Who would you vote to confirm as judge, Part 2

[Ebowed]

(Part 1 here.)  Basically imagine you're a Senator and all of these forum members have been nominated for judicial positions. Say whether you'd vote to confirm them or not:

1.) Liberty
2.) Alcon
3.) David S
4.) Texasgurl
5.) Joe Republic
6.) MHS2002
7.) Supersoulty
8.) John F. Kennedy
9.) Emsworth
10.) MasterJedi
11.) Cosmo Kramer
12.) King
13.) Siege40
14.) TN2024
15.) htmldon
16.) True Democrat
17.) Colin Wixted
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya
19.) CheeseWhiz
20.) Dean
21.) Richius
22.) Bono
23.) dazzleman
24.) Milk and Cereal
25.) Gabu
26.) Bullmoose88
27.) hughento
28.) nini2287
29.) Frodo
30.) Tredrick

[nini2287]

1.) Liberty-probably not
2.) Alcon-yes
3.) David S-maybe
4.) Texasgurl-yes
5.) Joe Republic-yes
6.) MHS2002-yes
7.) Supersoulty-yes
8.) John F. Kennedy-yes
9.) Emsworth-yes
10.) MasterJedi-yes
11.) Preston Caldwel-probably
12.) King-yes
13.) Siege40-yes
14.) TN2024-yes
15.) htmldon-yes
16.) True Democrat-yes
17.) Colin Wixted-yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya-yes
19.) CheeseWhiz-yes
20.) Dean-yes
21.) Richius-maybe
22.) Bono-probably not
23.) dazzleman-probably
24.) Milk and Cereal-probably
25.) Gabu-yes
26.) Bullmoose88-yes
27.) hughento-yes
28.) nini2287-yes
29.) Frodo-yes
30.) Tredrick-yes

You must be logged in to read this quote.

[Filuwaúrdjan]

1.) Liberty: Yes
2.) Alcon: Yes
3.) David S: Probably not
4.) Texasgurl: Yes
5.) Joe Republic: Yes
6.) MHS2002: Yes
7.) Supersoulty: Yes
8.) John F. Kennedy: Yes
9.) Emsworth: Yes
10.) MasterJedi: Yes
11.) Preston Caldwel: Yesl
12.) King: Yes
13.) Siege40: Yes
14.) TN2024: Er... which is he? The nutter who sometimes has a CT avatar or the sane and reasonable poster with a TX avatar? No if the first, Yes if the second.
15.) htmldon: Yes
16.) True Democrat: Yes
17.) Colin Wixted: Yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya: Yes
19.) CheeseWhiz: Yes
20.) Dean: Yes
21.) Richius: No
22.) Bono: Yes actually
23.) dazzleman: Yes
24.) Milk and Cereal: No (revenge!)
25.) Gabu: Yes
26.) Bullmoose88: Yes
27.) hughento: Yes
28.) nini2287: Yes
29.) Frodo: Yes
30.) Tredrick: Yes

[falling apart like the ashes of American flags]

1.) Liberty - yes
2.) Alcon - yes
3.) David S - probably not
4.) Texasgurl - yes
5.) Joe Republic - yes
6.) MHS2002 - yes
7.) Supersoulty - no
8.) John F. Kennedy - don't know
9.) Emsworth - yes
10.) MasterJedi - no
11.) Cosmo Kramer - no
12.) King - yes
13.) Siege40 - yes
14.) TN2024 - no
15.) htmldon - no
16.) True Democrat - yes
17.) Colin Wixted - no
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - no
19.) CheeseWhiz - no
20.) Dean - yes
21.) Richius - HELL NO
22.) Bono - probably, but I'm a little worried about his views on gun control...
23.) dazzleman - no
24.) Milk and Cereal - yes as long as he defends strip clubs
25.) Gabu - yes
26.) Bullmoose88 - yes
27.) hughento - yes
28.) nini2287 - yes
29.) Frodo - yes
30.) Tredrick - no

[Everett]

1.) Liberty - Yes.
2.) Alcon - Yes.
3.) David S - Of course.
4.) Texasgurl - Yes.
5.) Joe Republic - jEW Republic? Eh, yes.
6.) MHS2002 - Yes.
7.) Supersoulty - Yes.
8.) John F. Kennedy - Yes.
9.) Emsworth - Yes.
10.) MasterJedi - Yes.
11.) Cosmo Kramer - Probably not.
12.) King - Yes.
13.) Siege40 - Yes.
14.) TN2024 - Don't know.
15.) htmldon - Maybe.
16.) True Democrat - Don't know.
17.) Colin Wixted - Maybe.
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - Don't know.
19.) CheeseWhiz - Yes.
20.) Dean - Uh...
21.) Richius - Maybe.
22.) Bono - Yes.
23.) dazzleman - Yes.
24.) Milk and Cereal - Yes.
25.) Gabu - Yes.
26.) Bullmoose88 - Don't know.
27.) hughento - Yes.
28.) nini2287 - Don't know.
29.) Frodo - Maybe.
30.) Tredrick - Maybe/Don't know.

