Who would you vote to confirm as judge, Part 2

[bullmoose88]

1.) Liberty - NO
2.) Alcon - NO
3.) David S - NO
4.) Texasgurl - NO
5.) Joe Republic - NO
6.) MHS2002 - NO
7.) Supersoulty - NO
8.) John F. Kennedy - NO
9.) Emsworth - YES
10.) MasterJedi - NO
11.) Cosmo Kramer - NO!
12.) King - NO
13.) Siege40 - NO
14.) TN2024 - NO
15.) htmldon - NO
16.) True Democrat - YES
17.) Colin Wixted - NO
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - NO
19.) CheeseWhiz - NO
20.) Dean - YES
21.) Richius - NO
22.) Bono - NO
23.) dazzleman - NO
24.) Milk and Cereal - NO
25.) Gabu - PROBABLY
26.) Bullmoose88 - YES
27.) hughento - NO
28.) nini2287 - YES
29.) Frodo - NO
30.) Tredrick - NO

I thought you claimed to be somewhat of a libertarian? Despite this you vote against all libertarian leaning forumites?

Ahem.

[The Dowager Mod]

Actually, on that list I would vote to confirm everyone except TN2024, because I'm not sure he's sane, and Richius, because of the constant logical fallacies.

As you can see, I'm fairly lenient, as long as someone's not crazy, doesn't have a legal mind or is ethically challenged.

I missed the first list, but I see that only opebo and Texasgurl would vote against confirming me.  (not that unexpected).  I'll give my opinion of the other people on the other thread, since I never did before.

Also, interesting that opebo would confirm me but not Texasgurl who is much more socially liberal than I am.

I don't know you well enough.

[Jake]

1.) Liberty - No
2.) Alcon - Most likely
3.) David S - No
4.) Texasgurl - No
5.) Joe Republic - Most likely
6.) MHS2002 - Yes
7.) Supersoulty - Yes
8.) John F. Kennedy - Yes
9.) Emsworth - Most likely
10.) MasterJedi - No
11.) Cosmo Kramer - Yes
12.) King - No
13.) Siege40 - No
14.) TN2024 - No
15.) htmldon - No
16.) True Democrat - No
17.) Colin Wixted - Yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - No
19.) CheeseWhiz - No
20.) Dean - No
21.) Richius - No
22.) Bono - No
23.) dazzleman- Yes
24.) Milk and Cereal - No
25.) Gabu - Yes
26.) Bullmoose88 - No
27.) hughento - Yes
28.) nini2287 - Yes
29.) Frodo - Yes
30.) Tredrick - Yes

[bullmoose88]

1.) Liberty - No
2.) Alcon - Most likely
3.) David S - No
4.) Texasgurl - No
5.) Joe Republic - Most likely
6.) MHS2002 - Yes
7.) Supersoulty - Yes
8.) John F. Kennedy - Yes
9.) Emsworth - Most likely
10.) MasterJedi - No
11.) Cosmo Kramer - Yes
12.) King - No
13.) Siege40 - No
14.) TN2024 - No
15.) htmldon - No
16.) True Democrat - No
17.) Colin Wixted - Yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - No
19.) CheeseWhiz - No
20.) Dean - No
21.) Richius - No
22.) Bono - No
23.) dazzleman- Yes
24.) Milk and Cereal - No
25.) Gabu - Yes
26.) Bullmoose88 - No
27.) hughento - Yes
28.) nini2287 - Yes
29.) Frodo - Yes
30.) Tredrick - Yes

Guess I'm not nearly socially aut....conservative enough for you and states.

[Akno21]

1.) Liberty - YES
2.) Alcon - Yes
3.) David S - Yes
4.) Texasgurl - Yes
5.) Joe Republic - YES
6.) MHS2002 - Yes
7.) Supersoulty - YES
8.) John F. Kennedy - YES
9.) Emsworth - YES
10.) MasterJedi - Yes
11.) Cosmo Kramer - No
12.) King - Yes
13.) Siege40 - Yes
14.) TN2024 - No
15.) htmldon - Yes
16.) True Democrat - Yes
17.) Colin Wixted - YES
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - Yes
19.) CheeseWhiz - Yes
20.) Dean - Yes
21.) Richius - No
22.) Bono - No
23.) dazzleman- YES
24.) Milk and Cereal - Yes
25.) Gabu - Yes
26.) Bullmoose88 - Yes
27.) hughento - Yes
28.) nini2287 - Yes
29.) Frodo - Yes
30.) Tredrick - YES

Capital YES is for people who actually understand the law and seem very smart about it, normal Yes is for people within the mainstream, who would need to update their legal knowledge, not views, to get my vote in real life

[MHS2002]

I finally got on a list!

