List of Alternate Presidents 2.0.

[Sirius_]

Oof the old government

Following shocking revelations of many politicians bargaining for Russian support, the old party system breaks down, many are ousted, and a parliamentary system is put in place.

2019 Emergency Election:
National Unity: 490
American Fatherland: 10
Prime Minister: Claire McCaskill (NU-MO)
Deputy Prime Minister: Arnold Schwarzenegger (NU-CA)
Opposition Leader: Jared Kushner  (AF-NY)
2023 Election:
American Union of Labor: 36
National Unity: 412
Facts and Logic: 52
Prime Minister: Claire McCaskill (NU-MO)
Deputy Prime Minister: Angus King (NU-ME)
Opposition Leader: Ben Shapiro (FaL-CA)
2027 Election:
American Union of Labor: 2
Progressive Future: 105
National Unity: 202
Christian Democrats USA: 16
Facts and Logic: 186
Prime Minister: Kyrsten Sinema (NU-AZ)
Deputy Prime Minister: Ayanna Pressley (PF-NY)
Opposition Leader: Ben Shapiro (FaL-CA)
2031 Election:
Progressive Future: 133
National Unity: 119
Christian Democrats USA: 30
Facts and Logic: 218
Prime Minister: Ayanna Pressley (PF-NY) Until loss of confidence in 2033, then Joe Cunningham (NU-SC)
Deputy Prime Minister: Joe Cunningham (NU-SC) until confidence vote in 2033, then Lee Carter (PF-VA)
Opposition Leader: Ben Shapiro (FaL-CA) until sexual assault charge in 2035, then Dan Crenshaw (FaL-TX)

I'll keep doing these later

[Sirius_]

2035 Election:
Progressive Future: 225
National Unity: 76
Christian Democrats USA: 189
Facts and Logic: 10
Prime Minister: Lee Carter (PF-VA)
Deputy Prime Minister: Joe Cunningham (NU-SC) until the 2036 conflict, in which Cunningham breaks with Carter on several key economic platforms. Carter then controversially replaces him with John Bel Edwards (CDU-LA).
Opposition Leader: John Bel Edwards (CDU-LA) until the 2036 conflict, then Joe Cunningham (NU-SC)
2039 Election:
Progressive Future: 86
National Unity: 163
Christian Democrats USA: 232
Facts and Logic: 19
Prime Minister: John Bel Edwards (CDU-LA)
Deputy Prime Minister: Dan Crenshaw (FaL-TX)
Opposition Leader: Phil Scott (NU-VT)
2043 Election:
Progressive Future: 63
National Unity: 166
Christian Democrats USA: 232
Facts And Logic: 29
Prime Minister: John Bel Edwards (CDU-LA)
Deputy Prime Minister: Dan Crenshaw (FaL-TX)
Opposition Leader: Abigail Spanberger (NU-VA)

In 2046, the Christian Democrats USA including Prime Minister Edwards are found guilty of receiving illegal funds and support from Angela Merkel and her allies in the German CDU. Chief Justice Merrick Garland declares the 2043 election void and a snap election is held.

2046 Snap Election:
Progressive Future: 72
National Unity: 426
Facts and Logic: 2
Prime Minister: Abigail Spanberger (NU-VA)
Deputy Prime Minister: Carlos Curbelo (NU-FL)
Opposition Leader: Rashida Tlaib (PF-MI)

And the cycle repeats...

[S019]

1945-1953: Thomas Dewey
1953-1961: Adlai Stevenson
1961-1969: Nelson Rockefeller
1969-1977: Eugene McCarthy
1977-1981: Barry Goldwater
1981-1989: Paul Sarbanes
1989-1993: Howell Heflin
1993-2001: Al D'Amato
2001-2009: Bob Kerrey
2009-2017: John McCain
2017-Present: Joe Lieberman

[Cabbage]

Constitutional Convention Ends In Havoc; Elective Constitutional Monarchy Established
Age Limit for Prime Minister is 25

KINGS
1. George Washington (1787-1799, from Virginia)
2. Thomas Jefferson (1799-1826, from Virginia)
3. William I Henry Harrison (1826-1841, from Ohio)
4. Henry Clay (1841-1852, from Kentucky)
5. Winfield Scott (1852-1866, from New Jersey)
6. Abraham Lincoln (1866-1882, from Illinois)
7. Stephen Grover Cleveland (1882-1908, from New York)
8. William II Jennings Bryan (1908-1925, from Nebraska)
9. Franklin Delano Roosevelt (1925-1945, from New York)
10. Harry S Truman (1945-1972, from Missouri)
11. Hubert H. Humphrey (1972-1978, from Minnesota)
12. James E. Carter (1978-Present, from Georgia)

