Summary of political beliefs (user search)
       |           

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?
April 25, 2024, 02:17:35 PM
News: Election Simulator 2.0 Released. Senate/Gubernatorial maps, proportional electoral votes, and more - Read more

  Talk Elections
  General Politics
  Individual Politics (Moderator: The Dowager Mod)
  Summary of political beliefs (search mode)
Pages: [1]
Author Topic: Summary of political beliefs  (Read 562083 times)
The Right Honourable Martin Brian Mulroney PC CC GOQ
laddicus finch
Jr. Member
***
Posts: 1,850


« on: February 11, 2022, 12:55:41 AM »
« edited: February 11, 2022, 01:06:59 AM by laddicus finch »

Thought it'd be fun to do this, because I don't really know where I stand politically these days. Here goes nothing:

Social Issues:

Abortion: Strongly pro-choice. I don't think all abortion restrictions are necessarily unreasonable, but I think it's more fair to leave the choice to the individual women in question. Keep in mind I'm from Canada which has probably the most liberal abortion laws anywhere, so the specific context of Canada will affect my answer on this and other things.

Gay Marriage/LGBT Rights: Strongly support

Immigration: The flow of human capital is, on balance, a good thing. But there should be controls in place. Immigration should be sustainable and take into consideration the hosting country's needs and capacity. Illegal/undocumented immigrants already in the country should be given a path to legal residency and citizenship, and should not be denied access to basic services - however, the flow of immigration should be controlled.

Gun Control: Again, contextual. In Canada I think gun control measures should target the black market and not legal ownership, and I particularly oppose the Liberal government's moves on this front. In general though I'd say gun ownership should be allowed for people without criminal records, but high-capacity magazines and many modifications should be banned. Semi-auto rifles and handguns should have stricter restrictions than, say, shotguns or bolt-action guns.

Drugs: Keep marijuana legal for everyone over 18, and look into limited legalization of mushrooms. Decriminalize drug use, but enforce harsh penalties against trafficking and dealing.

Alcohol: Lower the drinking age to 18.

Prostitution: People should not be punished for selling their bodies for money, period. But I hesitate to support complete legalization, because as can be seen in places like the Netherlands, this can create an issue with trafficking.

Death Penalty: Oppose

Black Lives Matter: The movement against the killing and mistreatment of black people by the police, support whole-heartedly. The organization, I support their core mission but oppose certain far-left and anarchist elements. I don't think "defund the police" is a good idea in general. The police should absolutely be demilitarized and their training should shift more towards de-escalation and harm reduction - but the idea of broadly diverting police funds to social services strikes me as a little naive, and I don't think the early experiments with this have helped.

Affirmative Action: Very uncomfortable with the idea, but I think completely ending it would do more harm than good. I generally don't think it should be present in the workplace, but in education and training I'm more supportive.

Economic Issues:

Unions: Workers have the right to unionize, and this right should be protected. I don't support right-to-work laws as it only creates a free rider problem. That said, I think public sector unions in particular have too much power. Governments should respect and protect the right on workers to organize, but governments also have the authority to reject unions' demands and enact back-to-work legislation.

Healthcare: Universal access should be guaranteed. I'm not opposed to private delivery of care, but people have a right to medical care.

Taxation: Keep taxes at the minimum level required to meet the government's mandates. I oppose the idea of using taxation as a means of achieving greater equality. Corporate taxes in particular should not be raised unless absolutely necessary, as they just tend to get passed on to the consumer.

Income tax cuts, when appropriate, should be done by cutting the lowest brackets, as this results in tax cuts for everyone and has the greatest net benefit to low income earners - in the case of jurisdictions with a 0% bracket like Canada and most of its provinces, the threshold of that bracket should be raised instead of reducing the rate for individual brackets.

Tariffs: Bad, except in the context of national security. The idea of enacting tariffs to "protect jobs" ultimately cause more harm than good by raising prices for everyone and worsening inflation.

Student Debt: Don't support student loan forgiveness, it would cost far too much, and on average, someone who has hefty student debts to get higher education is still better off than someone who has no higher education. However, the current system of student financing in the US creates perverse incentives and raises tuition. I'm no expert on how to fix this, but forgiving student debt is not something I support.

I think moving towards debt-free college is a good idea, but it depends on how you finance and administer it. Grants, government-backed loans, and bursaries should be more widely available.

Energy/Oil: Nuclear development, where financially sustainable, should be supported, as should green energy. End subsidies to fossil fuel companies. I do not support the Green New Deal, because it has provisions like the job guarantee which I think are misguided. Fossil fuels will not go away tomorrow, but we should prioritize a transition towards more sustainable forms of energy.

Climate Change: Support the scientific consensus, and fostering more global action on climate change. Innovation on clean energy and carbon mitigation should be supported, because I don't think getting the whole world to dramatically reduce energy consumption is a realistic goal. Support the idea of carbon pricing in theory, but again, without global cooperation, it could just end up being a nuisance with no real results.

Other stuff:

COVID restrictions: Oh boy. If you've been following what's going on in Canada as of February 2022, you'll understand why I felt the need to say "oh boy."