24.) Milk and Cereal - yes as long as he defends strip clubs

Yeah, that's all I care about, too.

[The Dowager Mod]

1.) Liberty no
2.) Alcon no
3.) David S no
4.) Texasgurl
5.) Joe Republic yes
6.) MHS2002 no
7.) Supersoulty yes
8.) John F. Kennedy no
9.) Emsworth no
10.) MasterJedi no
11.) Cosmo Kramer no
12.) King no
13.) Siege40 yes
14.) TN2024 no
15.) htmldon yes
16.) True Democrat no
17.) Colin Wixted no
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya no
19.) CheeseWhiz no
20.) Dean no
21.) Richius no
22.) Bono no
23.) dazzleman yes
24.) Milk and Cereal no
25.) Gabu no
26.) Bullmoose88 yes
27.) hughento yes
28.) nini2287 no
29.) Frodo no
30.) Tredrick no

[nclib]

1.) Liberty - lean no
2.) Alcon - yes
3.) David S - yes
4.) Texasgurl - yes
5.) Joe Republic - yes
6.) MHS2002 - yes
7.) Supersoulty - yes
8.) John F. Kennedy - yes
9.) Emsworth - yes
10.) MasterJedi - yes
11.) Cosmo Kramer - lean no
12.) King - yes
13.) Siege40 - yes
14.) TN2024 - no
15.) htmldon - yes
16.) True Democrat - yes
17.) Colin Wixted - lean yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - lean no
19.) CheeseWhiz - not familiar enough with his positions
20.) Dean - yes
21.) Richius - no
22.) Bono - no
23.) dazzleman - lean no
24.) Milk and Cereal - yes
25.) Gabu - yes
26.) Bullmoose88 - yes
27.) hughento - yes
28.) nini2287 - yes
29.) Frodo - yes
30.) Tredrick - yes

[Emsworth]

1.) Liberty: Yes
2.) Alcon: Yes
3.) David S: Yes
4.) Texasgurl: Unsure
5.) Joe Republic: Yes
6.) MHS2002: Yes
7.) Supersoulty: Yes
8.) John F. Kennedy: Yes
9.) Emsworth:
10.) MasterJedi: Yes
11.) Cosmo Kramer: No
12.) King: Yes
13.) Siege40: Yes
14.) TN2024: Unsure
15.) htmldon: Yes
16.) True Democrat: Yes
17.) Colin Wixted: Yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya: Yes
19.) CheeseWhiz: Yes
20.) Dean: Yes
21.) Richius: No
22.) Bono: No
23.) dazzleman: Yes
24.) Milk and Cereal: Yes
25.) Gabu: Yes
26.) Bullmoose88: Yes
27.) hughento: Yes
28.) nini2287: Yes
29.) Frodo: Yes
30.) Tredrick: Yes

[Frodo]

1.) Liberty Maybe
2.) Alcon Yes
3.) David S Maybe
4.) Texasgurl No
5.) Joe Republic Yes
6.) MHS2002 Yes
7.) Supersoulty Yes
8.) John F. Kennedy Yes
9.) Emsworth Yes
10.) MasterJedi Maybe
11.) Cosmo Kramer Maybe
12.) King Maybe
13.) Siege40 Maybe
14.) TN2024 I have no idea
15.) htmldon Maybe
16.) True Democrat Yes
17.) Colin Wixted Yes
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya Yes
19.) CheeseWhiz No
20.) Dean Maybe
21.) Richius No
22.) Bono No
23.) dazzleman Maybe
24.) Milk and Cereal No
25.) Gabu Yes
26.) Bullmoose88 Yes
27.) hughento Yes
28.) nini2287 Yes
29.) Frodo
30.) Tredrick Yes

[??????????]

1.) Liberty - No
2.) Alcon - No
3.) David S - Yes
4.) Texasgurl - No
5.) Joe Republic - No
6.) MHS2002 - Lean Yes
7.) Supersoulty - Lean Yes
8.) John F. Kennedy - No
9.) Emsworth - Uncertain
10.) MasterJedi - Yes
11.) Cosmo Kramer - Yes
12.) King - No
13.) Siege40 - No
14.) TN2024 - No
15.) htmldon - NO
16.) True Democrat - Lean No
17.) Colin Wixted - No
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - Lean No
19.) CheeseWhiz - Lean No
20.) Dean - NO!!
21.) Richius - Yes
22.) Bono - Yes
23.) dazzleman - Yes
24.) Milk and Cereal - Yes
25.) Gabu - No
26.) Bullmoose88 - No
27.) hughento - No
28.) nini2287 - No
29.) Frodo - No
30.) Tredrick - Yes

[The Dowager Mod]

Well at least you didn't put exclamation points after my no.

[??????????]

Well at least you didn't put exclamation points after my no.

Your stances on social issues are the main reason why I said no. I can tolerate most of the leftist posters economic policies here.

[Emsworth]

9.) Emsworth - Uncertain

That's surprising. I had imagined that you would have answered no.

[??????????]