PRIME MINISTERS
(key: Federalist Democratic-Republican Democratic Republican)
*: assassinated /: died of NC ^: elected king

1. John Adams (1789-1797, from Massachusetts)
2. Thomas Jefferson (1797-1799, from Virginia)^
3. James Madison (1799-1801, from Virginia)
4. Charles Cotesworth Pinckney (1801-1805, from South Carolina)
5. James Monroe (1805-1813, from Virginia)
6. DeWitt Clinton (1813-1821, from New York)
7. John Quincy Adams (1821-1829, from Massachusetts)
8. Andrew Jackson (1829-1841, from Tennessee)
9. Daniel Webster (1841-1849, from Massachusetts)
10. Zachary Taylor (1849-1850, from Louisiana)/
11. Millard Fillmore (1850-1853, from New York)
12. John Fremont (1853-1859, from California)*
13. Lewis Campbell (1859-1861, from Ohio)
14. Abraham Lincoln (1861-1865, from Illinois)
15. George McClellan (1865-1869, from New Jersey)
16. Ulysses S. Grant (1869-1877, from Illinois)
17. Samuel J. Tilden (1877-1881, from New York)
18. James A. Garfield (1881, from Ohio)*
19. Chester A. Arthur (1881-1885, from New York)
20. James G. Blaine (1885-1889, from Maine)
21. William Jennings Bryan (1889-1901, from Nebraska)
22. Alton Parker (1901-1905, from New York)
23. Theodore Roosevelt (1905-1917, from New York)
24. Charles Evans Hughes (1917-1921, from New York)
25. Franklin Delano Roosevelt (1921-1925, from New York)
26. Herbert Hoover (1925-1929, from California)
27. John Nance Garner (1929-1937, from Texas)
28. Thomas Dewey (1937-1941, from New York)
29. Harry S Truman (1941-1945, from Missouri)^
30. Adlai Stevenson II (1945-1949, from Illinois)
31. Dwight D. Eisenhower (1949-1961, from New York)
32. John F. Kennedy (1961-1963, from Massachusetts)*
33. Lyndon B. Johnson (1963-1969, from Texas)
34. Richard M. Nixon (1969-1981, from California)
35. Walter Mondale (1981-1985, from Minnesota)
36. Ronald Reagan (1985-1993, from California)
37. Bill Clinton (1993-2005, from Arkansas)
38. George W. Bush (2005-2013, from Texas)
39. Willard Mitt Romney (2013-2017, from Massachusetts)
40. Barack Obama (2017-present, from Illinois)

DEPUTY PRIME MINISTERS (appointed by Prime Ministers)
^: elevated to PM (all others the same)

1. Thomas Pinckney (1789-1797, from South Carolina)
2. James Madison (1797-1799, from Virginia)^
3. James Monroe (1799-1801, from Virginia)
4. Rufus King (1801-1805, from New York)
5. George Clinton (1805-1812, from New York)/
6. Elbridge Gerry (1812-1813, from Massachusetts)
7. Jared Ingersoll (1813-1821, from Pennsylvania)
8. Richard Rush (1821-1829, from Pennsylvania)
9. John C. Calhoun (1829-1833, from South Carolina)
10. Martin van Buren (1833-1841, from New York)
11. John Tyler (1841-1849, from Virginia)
12. Millard Fillmore (1849-1850, from New York)^
13. Charles Francis Adams (1850-1853, from Massachusetts)
14. Lewis Campbell (1853-1859, from Ohio)^
15. William Pennington (1859-1861, from New Jersey)
16. Hannibal Hamlin (1861-1865, from Maine)
17. George Pendleton (1865-1869, from Ohio)
18. Schuyler Colfax (1869-1873, from Indiana)
19. Henry Wilson (1873-1875, from Massachusetts)/
20. William Wheeler (1875-1877, from New York)
21. Thomas Hendricks (1877-1881, from Indiana)
22. Chester A. Arthur (1881, from New York)^
23. John Sherman (1881-1885, from Ohio)
24. John Logan (1885-1886, from Illinois)/
25. George Edmunds (1886-1889, from Vermont)
26. Adlai Stevenson I (1889-1897, from Illinois)
27. Arthur Sewall (1897-1900, from Maine)/
28. Thomas Watson (1900-1901, from Georgia)
29. Henry G. Davis (1901-1905, from West Virginia)
30. Charles Fairbanks (1905-1918, from Indiana)/
31. Warren G. Harding (1918-1921, from Ohio)
32. James M. Cox (1921-1925, from Ohio)
33. Charles Curtis (1925-1929, from Kansas)
34. Al Smith (1929-1937, from New York)
35. Alf Landon (1937-1941, from Kansas)
36. Adlai Stevenson II (1941-1945, from Illinois)^
37. Alben Barkley (1945-1949, from Kentucky)
38. Earl Warren (1949-1961, from California)
39. Lyndon B. Johnson (1961-1963, from Texas)^
40. Hubert H. Humphrey (1963-1969, from Minnesota)
41. Spiro T. Agnew (1969-1973, from Maryland)
42. Gerald R. Ford (1973-1977, from Michigan)
43. Bob Dole (1977-1981, from Kansas)
44. Geraldine Ferraro (1981-1985, from New York)
45. George H. W. Bush (1985-1993, from Texas)
46. Al Gore (1993-2005, from Tennessee)
47. Dick Cheney (2005-2013, from Wyoming)
48. Paul Ryan (2013-2017, from Wisconsin)
49. Tim Kaine (2017-present, from Virginia)