1.) Liberty: Yes
2.) Alcon: Yes
3.) David S: Yes
4.) Texasgurl: Probably
5.) Joe Republic: Yes
6.) MHS2002: Under no circumstances
7.) Supersoulty: Yes
8.) John F. Kennedy: Yes
9.) Emsworth: Yes
10.) MasterJedi: Yes
11.) Cosmo Kramer: Probably
12.) King: Yes
13.) Siege40: Probably
14.) TN2024: No
15.) htmldon: Yes
16.) True Democrat: Yes
17.) Colin Wixted: Yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya: Yes
19.) CheeseWhiz: Yes
20.) Dean: Maybe
21.) Richius: No
22.) Bono: Maybe
23.) dazzleman: Yes
24.) Milk and Cereal: Yes
25.) Gabu: Yes
26.) Bullmoose88: Yes
27.) hughento: Yes
28.) nini2287: Yes
29.) Frodo: Yes
30.) Tredrick: Yes

[nini2287]

Actually, on that list I would vote to confirm everyone except TN2024, because I'm not sure he's sane, and Richius, because of the constant logical fallacies.

As you can see, I'm fairly lenient, as long as someone's not crazy, doesn't have a legal mind or is ethically challenged.

I missed the first list, but I see that only opebo and Texasgurl would vote against confirming me.  (not that unexpected).  I'll give my opinion of the other people on the other thread, since I never did before.

Also, interesting that opebo would confirm me but not Texasgurl who is much more socially liberal than I am.

I don't know you well enough.

Fair enough.

[??????????]

17.) Colin Wixted - No

Why the no vote States?

Actually I don't know your views well enough as I mostly see you in the Fantasy stuff.

[CheeseWhiz]

nini2287, Al, Everett, Emsworth, Milk_and_cereal, Akno21 and MHS2002 are now my friends

I no longer like BRTD, TexasGurl, Frodo, StatesRights, opebo or Jake

1.) Liberty - YES
2.) Alcon - Yes
3.) David S - Yes
4.) Texasgurl - YES (even though she voted no for me )
5.) Joe Republic - Yes
6.) MHS2002 - YES
7.) Supersoulty - YES
8.) John F. Kennedy - YES
9.) Emsworth - YES
10.) MasterJedi - Yes
11.) Cosmo Kramer - No
12.) King - Yes
13.) Siege40 - Yes
14.) TN2024 - Unsure
15.) htmldon - YES
16.) True Democrat - Yes
17.) Colin Wixted - Yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - Yes
19.) CheeseWhiz - NO!!!
20.) Dean - Unsure
21.) Richius - No
22.) Bono - No
23.) dazzleman- YES
24.) Milk and Cereal - YES
25.) Gabu - Yes
26.) Bullmoose88 - Yes
27.) hughento - Yes
28.) nini2287 - Yes
29.) Frodo - Yes (even though I don't like him )
30.) Tredrick - YES

YES is for people who I think have the skills and knowledge to become a judge in real life.

[Emsworth]

nini2287, Al, Everett, Emsworth, Milk_and_cereal, Akno21 and MHS2002 are now my friends

Awwww....

[Bono]

YES is for people who I think have the skills and knowledge to become a judge in real life.

So all those people have a law degree?

[Emsworth]

YES is for people who I think have the skills and knowledge to become a judge in real life.

So all those people have a law degree?

Obviously not, especially considering that many posters have not reached college. Clearly, CheeseWhiz was referring to an aptitude for making good, sound legal arguments.

[JohnFKennedy]

YES is for people who I think have the skills and knowledge to become a judge in real life.

So all those people have a law degree?

Just give me a few years.....

[Max Power]

Can I be in part three?

