When was America ready for a president....

[Oswald Acted Alone, You Kook]

That is a:

Black?
Female?
Openly Gay?
Roman Catholic?
White Hispanic/Latino?
Brown Hispanic/Latino?
Middle-Eastern?
Muslim?
Jewish?
Openly Atheist?
Far East Asian?
Pacific Islander?
Buddhist?
Indian? (As in from India)
Native American?
Trans?
Polygamist?
Socialist?
Anarchist?
Autistic?
Illegitimate child?
Robot?

[Sumner 1868]

Black? 1990s
Female? 1980s
Openly Gay? 2010s
Roman Catholic? 1950s
White Hispanic/Latino? 1990s
Brown Hispanic/Latino? 1990s
Middle-Eastern? Not yet
Muslim? Not yet
Jewish? 1970s
Openly Atheist? Not yet
Far East Asian? 1990s
Pacific Islander? 1990s
Buddhist? Never
Indian? (As in from India) 1990s
Native American? 1970s
Trans? Not yet
Polygamist? Never
Socialist? 2010s
Anarchist? Never
Autistic? Depends on severity
Illegitimate child? 20th century
Robot? Never

[SUSAN CRUSHBONE]

Black? not yet (all of these are barring exceptional circumstances such as the great recession)
Female? not yet
Openly Gay? not yet
Roman Catholic? 1940s
White Hispanic/Latino? 1960s? depends on "how white" they are, if that makes sense
Brown Hispanic/Latino? not yet
Middle-Eastern? not yet
Muslim? not yet
Jewish? 1980s
Openly Atheist? not yet
Far East Asian? not yet
Pacific Islander? not yet
Buddhist? not yet
Indian? (As in from India) not yet
Native American? not yet
Trans? not yet
Polygamist? not yet
Socialist? not yet (although it would've been possible during the 1930s-40s)
Anarchist? not yet
Autistic? openly? not yet
Illegitimate child? 1960s
Robot? not yet

[bagelman]

That is a:

Black? 2000s
Female? 1980s
Openly Gay? 2010s
Roman Catholic? 1950s
White Hispanic/Latino? 1990s
Brown Hispanic/Latino? 2020s
Middle-Eastern? 1990s
Muslim? 2050s
Jewish? 1980s or earlier
Openly Atheist? 2020s
Far East Asian? 1990s
Pacific Islander? 1990s
Buddhist? 2010s
Indian? (As in from India) 1990s or 2000s
Native American? probably midcentury
Trans? 2030s or 40s maybe
Polygamist? 2100s. The 2096 Missouri state senate debates showed some progress on this issue; they were generally negative about the 2052 Family Law as it was called in DC. Hate that law.
Socialist? 2010s
Anarchist? Never
Autistic? 2020s or 30s for someone who is openly Asperger's.
Illegitimate child? Now-ish
Robot? They may not be so polite as to ask....

[100% pro-life no matter what]

Black? 1990s
Female? 1980s
Openly Gay? 2020s
Roman Catholic? 1950s
White Hispanic/Latino? 1980s
Brown Hispanic/Latino? 2010s
Middle-Eastern? 2030s
Muslim? 2050s
Jewish? 1970s
Openly Atheist? 2030s
Far East Asian? 1990s
Pacific Islander? 1990s
Buddhist? Never?
Indian? (As in from India) 2000s
Native American? 1990s
Trans? Never
Polygamist? Never
Socialist? Hopefully never
Anarchist? Never
Autistic? Depends on what you mean
Illegitimate child? 2000s
Robot? 2200s