FAILED CANDIDATES

ROYAL
1787: None
1799: John Adams
1826: Andrew Jackson
1841: Martin van Buren
1852: Franklin Pierce from New Hampshire
1866: George McClellan
1882: James G. Blaine
1908: Theodore Roosevelt
1925: Herbert Hoover
1945: Thomas Dewey
1972: Richard Nixon
1978: Bob Dole

PRIME MINISTERIAL (additional specifications only added for those not mentioned before)
1789/1792: Thomas Jefferson
1796: John Adams
1800/1812: James Madison
1804: Charles Cotesworth Pinckney
1808: Rufus King
1816: Daniel D. Tompkins from New York
1820: William Crawford from Georgia
1824: Andrew Jackson
1828: Richard Rush
1832: John Sergeant from Pennsylvania
1836: Hugh White from Tennessee
1840/1844: Martin van Buren
1848: Lewis Cass from Michigan
1852/1856: James Buchanan from Pennsylvania
1860: Stephen Douglas from Illinois
1864: Abraham Lincoln
1868: George McClellan
1872: Horatio Seymour from New York
1876: Rutherford B. Hayes from Ohio
1880: Winfield Scott Hancock from Pennsylvania
1884: Thomas Hendricks
1888: James G. Blaine
1892: Benjamin Harrison from Indiana
1896/1900: William McKinley from Ohio
1904: Alton Parker
1908: George Gray from Delaware
1912/1916: Woodrow Wilson from New Jersey
1920: Warren G. Harding
1924: Franklin Delano Roosevelt
1928/1932: Herbert Hoover
1936: Henry Wallace from New York
1940: Thomas Dewey
1944: Harold Stassen from Minnesota
1948-1956: Adlai Stevenson II
1960: Richard Nixon from California
1964: Barry Goldwater from Arizona
1968: Hubert H. Humphrey
1972: George S. McGovern from South Dakota
1976: James E. Carter
1980: Bob Dole
1984: Walter Mondale
1988: Michael Dukakis
1992: George H. W. Bush
1996: Richard Lugar from Indiana
2000: Steve Forbes from New York
2004: John Kerry from Massachusetts
2008: Hillary Clinton from New York
2012: Joe Biden from Delaware
2016: Willard Mitt Romney

[Unconditional Surrender Truman]

MONARCHS of the UNITED STATES
1789 – 1799     George I (“The Patriot”)     House of Washington–Custis–Lee
1799 – 1857     George II     House of Washington–Custis–Lee
1857 – 1861     Robert I (“The Fox”)     House of Washington–Custis–Lee
1861 – 1865     Abraham I (“The Emancipator”)     House of Lincoln
1865 – 1926     Robert II     House of Lincoln
1926 – 1938     Mary I     House of Lincoln
1938 – 1938     Abraham II (“The Unwilling”)     House of Isham
1938 – 1948     Mary II (“Jessie”)     House of Lincoln
1948 – 1985     Robert III     House of Lincoln–Beckwith
1985 –  -----     Timothy (“The Bastard”)     House of Lincoln–Beckwith

[Joe Biden 2024]

Reagan as Wilson

40. Ronald Reagan/John Connally 1981-1989
41. Gary Hart/Mario Cuomo 1989-1991
42. Mario Cuomo/vacant 1991, Lee Hamilton 1991-1997
43. Les Aspin/Chris Dodd 1997-2001
44. Rudy Giuliani/Newt Gingrich 2001-2009, Rob Portman 2009-2013, Norm Coleman 2013
45. Norm Coleman/vacant 2013, John Thune 2013-2021
46. William McRaven/Kyrsten Sinema 2021-2029

Losing Tickets

1980: Jimmy Carter/Peter Rodino, George McGovern/Hugh Carey
1984: Reubin Askew/Edmund Muskie
1988: John Love/Rudy Giuliani
1992: Dick Cheney/Pete Wilson
1996: George Pataki/Trent Lott
2000: Les Aspin/Chris Dodd
2004: Zell Miller/Steve Jobs
2008: Steve Jobs/Dick Durbin
2012: Deval Patrick/Ted Strickland
2016: Deval Patrick/Gavin Newsom
2020: Larry Hogan/Ted Cruz
2024: Larry Hogan/Rand Paul

