LOL, why does Mr. Teapot Dome have 2/3rds of the vote?
Because Mr. Teapot Dome didn't lock up people for their political views, lie to the public about going to war, and segregate the federal government when he came to town
THIS
People would not be asking the same question if this were say John Q Adams vs Andrew Jackson. Sure, one was a mediocre president with corrupt buddies who supported insane tariffs which damaged the economy, but the other was literally a white supremacist with war fever who supported actions against people due to their ethnicity and race.
That could apply to either one of those scenarios.