MB]

Comes down to Sanchez vs. Naso.

Sanchez wins.

[TJ in Oregon]

Muon sweep.

[IceSpear]

Comes down to Sanchez vs. Naso.

Sanchez Naso wins.

[Politician]

It would come down to

ThatConservativeGuy vs Sunrise vs RFayette vs Grassroots

Lol

Reaganfan would win easily.

[Badger]

Muon sweep.

Nah. To moderate even though he's reasonably conservative having voted against SSM in the Illinois legislature and all. More importantly, simply too science-based and fundamentally sane.

[Badger]

Comes down to Sanchez vs. Naso.

Sanchez wins.

[Badger]

Comes down to Sanchez vs. Naso.

Sanchez wins.

Or at least a 60-40 chance over naso

[Mr. Morden]

All of these guys have zero name recognition, so ThatConservativeGuy probably wins on the basis of his appealing (to GOP primary voters) user name.

Though I guess all but Muon (and maybe one or two others?) are probably disqualified for not being old enough to be president.

[DINGO Joe]

Won't somebody please clap for RINO Tom?

[Santander]

Comes down to Sanchez vs. Naso.

Sanchez wins.

[Sprouts Farmers Market ✘]

Won't somebody please clap for RINO Tom?

At least he's not dating a tiny Mexican woman!

[mvd10]

I think RFayette wins actually. He's conservative and he atleast backs Trump iirc. I don't really think there is room for a Reaganfan vs Sanchez horserace. It'll probably be RFayette vs Reaganfan/Sanchez vs a token vaguely non-Trumpist candidate (Alabama Indy? ThatConservativeGuy? maybe me lmfao?) with either RFayette or Reaganfan/Sanchez winning.

[CatoMinor]

By the time Iowa rolls around most have dropped out and Naso has a slight lead nationally. Sanchez siphons off enough of Naso's voters to allow NC Yankee a narrow win. Following this Sanchez drops out to allow his base to consolidate behind Reaganfan. This allows Reaganfan to sweep most of the remaining states with pluralities despite the best efforts of Badger and his coalition for reason. Moun2 wins Illinois, and NC Yankee would pick up North Carolina before dropping out and endorsing Badger who would remain in until the end to collect as many delegates as possible to protest at the convention. .