[Joe Biden 2024]

W as Clinton

43. George W. Bush/Lamar Alexander 2001-2009
44. Hillary Clinton/Wesley Clark 2009-2017
45. Marco Rubio/Mike Crapo 2017-2025
46. Mark Cuban/Roy Cooper 2025-2029

Losing Tickets

2000: Al Gore/Joe Lieberman
2004: Lloyd Bentsen/John Kerry
2008: Lamar Alexander/Chuck Hagel
2012: Scott Brown/Rick Perry
2016: Russ Feingold/Alison Lundergan Grimes
2020: John Hickenlooper/Hakeem Jeffries
2024: Jeb Bush/Tim Pawlenty

[Joe Biden 2024]

Obama as Kennedy

44. Barack Obama/Joe Biden 2009-2011
45. Joe Biden/vacant 2011, Russ Feingold 2011-2017
46. Mitt Romney/Bob McDonnell 2017-2021, vacant 2021, Kevin McCarthy 2021-2022
47. Kevin McCarthy/vacant 2022, Jon Huntsman 2022-2025
48. Jay Inslee/Tammy Baldwin 2025-2029

Losing Tickets

2008: Mitt Romney/Jeb Bush
2012: Mike Pence/Newt Gingrich
2016: Russ Feingold/Chris Murphy
2020: Elizabeth Warren/Al Franken/Susan Rice
2024: Kevin McCarthy/John N. Kennedy

[President Johnson]

Lyndon B. Johnson as Andrew Johnson

35. John F. Kennedy/Lyndon B. Johnson, 1961-1963 (assassinated)
36. Lyndon B. Johnson/Hubert Humphrey, 1963-1969
37. William Westmoreland/William Scranton, 1969-1977
38. Jim Rhodes/Paul Laxalt, 1977-1981
39. Jack Kemp/Spiro Agnew, 1981 (assassinated)
40. Spiro Agnew/Phil Crane, 1981-1985
41. Pat Moynihan/Birch Bayh, 1985-1989
42. John Eisenhower/Al D'Amato, 1989-1993
43. Pat Moynihan/Bill Brady, 1993-1997
44. George Voinovich/George Pataki, 1997-2001 (assassinated)
45. George Pataki/Don Young, 2001-2009
46. Bob Taft Jr./Lamar Alexander, 2009-2013
47. Joe Biden/Evan Bayh, 2013-2021
48. Mike DeWine/Scott Brown, 2021-2023 (assassinated)
49. Scott Brown/Bruce Rauner, 2023-2029
50. John Cox/Kristi Noem, 2029-2033
51. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez/Beto O'Rourke, 2033-

[Joe Biden 2024]

Truman as Coolidge

33. Harry S. Truman/vacant 1945-1949, William O. Douglas 1949-1953
34. W. Averell Harriman/Ernest McFarland 1953-1957
35. John Bricker/Joseph W. Martin 1957-1965, Frederick Seaton 1965-1969, Clifford Case 1969
36. Clifford Case/vacant 1969-1973, Hugh Scott 1973-1977
37. Thomas Moorer/John Glenn 1977-1985
38. Paul Laxalt/Howard Baker 1985-1987
39. Howard Baker/vacant 1987-1989, Pete Wilson 1989-1993
40. John Glenn/Edwin Edwards 1993-1997, vacant 1997. William H. Gray III 1997-1998
41. William H. Gray III/vacant 1998, Douglas Wilder 1998-2001
42. George Pataki/Gordon Smith 2001-2005
43. Mark Warner/Sam Nunn 2005-2013
44. Sam Nunn/Martin Heinrich 2013-2017
45. Eric Greitens/Joni Ernst 2017-2025
46. Stacey Abrams/Jeh Johnson 2025-2029

Losing Tickets

1948: Douglas MacArthur/Earl Warren
1952: George T. Mickelson/Robert A. Taft
1956: W. Averell Harriman/Ernest McFarland
1960: Pat Brown/Michael DiSalle
1964: Paul C. Fisher/Lyndon B. Johnson
1968: John Connally/Frank Clement
1972: John Connally/Edmund Muskie
1976: Daniel Evans/Jesse Helms
1980: Daniel Evans/Bill Brock
1984: John Glenn/Ted Kennedy
1988: Paul Simon/Paul G. Kirk
1992: Pete Wilson/John Warner
1996: George W. Bush/Carroll Campbell/Donald Rumsfeld
2000: William H. Gray III/Russ Feingold
2004: George Pataki/Gordon Smith
2008: Gordon Smith/Lisa Murkowski
2012: Mike Pence/Jon Kyl
2016: Sam Nunn/Martin Heinrich
2020: Russ Feingold/Jim Webb
2024: Joni Ernst/Rob Portman