9.) Emsworth - Uncertain

That's surprising. I had imagined that you would have answered no.

You seem to have a good knowledge of things. I don't disagree with you completely. Your stances on Economic issues appears to be ok with me.

[opebo]

1.) Liberty - NO
2.) Alcon - NO
3.) David S - NO
4.) Texasgurl - NO
5.) Joe Republic - NO
6.) MHS2002 - NO
7.) Supersoulty - NO
8.) John F. Kennedy - NO
9.) Emsworth - YES
10.) MasterJedi - NO
11.) Cosmo Kramer - NO!
12.) King - NO
13.) Siege40 - NO
14.) TN2024 - NO
15.) htmldon - NO
16.) True Democrat - YES
17.) Colin Wixted - NO
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - NO
19.) CheeseWhiz - NO
20.) Dean - YES
21.) Richius - NO
22.) Bono - NO
23.) dazzleman - NO
24.) Milk and Cereal - NO
25.) Gabu - PROBABLY
26.) Bullmoose88 - YES
27.) hughento - NO
28.) nini2287 - YES
29.) Frodo - NO
30.) Tredrick - NO

[MaC]

Basically imagine you're a Senator and all of these forum members have been nominated for judicial positions. Say whether you'd vote to confirm them or not:

1.) Liberty
2.) Alcon
3.) David S
4.) Texasgurl
5.) Joe Republic
6.) MHS2002
7.) Supersoulty
8.) John F. Kennedy
9.) Emsworth
10.) MasterJedi
11.) Cosmo Kramer
12.) King
13.) Siege40
14.) TN2024
15.) htmldon
16.) True Democrat
17.) Colin Wixted
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya
19.) CheeseWhiz
20.) Dean
21.) Richius
22.) Bono
23.) dazzleman
24.) Milk and Cereal
25.) Gabu
26.) Bullmoose88
27.) hughento
28.) nini2287
29.) Frodo
30.) Tredrick

Basically all except for Preston and Richius.  Although Richius's veiws, I can agree with mostly on, I'd think he might be too quick to fly off the handle.  Of course some I would only appoint to a lower court and would not likely see the Supreme court.  Like I said, Liberty and Alcon would probably be most likely to get a higher seat.

[nini2287]

4.) Texasgurl-yes

28.) nini2287 no

Thanks lol

[MaC]

4.) Texasgurl-yes

28.) nini2287 no

Thanks lol

Heh, same thing she said for me.

24.) Milk and Cereal: No (revenge!)

You probably wouldn't have said yes anyways 

24.) Milk and Cereal - yes as long as he defends strip clubs

You know I would

[Sam Spade]

Actually, on that list I would vote to confirm everyone except TN2024, because I'm not sure he's sane, and Richius, because of the constant logical fallacies.

As you can see, I'm fairly lenient, as long as someone's not crazy, doesn't have a legal mind or is ethically challenged.

I missed the first list, but I see that only opebo and Texasgurl would vote against confirming me.  (not that unexpected).  I'll give my opinion of the other people on the other thread, since I never did before.

[nini2287]

Actually, on that list I would vote to confirm everyone except TN2024, because I'm not sure he's sane, and Richius, because of the constant logical fallacies.

As you can see, I'm fairly lenient, as long as someone's not crazy, doesn't have a legal mind or is ethically challenged.

I missed the first list, but I see that only opebo and Texasgurl would vote against confirming me.  (not that unexpected).  I'll give my opinion of the other people on the other thread, since I never did before.

Also, interesting that opebo would confirm me but not Texasgurl who is much more socially liberal than I am.

[ATFFL]

BRTD and opebo:  Thanks for the compliments.

[Colin]

17.) Colin Wixted - No

Why the no vote States?

[Bleeding heart conservative, HTMLdon]

I think the only one I could vote to confirm is JFK, as he is the only one I know has some affiliation with the practice of law.

[JohnFKennedy]

1.) Liberty - NO
2.) Alcon - NO
3.) David S - NO
4.) Texasgurl - NO
5.) Joe Republic - NO
6.) MHS2002 - NO
7.) Supersoulty - NO
8.) John F. Kennedy - NO
9.) Emsworth - YES
10.) MasterJedi - NO
11.) Cosmo Kramer - NO!
12.) King - NO
13.) Siege40 - NO
14.) TN2024 - NO
15.) htmldon - NO
16.) True Democrat - YES
17.) Colin Wixted - NO
18.) Wiseguy/Dubya - NO
19.) CheeseWhiz - NO
20.) Dean - YES
21.) Richius - NO
22.) Bono - NO
23.) dazzleman - NO
24.) Milk and Cereal - NO
25.) Gabu - PROBABLY
26.) Bullmoose88 - YES
27.) hughento - NO
28.) nini2287 - YES
29.) Frodo - NO
30.) Tredrick - NO

I thought you claimed to be somewhat of a libertarian? Despite this you vote against all libertarian leaning forumites?

[Emsworth]

9.) Emsworth - YES

I thouht you claimed to be somewhat of a libertarian? Despite this you vote against all libertarian leaning forumites?

Ahem...