Initially, I was very supportive of all COVID measures. I think Omicron (and Canada's very high vaccination rate) have changed my view a little bit. In general, restrictions should be used in a targeted way to manage outbreaks, and I have no problem with mask mandates. Vaccine mandates can be used to limit spread in specific, high-risk settings. What I emphatically oppose is the idea of using mandates to increase compliance, especially in a country with one of the highest vaxxed rates in the world. The scientific consensus in Canada has started to shift a little, arguing that we have to learn to live with COVID. At one point, it will have to be up to individuals to take responsibility for avoiding dangerous situations when they feel the need, and self-isolate when they have symptoms. People should get the support they need to do this. However, lockdowns have had negative impacts on education, business, mental health, and even social cohesion. When most Canadians are vaccinated, and we have very strict restrictions, but COVID is still not being contained, we need to shift our scope from containment towards management.

Generally civil libertarian, I think a healthy skepticism of government (and all forms of authority) are necessary for a free society. However, nobody exists in a vacuum, and we all have a responsibility to respect others and the law. Tyranny and anarchy are both evil - governments should be limited in their ability to restrict civil liberties, but not in the ability to enforce existing laws. I think this is an importance balance.

On foreign policy, not exactly hawkish, but probably more so than dovish in today's context. For something topical, I absolutely support defending Ukraine, although leaving military intervention as a last resort. In general, I think military action should be used only as a last resort. All NATO countries should aim to contribute 2% of GDP to their military, and I think Canada should gradually increase spending once we kill the structural deficit. Strongly oppose nation-building and think Bush's handling of the Iraq War was one of the worst decisions made by a recent President. However, I do not support isolationism, and think that the west should defend its allies and intervene to stop genocides. The American military-industrial complex should be defunded, the military does not exist to create jobs, but to defend the country and its allies.
Logged
The Right Honourable Martin Brian Mulroney PC CC GOQ
laddicus finch
Jr. Member
***
Posts: 1,850


« Reply #1 on: May 30, 2023, 06:42:30 PM »

Minimum Wage: Distort the labour market, but necessary, because the alternatives are worse. Raise periodically to keep in line with CoL, and encourage employers to increase wages, benefits etc via incentives.

Abortion: Pro-choice. I'm not personally comfortable with abortion and think more humane alternatives should be supported. But stopping people who want one from getting a legal abortion ain't right.

Birth Control: Supportive.

Same-Sex Marriage: Supportive.

Death Penalty/Sentencing: Not against it on principle, but here in Canada it's been abolished for decades, and I wouldn't support bringing it back.

Marijuana: Keep legal.

Gun Control: Generally pro-gun rights, but I can go either way depending on the specific measure proposed.

Prostitution: The act of prostitution shouldn't be a crime, but brothels and organized prostitutions should be. Again, it depends on the local context. In places where it's already normalized, I'd feel different. But here in Canada it's not a commonplace thing, and I'm good keeping it that way.

Affirmative Action: Generally opposed, but I can see limited circumstances where it makes sense.

Reparations: Opposed.

Police Reform: Way too broad to give a snappy answer on. Very opposed to Defund the Police and other such nonsense, but I acknowledge the need for some reform. Generally though, I tend to think that peace and public order should not be things that we experiment with, so with police reform I support a more gradual approach.

Prisons: They should exist and be used primarily to keep criminals away from society.

Free Speech: Non-negotiable, with exceptions for direct incitement of violence, breaching national security, doxxing private information, "yelling fire in a theater", etc.

PATRIOT Act: I'm not very knowledgable or have strong opinions on that act in particular, so I won't comment on it. In general, I'm against permitting government surveillance of civilians, but it's all about proportionality - sometimes, a crisis is bad enough that trade-offs must be made. From what I know, I don't think the PATRIOT Act was a proportionate or necessary response to 9/11, although a softer approach would have been.

Eminent Domain: Support, but arbitrated negotiation required before invoking eminent domain. And if invoked, must compensate greater than market value.

Immigration: Support legal immigration with a streamlined process, but I think current rates in Canada are too high. Main focus should be on skill-based immigration, support taking refugees from severe crisis areas, oppose illegal immigration and sanctuary cities.

Euthanasia: Yes, but only for terminal illnesses.

Mask Mandates: I mean at this point, opposed. But 2-3 years ago, it was clearly necessary.

Vaccine Mandates: In general, I think individuals should never be made to ingest or inject anything against their will, even if it's for the common good - there are certain boundaries of personal autonomy that should not be crossed. But I think public schools should be able to mandate it for students, and employers should be able to mandate it provided that there is a reason (working with vulnerable people, etc).

COVID-19 Vaccines: Ditto, although I wouldn't mandate it for public school students either, but definitely mandate it for healthcare workers for example.

LGBT: Lol what a broad topic. I support the right of LGBT people to live and express themselves freely and not be discriminated, and I support same-sex marriage and adoption. I don't support physical transition for pre-pubescent minors. I'm also very uncomfortable with the public expression and normalization of sexually explicit aspects embraced by some people in the LGBT community. I know what people are going to say, no I'm not accusing LGBT people of being perverts or anything like that, or saying "just don't do it in public", because of course people should be able to express themselves. But if your self-expression involves publicizing your fetish in the middle of the street, as it seems to for some people in the community, don't get surprised when people try to shield their kids from that subculture.