[President Johnson]

Gerald Ford is shot in 1975

38. Gerald R. Ford/Nelson A. Rockefeller, 1974-1975
39. Nelson A. Rockefeller/vacant, Howard Baker, 1975-1979
40. Howard Baker/vacant, Jack Kemp, 1979-1981
41. Frank Church/Edmund G. Brown, 1981-1984
42. Edmund G. Brown/vacant, Lloyd Bentsen, 1984-1989
43. Richard Lugar/George Deukmejian, 1989-1997
44. Albert Arnold Gore/John Forbes Kerry, 1997-2005
45. John McCain/Mark Sandford, 2005-2009
46. Christopher Dodd/Bill Richardson, 2009-2013
47. Fred Thompson/Thomas W. Corbett, 2013-2015
48. Thomas W. Corbett/Jon Huntsman, 2015-2021
49. Edward Miner Lamont/Veronica Escobar, 2021-2029
50. Veronica Escobar/Jospeh P. Kennedy Jr., 2029-incumbent


Losing tickets:

1976: James E. Carter/Walter F. Mondale
1980: Howard Baker/Jack Kemp (inc.)
1984: Jack Kemp/Robert J. Dole
1988: Edmund G. Brown/Lloyd Bentsen (inc.)
1992: Albert Arnold Gore/Paul Tsongas
1996: Peter Barton Wilson/Phil Gramm
2000: John McCain/Trent Lott
2004: John Forbes Kerry/Richard Gephardt
2008: John McCain/Mark Sandford (inc.)
2012: Christopher Dodd/Bill Richardson (inc.)
2016: Bernard Sanders/Martin Heinrich
2020: Jon Huntsman/Marco Rubio
2024: Thomas Cotton/Richard Scott
2028: Josh Hawley/Elise Stefanik

[Joe Biden 2024]

W as Hayes

43. George W. Bush/Bob Dornan 2001-2005
44. John Kasich/Rudy Giuliani 2005
45. Rudy Giuliani/vacant 2005-2009
46. Ed Rendell/Jim Hunt 2009, vacant 2009-2013
47. Jeb Bush/Paul Ryan 2013-2017
48. Ed Rendell/Adam Schiff 2017-2021
49. Rob Portman/Chris Christie 2021-2023, vacant 2023-2025, Charlie Baker 2025
50. Charlie Baker/vacant 2025-2029

Losing Tickets

2000: Howard Dean/Jim Hunt
2004: Wesley Clark/Sherrod Brown
2008: Tom Ridge/Roy Blunt
2012: Ed Rendell/Evan Bayh
2016: Jeb Bush/David Petraeus
2020: Bernie Sanders/Tom Perez
2024: Bernie Sanders/Adam Schiff

[Joe Biden 2024]

Gerald Ford is shot in 1975

38. Gerald R. Ford/Nelson A. Rockefeller, 1974-1975
39. Nelson A. Rockefeller/vacant, Howard Baker, 1975-1979
40. Howard Baker/vacant, Jack Kemp, 1979-1981
41. Frank Church/Edmund G. Brown, 1981-1984
42. Edmund G. Brown/vacant, Lloyd Bentsen, 1984-1989
43. Richard Lugar/George Deukmejian, 1989-1997
44. Albert Arnold Gore/John Forbes Kerry, 1997-2005
45. John McCain/Mark Sandford, 2005-2009
46. Christopher Dodd/Bill Richardson, 2009-2013
47. Fred Thompson/Thomas W. Corbett, 2013-2015
48. Thomas W. Corbett/Jon Huntsman, 2015-2021
49. Edward Miner Lamont/Veronica Escobar, 2021-2029
50. Veronica Escobar/Jospeh P. Kennedy Jr., 2029-incumbent


Losing tickets:

1976: James E. Carter/Walter F. Mondale
1980: Howard Baker/Jack Kemp (inc.)
1984: Jack Kemp/Robert J. Dole
1988: Edmund G. Brown/Lloyd Bentsen (inc.)
1992: Albert Arnold Gore/Paul Tsongas
1996: Peter Barton Wilson/Phil Gramm
2000: John McCain/Trent Lott
2004: John Forbes Kerry/Richard Gephardt
2008: John McCain/Mark Sandford (inc.)
2012: Christopher Dodd/Bill Richardson (inc.)
2016: Bernard Sanders/Martin Heinrich
2020: Jon Huntsman/Marco Rubio
2024: Thomas Cotton/Richard Scott
2028: Josh Hawley/Elise Stefanik

I think this might be the first time I've ever seen Corbett used on this site.