[Gustaf]

1.) Liberty - YES
2.) Alcon YES
3.) David S YES
4.) Texasgurl NO
5.) Joe Republic YES
6.) MHS2002 YES
7.) Supersoulty NO
8.) John F. Kennedy YES
9.) Emsworth YES
10.) MasterJedi NO
11.) Cosmo Kramer NO
12.) King NO
13.) Siege40 YES
14.) TN2024 ABSTAIN
15.) htmldon ABSTAIN
16.) True Democrat YES
17.) Colin Wixted YES
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya ABSTAIN
19.) CheeseWhiz ABSTAIN
20.) Dean NO
21.) Richius NO
22.) Bono - ABSTAIN
23.) dazzleman YES
24.) Milk and Cereal NO
25.) Gabu YES
26.) Bullmoose88 YES
27.) hughento YES
28.) nini2287 ABSTAIN
29.) Frodo NO
30.) Tredrick YES

I voted abstain on those I don't think I know well enough. Some of my no votes are not to be taken personally - you guys might be excellent in many different positions - just not supreme court judges.

[WiseGuy]

1.) Liberty - YES
2.) Alcon YES
3.) David S YES
4.) Texasgurl NO
5.) Joe Republic YES
6.) MHS2002 YES
7.) Supersoulty YES
8.) John F. Kennedy YES
9.) Emsworth NO
10.) MasterJedi YES
11.) Cosmo Kramer NO
12.) King YES
13.) Siege40 YES
14.) TN2024 NO
15.) htmldon YES
16.) True Democrat YES
17.) Colin Wixted YES
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya ABSOLUTLY NOT
19.) CheeseWhiz NO
20.) Dean NO
21.) Richius NO
22.) Bono - As much as I like him, NO
23.) dazzleman YES
24.) Milk and Cereal YES
25.) Gabu YES
26.) Bullmoose88 YES
27.) hughento As much as I like him, NO
28.) nini2287 DON'T KNOW
29.) Frodo YES
30.) Tredrick YES

[Emsworth]

9.) Emsworth NO

[jokerman]

I find it very amusing my views are compared to the extremity of the views of Richius or Bono.  I doubt I have any major extreme views.  Once again I am being painted as this social authoritarian bogeyman who wants to control your life.  You can look at my Senate record -I'm quite the social moderate.

[jokerman]

1.) Liberty No
2.) Alcon Yes
3.) David S No
4.) Texasgurl No
5.) Joe Republic Yes
6.) MHS2002 Yes
7.) Supersoulty Yes
8.) John F. Kennedy No
9.) Emsworth Yes
10.) MasterJedi Yes
11.) Cosmo Kramer Yes
12.) King Yes
13.) Siege40 Yes
14.) TN2024 No
15.) htmldon Yes
16.) True Democrat Yes
17.) Colin Wixted Yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya Yes
19.) CheeseWhiz No
20.) Dean No
21.) Richius No
22.) Bono No
23.) dazzleman No
24.) Milk and Cereal No
25.) Gabu
26.) Bullmoose88 No
27.) hughento
28.) nini2287
29.) Frodo
30.) Tredrick

[dazzleman]

23.) dazzleman No

Preston, just curious why you voted no for me.  That's the only "no" vote that surprised me.  I thought our views on things were reasonably similar.

[Bono]

23.) dazzleman No

Preston, just curious why you voted no for me.  That's the only "no" vote that surprised me.  I thought our views on things were reasonably similar.

You believe in an overbearing federal government, colonization of space and "manifest destiny", whatever that is.

[dazzleman]

23.) dazzleman No

Preston, just curious why you voted no for me.  That's the only "no" vote that surprised me.  I thought our views on things were reasonably similar.

You believe in an overbearing federal government, colonization of space and "manifest destiny", whatever that is.

I do? OK.

[jokerman]

23.) dazzleman No

Preston, just curious why you voted no for me.  That's the only "no" vote that surprised me.  I thought our views on things were reasonably similar.

It's not ideology -I don't know you that well anyway.  It's mainly partisanship and for some reason when I hear the name dazzleman I think ultra-partisan Republican.  Perhaps I should take a closer look.

[dazzleman]

23.) dazzleman No

Preston, just curious why you voted no for me.  That's the only "no" vote that surprised me.  I thought our views on things were reasonably similar.

It's not ideology -I don't know you that well anyway.  It's mainly partisanship and for some reason when I hear the name dazzleman I think ultra-partisan Republican.  Perhaps I should take a closer look.

I'm partisan, but I think ultra-partisan is probably an overstatement.  In any case, thanks for answering.

[Emsworth]

Update:

I am excluding those whom I have not seen post about the Constitution:

1.) Liberty: Yes
2.) Alcon: Yes
3.) David S: Yes
4.) Texasgurl: No (Commerce clause, general welfare)
8.) John F. Kennedy: Yes
9.) Emsworth: -
22.) Bono: Yes