The Convention for Agreement on Regional Consolidation in Atlasia - MAP SELECTED

[Хahar 🤔]

I, Xahar, publicly support regional consolidation. I understand that regional consolidation requires compromise and collaboration. In the pursuit of progress and in the spirit of collaboration, I hereby join the Convention for Agreement on Regional Consolidation in Atlasia. I shall have the right to debate, to submit a map proposal for regional consolidation and to vote on all entries submitted during the submission period.

[Adam Griffin]

CARCA ACTIVATED



MAP SUBMISSION PERIOD: ONLINE

MAP SUBMISSION PERIOD TERMINATES: 10/19/13 01:31:28 AM ET

MAP VOTING PERIOD BEGINS: 10/19/13 01:31:29 AM ET

[Chancellor Tanterterg]

How do you change the number of electoral votes given to each state when making the map?  It'd be easier to change them to the number Atlasians living in each state.

[Talleyrand]

How do you change the number of electoral votes given to each state when making the map?  It'd be easier to change them to the number Atlasians living in each state.

I was wondering this too, but here's a map that does not account for population.

[windjammer]

How do you change the number of electoral votes given to each state when making the map?  It'd be easier to change them to the number Atlasians living in each state.

I was wondering this too, but here's a map that does not account for population.

I will never support this map, I don't want to split the Midwest!

[Flake]

How do you change the number of electoral votes given to each state when making the map?  It'd be easier to change them to the number Atlasians living in each state.

I was wondering this too, but here's a map that does not account for population.

I will never support this map, I don't want to split the Midwest!

But all it does is give Oklahoma to the Southern region, and only 1 voter there (Maxwell).

[windjammer]

How do you change the number of electoral votes given to each state when making the map?  It'd be easier to change them to the number Atlasians living in each state.

I was wondering this too, but here's a map that does not account for population.

I will never support this map, I don't want to split the Midwest!

But all it does is give Oklahoma to the Southern region, and only 1 voter there (Maxwell).

No, Minnesota, Iowa are two  Midwest states too!

[Talleyrand]

It's inevitable that 1-5 regions are going to be split. I'd strongly encourage that none of us get too attached to our imaginary fiefdoms here.

My map splits 3 regions (the Midwest, Mideast, and Northeast). I made the map without considering the interests of any region in mind, and remember it's only a proposal. I'm sure there will be some good alternatives available if you don't like. I'm open to all reasonable ideas here.

[Flake]

How do you change the number of electoral votes given to each state when making the map?  It'd be easier to change them to the number Atlasians living in each state.

I was wondering this too, but here's a map that does not account for population.

I will never support this map, I don't want to split the Midwest!

But all it does is give Oklahoma to the Southern region, and only 1 voter there (Maxwell).

No, Minnesota, Iowa are two  Midwest states too!

Oops sorry about forgetting about them, but Talleyrand is right

It's inevitable that 1-5 regions are going to be split. I'd strongly encourage that none of us get too attached to our imaginary fiefdoms here.

My map splits 3 regions (the Midwest, Mideast, and Northeast). I made the map without considering the interests of any region in mind, and remember it's only a proposal. I'm sure there will be some good alternatives available if you don't like. I'm open to all reasonable ideas here.

At least one region will be split, and most likely four or all five will be split.

[GAworth]

How about this map. Don't mind the population, just look at the states.

[GAworth]

How about this map. Don't mind the population, just look at the states.

So I was told my map didn't work. So here is my map again.

[The world will shine with light in our nightmare]

Blue=61
Red=51
Gray=53

Some of the numbers on the map were hard to see, but I tried counting the populations as best as I could.

[Flake]

For those of you who are using my electoral map (the one GAworth used)

Since a few people joined the game, the numbers may be off a bit.

[Donerail]

Talleyrand's map has my full support. Hopefully the MN/IA issue can be resolved, but it's an ideal starting point.

[Sopranos Republican]

https://uselectionatlas.org/FORUM/index.php?topic=174045.0

BTW, for everyone who is wondering how to alter the EV totals on the maps.

[Fritz]

A couple minor changes to Tallyrand's map.

This map:
1. Combines the Midwest and Pacific entirely, except OK
2. Leaves the Northeast intact, except Delaware
3. Leaves the IDS intact
4. Divides the Mideast between the Northeast and South.  Sorry ME, this is the one region that simply must be split up because of its location on the map
5. West = 53, Northeast = 57, South =58

Missouri could really go in any of the three, in fact it may be better off in the West.  Also, West Virginia could go South or NE.

[Maxwell]

Fritz's map is a favorite of mine.

[Fritz]

Missouri looks better in the West. 

[Flake]

Missouri looks better in the West. 

This is the best map I've seen so far!

[GAworth]

Missouri looks better in the West. 

My only amendment would be a switch of Maryland and Delaware to the North, and move West Virginia to the South.

[Fritz]

My only amendment would be a switch of Maryland and Delaware to the North, and move West Virginia to the South.

I agree.  Lets go with this one:

West = 55, South = 52, Northeast = 61

[Talleyrand]

That's very clean and aesthetically pleasing, plus it balances the population as much as can be reasonably expected- it has my full support at this point.

[Donerail]

That's very clean and aesthetically pleasing, plus it balances the population as much as can be reasonably expected- it has my full support at this point.

[The world will shine with light in our nightmare]

That's very clean and aesthetically pleasing, plus it balances the population as much as can be reasonably expected- it has my full support at this point.

It's also the exact same thing I proposed.

[GAworth]

My proposal:

I could very well support this.