[Cabbage]

Ford as Cleveland:

Gerald Ford/Nelson Rockefeller, 1974-1977
Jimmy Carter/Walter Mondale, 1977-1981
Gerald Ford/Bob Dole, 1981-1985
Ted Kennedy/Lloyd Bentsen, 1985-1989
Lloyd Bentsen/Birch Bayh, 1989-1997
Al Gore/Bill Clinton, 1997-2001
George W. Bush/Dick Cheney, 2001-2009
Bill Clinton/Barack Obama, 2009-2011
Barack Obama/Tim Kaine, 2011-2017
Hillary Clinton/Julian Castro, 2017-2021
Ted Cruz/Paul Ryan, 2021-present

Losing Tickets:
1976: Gerald Ford/Bob Dole
1980: Jimmy Carter/Walter Mondale
1984: Ronald Reagan/George H. W. Bush
1988: Ronald Reagan/Jack Kemp
1992: George H. W. Bush/Bob Dole
1996: Ronald Reagan/Steve Forbes
2000: Al Gore/Bill Clinton
Ralph Nader/Winona LaDuke
2004: John Kerry/Evan Bayh
2008: Mike Huckabee/Rick Perry
2012: Rick Perry/Sarah Palin
2016: Ted Cruz/Carly Fiorina
2020: Hillary Clinton/Julian Castro

[President of the great nation of 🏳️‍⚧️]

Wow, Kasich comes back from the dead after getting assassinated in '05?

[Unconditional Surrender Truman]

Fewest (I think) individuals to be president, choosing from OTL candidates and respecting OTL dates of birth/death.

PRESIDENTS of the UNITED STATES
1. George Washington (Independent, Virginia) 1789 – 1797
2. Thomas Jefferson (Republican, Virginia) 1797 – 1809
3. James Madison (Republican, Virginia) 1809 – 1817
4. James Monroe (Republican, Virginia) 1817 – 1825
5. Andrew Jackson (Democratic, Tennessee) 1825 – 1837
6. Martin Van Buren (Democratic, New York) 1837 – 1853
7. Stephen Douglas (Democratic, Illinois) 1853 – 1861
8. Abraham Lincoln (Republican, Illinois) 1861 – 1865 ‡
9. Andrew Johnson (Democratic, Tennessee) 1865 – 1869
10. Ulysses S. Grant (Republican, Ohio) 1869 – 1885
11. Stephen Grover Cleveland (Democratic, New York) 1885 – 1897
12. William Jennings Bryan (Democratic, Nebraska) 1897 – 1905
13. Theodore Roosevelt (Republican, New York) 1905 – 1909
—. William Jennings Bryan (Democratic, Nebraska) 1909 – 1913
—. Theodore Roosevelt (Republican, New York) 1913 – 1919 †
14. Charles Warren Fairbanks (Republican, Indiana) 1919 – 1921
15. Alfred Emmanuel Smith (Democratic, New York) 1921 – 1933
16. Franklin Delano Roosevelt (Democratic, New York) 1933 – 1945 †
17. Harry S. Truman (Democratic, Missouri) 1945 – 1957
18. Lyndon Baines Johnson (Democratic, Texas) 1957 – 1973
19. Walter Frederick Mondale (Democratic, Minnesota) 1973 – 1981
20. George Herbert Walker Bush (Republican, Texas) 1981 – 1985
—. Walter Frederick Mondale (Democratic, Minnesota) 1985 – 1989
—. George Herbert Walker Bush (Republican, Texas) 1989 – 1997
21. Patrick Joseph Buchanan (Republican, Virginia) 1997 – 2005
22. Johnny Reid Edwards (Democratic, North Carolina) 2005 – 2013
23. Richard John Santorum (Republican, Pennsylvania) 2013 – present

[Boobs]

Fewest (I think) individuals to be president, choosing from OTL candidates and respecting OTL dates of birth/death.

You counted Bush twice and skipped #21 and #25, I think.

[President of the great nation of 🏳️‍⚧️]

Truman also skipped 14.

