Deportation?

[??????????]

Which 'American' poster(s) would you like to kick out of the States if you could?

My list :

- Pym Fourtyn
- Born on the Floor
- Migrendel
- JFraud
- Shira

[A18]

Every Democrat on the board would be a good start

[Joe Republic]

You guys make me laugh sometimes.  StatesRights picks five Democrats, and Philip kicks the rest of them out too.  You do realize how stupidly partisan you look, don't you?

[??????????]

You guys make me laugh sometimes.  StatesRights picks five Democrats, and Philip kicks the rest of them out too.  You do realize how stupidly partisan you look, don't you?

What's your point? I'm not a nutless moderate.

[Joe Republic]

You would kick people who disagree with you out of the country?  Isn't it big enough for all of you at once?

[??????????]

You would kick people who disagree with you out of the country?  Isn't it big enough for all of you at once?

Well, we could ship them to Alaska perhaps..or pen them up in California and shoot at them for fun?

[Joe Republic]

OK at least you're joking.  If you were serious, then I'd be worried what kind of America you think you live in.

[Jake]

Philip
Shira
Pym Fortyn
Palefire
AuH20

[minionofmidas]

Yeah, that last post of States' was actually funny.

[MaC]

opebo-to ensure the safety of American children.  He hates it here anyways, might as well let him go.

[A18]

You would kick people who disagree with you out of the country?  Isn't it big enough for all of you at once?

Yes, but the problems is that they vote for socialism and judicial corruption.

[Joe Republic]

You would kick people who disagree with you out of the country?  Isn't it big enough for all of you at once?

Yes, but the problems is that they vote for socialism and judicial corruption.

In a similar way that you'd vote for a flat tax and StatesRights would vote for George Wallace?  Take a look in the mirror before you decide who deserves to leave the country.

[A18]

That is the entire point. I want a flat tax, the only remotely fair system, and these people are a threat to freedom.

[Joe Republic]

Then you have a fairly subjective and distorted opinion of what freedom actually is.

[TeePee4Prez]

States Rights
Jake
Richius (if he were an American)
Phillip
AuH20

[A18]

Then you have a fairly subjective and distorted opinion of what freedom actually is.

I'm using the dictionary definition. You can use your "moderate" trash definition all you want.

[MasterJedi]

I would deport you all so I could be Supreme Ruler of the Empire of the United States of America!

[Joe Republic]

States Rights
Jake
Richius (if he were an American)
Phillip
AuH20

You're no better for kicking people out based on partisan disagreement.

[Joe Republic]

Then you have a fairly subjective and distorted opinion of what freedom actually is.

I'm using the dictionary definition. You can use your "moderate" trash definition all you want.

You consider someone's belief in freedom to be based solely on their views on flat tax and socialism?

[A18]

Someone who doesn't believe in a flat tax is embracing an ideology of socialism, whereby people will inevitably be divided into economic classes, and majorities will form to hike taxes of the upper classes to pay for their selfish desires of those in the lower brackets.

Now, you could also believe in having no income tax, but this is assuming there's going to be one.

Underlying most arguments against the free market is a lack of belief in freedom itself.

[Joe Republic]

So as long as somebody supports the free market, it doesn't matter what else they believe in?  Let's say somebody thinks all black and Jewish people should be round up and shot, and the Baptist Church should have absolute control over the entire government, but they also support the flat tax.  Would you still let them stay in this country, and deport all the Democrats?

[A18]

All people who don't support the free market are a threat to freedom, so long as they take up a substantial percentage of the population.

That doesn't mean they're the only threat.

[Joe Republic]

Like I said, yours is a subjective opinion, because other people may have a different view on what a belief in freedom actually is.

[A18]

Then the definition of any word is subjective, and you are still without a point.

[Joe Republic]

I thought I'd already spelled it out for you.  No matter, I'll do it again.

You believe somebody should be deported if they don't believe in freedom.  Your definition of freedom is based on your own views about economics, regardless of what other people might think about them.  Therefore, your entire belief in freedom is subjective.  That means you shouldn't have any right to say who believes in freedom and who doesn't, because your definition of the term itself is skewed.