How would you have voted?: United States Presidential Elections

[The Mikado]

Washington
Washington
Adams
Adams
Jefferson
Pickney
Clinton
Monroe
Monroe
Adams
Adams
Clay
Van Buren (massive FF)
Van Buren
Clay (take that, James Polk!)
Van Buren
...Scott, I guess
Fremont
Lincoln
Lincoln
Grant
Greeley
Tilden
Hancock
Cleveland
Cleveland
Weaver
Bryan
Bryan
Debs (protest vote)
Bryan
Debs (that scoundrel Woodrow Wilson would never get my vote)
Benson (whoever he is, see above)
Cox
LaFollette
Smith
Roosevelt
Roosevelt
Roosevelt
Roosevelt
Truman
Stevenson
Stevenson
Kennedy
Johnson
Humphrey
McGovern
Carter
Carter
Mondale
Dukakis
Clinton
Clinton
Gore
Kerry
Obama

[The Mikado]

With Hindsight:

Probably wouldn't have had a vote until 1824 at the earliest, but...

Washington
Washington
Adams
Adams
Pinckney
Pinckney
Clinton
Monroe (Mainly because I don't know who "Rufus King" is)
Guess (Election 1820 must've been so dull)
Adams
Adams
Clay
Van Buren, though tempted to vote Webster
Van Buren
Clay
Van Buren
Ick.  Abstain Free Soil
Fremont
Lincoln
Lincoln
Grant
Probably Greeley
Tilden
Hancock
Cleveland
Cleveland
Cleveland
Palmer
...Fine. Bryan
TR
Debs...not a Bryan fan
Debs, definitely with hindsight.  I wouldn't want a part in electing Woodrow Wilson.
Anyone but Wilson
Cox
LaFollette, due to his vote against war with Germany
Smith
FDR
^^^
^^^
^^^
Truman
Stevenson
^^^
Kennedy
LBJ
Humphrey
McGovern
Carter
^^^
Mondale
Dukakis
Clinton
^^^
Gore
Kerry
Obama (who I did vote for!)

So, straight Dem since 1928.