[Joe Biden 2024]

Reagan as Nixon

40. Ronald Reagan/John Connally 1981-1985, vacant 1985, Bob Michel 1985-1986
41. Bob Michel/vacant 1986, Pete du Pont 1986-1989
42. Mario Cuomo/Sam Nunn 1989-1993
43. Lamar Alexander/Dick Thornburgh 1993-2001
44. Dick Thornburgh/John McCain 2001-2005
45. Jon Corzine/Tom Harkin 2005-2013
46. Scott Walker/Chuck Hagel 2013-2021
47. Mo Cowan/Russ Feingold 2021-2029

Losing Tickets

1980: Walter Mondale/Vance Hartke
1984: Ernest Hollings/Harrison Williams/John Lindsay
1988: Bob Michel/Warren Rudman
1992: Mario Cuomo/Sam Nunn
1996: Sam Nunn/Patricia Schroeder
2000: Gary Locke/Al Gore
2004: Dick Thornburgh/John McCain
2008: Warren Rudman/Rudy Giuliani
2012: Tom Harkin/Byron Dorgan
2016: Ron Wyden/Kirsten Gillibrand
2020: Lindsey Graham/Liz Cheney
2024: Bruce Rauner/Will Hurd

[P. Clodius Pulcher did nothing wrong]

Presidents	Years		Vice Presidents	Years
Howard Baker (R-Tenn.)	1981Assassinated		George Bush (R-Texas)	1981
George Bush (R-Texas)	1981–1985		Vacant
Gary Hart (D-Colo.)	1985–1989		Lloyd Bentsen (D-Texas)	1985–1989
George Bush (R-Texas)	1989–1993		Bob Dole (R-Kans.)	1989–1993
Gary Hart (D-Colo.)	1993–1997		Harris Wofford (D-Penn.)	1993–1997
Donald Rumsfeld (R-Ill.)	1997–2001A.		Lynn M. Martin (R-Texas)	1997–1999Died
			Vacant
			John McCain (R-Ariz.)	2001
John McCain (R-Ariz.)	2001–2009		Vacant
			John E. Sununu (R-N.H.)	2005–2009
Colin Powell (R-N.Y.)	2009–2013		Charlie Crist (R-Fla.)	2009–2012D.
Joe Lieberman (D-Conn.)	2013–2021		Amy Klobuchar (D-Penn.)	1993–1997
Marco Rubio (R-Fla.)	2021–2023D.		John James (R-Mich.)	2021–2023
John James (R-Mich.)	2023–2029		Vacant
			Cathy McMorris Rodgers (R-Wash.)	2025–2033
Ben Sasse (R-Neb.)	2029–2033
Joe Cunningham (D-S.C.)	2033–2045D.		Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.)	2033–2041
			Saikat Chakrabarti (D-Texas)	2041–2045
			Xochitl Torres Small (D-N.M.)	2045

[President of the great nation of 🏳️‍⚧️]

It took me way too long to get that it's a Baker as Garfield list. Not sure why Bentsen doesn't die in '85 ITTL though.

[Joe Biden 2024]

Obama as Harding

44. Barack Obama/Tim Kaine 2009-2011
45. Tim Kaine/vacant 2011, Tom Perez 2011-2017
46. Julian Castro/Chuck Schumer 2017-2021
47. Jon Huntsman/Paul Ryan 2021-2029

Losing Tickets

2008: Jim Edgar/Jon Huntsman
2012: Christine Todd Whitman/Rick Perry
2016: Gary Herbert/John Cornyn
2020: Julian Castro/Chuck Schumer
2024: Jay Inslee/Nina Turner

[Cabbage]

Meh. I'll restart this thread.

ALTERNATE PRESIDENTS FROM MY ABORTIVE HITLER VS. STALIN TIMELINE

(not meant for the squeamish)

Hilliard Victory

PRESIDENTS
(note: colors are reversed due to ideological butterfly effect, due to Hilliard's views)
Adam Hilliard (D) - 1933-1961
Strom Thurmond (D) - 1961-1969
George Wallace (D) - 1969-1977
Ronald Reagan (D) - 1977-1985
Newt Gingrich (D) - 1985-1989
George H. W. Bush (R) - 1989-1997
Bill Clinton (R) - 1997-2005
John McCain (R) - 2005-2013
Donald Trump (D) - 2013-2021
Marco Rubio (R) - 2021-

VICE PRESIDENTS
J. Hamilton Lewis (D) - 1933-1939
William D. Pelley (D) - 1939-1957
Strom Thurmond (D) - 1957-1961
George L. Rockwell (D) - 1961-1969
Orval Faubus (D) - 1969-1977
George Smathers (D) - 1977-1985
Pat Buchanan (D) - 1985-1989
Jim Thompson (R) - 1989-1997
George Deukmejian (R) - 1997-2005
Al Gore (R) - 2005-2013
David Duke (D) - 2013-2021
Paul Ryan (R) - 2021-

LOSING TICKETS
1932: Joseph Steele/Upton Sinclair (F-L)
1936-1964: No major opposition
1968: John F. Kennedy/Hubert H. Humphrey (R)
1972: Hubert H. Humphrey/Ed Muskie (R)
1976: Jerry Brown/Jimmy Carter (R)
1980: Al Gore, Sr./"Scoop" Jackson (R)
1984: Walter Mondale/Geraldine Ferraro (R)
1988: Newt Gingrich/Pat Buchanan (D)
1992: Fritz Hollings/Pat Buchanan (D)
1996: Robert Bork/Clyde N. Wilson (D)
2000: Mike Huckabee/Tom Tancredo (D)
2004: David Duke/Bill O'Reilly (D)
2008: Newt Gingrich/Bill O'Reilly (D)
2012: Barack Obama/George W. Bush (R)
2016: Mitt Romney/Scott Walker (R)
2020: Ted Cruz/Steve Bannon (D)