Free Trade: Based (but must be reciprocal).

Income/Corporate Taxes: Keep low. Cut income taxes whenever possible, preferably by raising the personal amount (i.e. the amount of income that isn't taxed before income taxes kick in, raising the personal amount would disproportionately help low income people). For corporate taxes, it all depends on the business environment, but it should be kept competitive.

Tax Credits: An imperfect but effective way of providing tax relief (and if we're being realistic, pandering to key voter blocs).

Healthcare: Ensure universal access to public healthcare while allowing more for-profit facilities to operate at the user's expense, as long as public facilities are available, and a certain % of private healthcare profits directly go to the public system. This would alleviate the over-capacity of public healthcare and give customers more options without abolishing the public system.

Social Security: Again, not American, not very familiar with the specifics.

National Debt: Limit deficits and pay down debt as much as practicable.

Campaign Finance Reform: Individuals should be allowed to donate up to a certain limit. Ban direct corporate and union donations, PACs should be permitted.

Unions: Support in the private sector, oppose in the public sector (but can make peace with).

Tariffs: Only reciprocal tariffs.

UBI: Opposed.

Welfare: Should be limited as much as possible, able-bodied people shouldn't rely on the state for their livelihood, although people with disabilities or other circumstances out of their control that make it hard for them to get work should get enough support to live on. Better to focus on skill development than provide welfare.

Foreign Policy: Support our allies in NATO, Ukraine, Israel, Japan, Korea, etc, and stay the f- away from China. Generally maintain warm relations with countries wherever possible, but also understand that geopolitics can be very brutal and unforgiving, so don't be naive.

Colleges: Shouldn't be free, but government should intervene to cut tuition costs, especially in state and community colleges. More importantly, I think governments should put a halt on the policy of getting as many students as possible into 4-year university degrees, and instead promote trades and associate degrees focused on professional development - nothing against academia, but the social expectation of needing a 4-year bachelor's degree (particularly arts and general business programs that aren't very useful anyway) is unhealthy and forces a lot of young people into financial and time commitments that really aren't necessary to be a useful member of society.

Education: What I said above for post-secondary, and the idea of applying more practical education in the secondary level also applies. I know very little about primary education policy though, so I won't say anything. I do think school choice and charter schools are a good thing, but public education is also important.

Afghanistan: What's done is done. Don't recognize the Taliban and give into their extremism, but we're well past the point of them being the de facto government.

China: Again, avoid getting entangled with China any more than necessary. I think the west has slowly learned the hard way (I'm thinking about Canada in particular, but it applies everywhere) that economic liberalization does NOT mean that China is going to become a trustworthy power.

Middle East: No particular opinion, but building ties with Middle Eastern countries without undermining NATO obligations is the best way to go for Canada.

Cuba: As a Canadian, Cuba is more a cheap vacation destination (and the birthplace of our Prime Minister of course  Wink ) than a real geopolitical question.

Military Spending: Work towards meeting the 2% NATO target by beefing up our presence in the Arctic.

NSA Spying: What I said above about the PATRIOT Act.

Palestine/Israel: Status quo for Canadian policy, support our allies in Israel but don't get any more involved than we need to. Against BDS and such things, but there's no reason for us to pick fights with the Palestinians either. Peace in the region would be nice, but not our job.

Ukraine-Russia War: Support Ukraine.

Mexico: Again, as a Canadian, I don't feel any kind of way about Mexico politically. I'd like to travel there though, I've done the typical Cancun thing but I'd like to see more of the country.

Climate Change: Important to tackle, but we have to be realistic about what we can actually achieve on this file. I don't support hamstringing our energy sector only to let that demand be fulfilled by others. Strongly supportive of renewable and nuclear energy.

Carbon Tax: A good idea in theory, but I question its effectiveness in the way it's been applied.

Keystone Pipeline: Support.

Energy independence: Supportive.

Big Lie: Biden won the election.

Voter ID: Support, as long as ID is easy enough to attain (or better yet, any official government ID like a license, passport, health card, etc).

Audits: Audits? Yeah, audits need to be done regularly as a matter of good business practice. I'm not sure what this is referring to lol.

Term Limits: Nah, doesn't really make sense in a parliamentary system.

DC/PR statehood: Don't care.

SCOTUS: No strong opinions.

Alcohol: End the government monopoly on liquor sales (this is a very Ontario specific thing though). I'm not a big drinker, but I don't think government intervention on alcohol consumption is necessary or advisable.

Porn: Banning it won't work, but it's a genuine public health issue. Focus on awareness, and clamp down on sketchy practices in the porn industry.

Religion in Schools: I have no problem with school prayer, and parents should be able to send their kids to religious schools. That said, public schools shouldn't promote or oppose any religion.
Logged
Pages: [1]  
Jump to:  


Login with username, password and session length

Terms of Service - DMCA Agent and Policy - Privacy Policy and Cookies

Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines

Page created in 0.037 seconds with 11 queries.