Steele Victory

PRESIDENTS
Joseph Steele (F-L) - 1933-1953
Dwight D. Eisenhower (F-L) - 1953-1961
Lyndon B. Johnson (D) - 1961-1969
Richard M. Nixon (F-L) - 1969-1977
Ronald Reagan (D) - 1977-1981
Jimmy Carter (F-L*) - 1981-1989
George H. W. Bush (D) - 1989-1997
Bill Clinton (D) - 1997-2005
Bernie Sanders (L) - 2005-2013
Barack Obama (L) - 2013-2021
Beto O'Rourke (D) - 2021-present

*: shortened from Farmer-Labor to Labor in 1984

VICE PRESIDENTS
Upton Sinclair (F-L) - 1933-1937
Huey Long (F-L) - 1937-1945
Harry S Truman (F-L) - 1945-1953
Richard M. Nixon (F-L) - 1953-1961
George Smathers (D) - 1961-1969
Spiro T. Agnew (F-L) - 1969-1973
Hubert H. Humphrey (F-L) - 1973-1977
Gerald Ford (D) - 1977-1981
Jerry Brown (F-L) - 1981-1989
Dan Quayle (D) - 1989-1997
Richard Lugar (D) - 1997-2005
John McCain (L) - 2005-2013
Paul Ryan (L) - 2013-2021
Marco Rubio (D) - 2021-present

LOSING TICKETS
1932: Adam Hilliard/J. Hamilton Lewis (D)
1936: Adam Hilliard/Charles Evans Hughes (D)
1940: Adam Hilliard/Charles Coughlin^ (D)
1944: John Garner/Strom Thurmond (D)
1948: Strom Thurmond/Robert Taft (D)
1952: Estes Kefauver/Douglas MacArthur (D)
1956: Douglas MacArthur/Estes Kefauver (D)
1960: John F. Kennedy/Stuart Symington (F-L)
1964: John F. Kennedy/Hubert H. Humphrey (F-L)
1968: George Wallace/Orval Faubus (D)
1972: George Smathers/Nelson Rockefeller (D)
1976: Jimmy Carter/Walter Mondale (F-L)
1980: Ronald Reagan/Gerald Ford (D)
1984: Gerald Ford/Jack Kemp (D)
1988: Michael Dukakis/Gary Hart (L)
1992: Jerry Brown/Al Gore (L)
1996: Bernie Sanders/Noam Chomsky (L)
2000: Mario Cuomo/Jesse Jackson (L)
2004: Richard Lugar/George W. Bush (D)
2008: George W. Bush/Sarah Palin (D)
2012: Rick Perry/Dana Rohrabacher (D)
2016: Hillary Clinton/Ted Cruz (D)
2020: Elizabeth Warren/Cory Booker (L)

^: Coughlin, having been born in Canada to Canadian parents, was technically ineligible, anyway.

[Joe Biden 2024]

Reagan as Carter

39. Jimmy Carter/Walter Mondale 1977-1981
40. Ronald Reagan/Howard Baker 1981-1985
41. Ted Kennedy/Cyrus Vance 1985-1993
42. Cyrus Vance/Bill Bradley 1993-1997
43. William Weld/Judd Gregg 1997-2005
44. Cyrus Vance Jr./Leon Panetta 2005-2013
45. Brian Sandoval/Rob Portman 2013-2021
46. Elizabeth Warren/Jay Inslee 2021-

Losing Tickets

1980: Jimmy Carter/Jay Rockefeller
1984: Ronald Reagan/Howard Baker
1988: Howard Baker/Paula Hawkins
1992: George S. Mickelson/John Warner
1996: Cyrus Vance/Bill Bradley
2000: Jay Rockefeller/Bill Richardson
2004: Judd Gregg/Arlen Specter
2008: Tom Ridge/Gordon Smith
2012: Joe Biden/Bev Purdue
2016: Martin O'Malley/Xavier Becerra
2020: Charlie Baker/John Hoeven

[Former Senator Haslam2020]

Trump 2012

45. Donald Trump (2013-2021)
46. Sherrod Brown (2021-2025)
47. Jon Huntsman (2025-2033)
48. Alexandria Ocascio Cortez (2033-2037)
49. Donald Trump Jr. (2037-2039)
50. George P. Bush (2039-2041)