The 1880 United States Presidential ElectionWhile President Tilden won the electoral vote by a very comfortable margin, some said land-slide, the popular vote was a different story. With rumors escaping that Blaine had been privy to corrupt financial dealings days after the end of the Republican National Convention, pro-silver and pro-paper money Republicans unhappy over the nomination of another gold candidate, and the populist Greenback campaign run by Weaver, a fast-paced race for election day began. Republican newspapers across the country denounced Blaine, with a "mugwump" faction throwing its support behind Tilden and a populist faction supporting Weaver. Meanwhile, Weaver took advantage of the nation's railroad system, going from town to town across the West and Mid-West campaigning. With Republican diehards still clinging to Blaine, neither Weaver nor Tilden could claim a majority of the popular vote. However, Tilden claimed a plurality, and a majority of the electoral vote as well, sealing the deal for his re-election.

President Samuel J. Tilden (Democrat-New York)/Associate Justice of the Supreme Court Joel Parker (Democrat-New Jersey) 245 electoral votes, 45.2% of the popular voteCongressman James B. Weaver (Greenback-Iowa)/Former Congressman Benjamin Franklin Butler (Greenback-Massachusetts) 124 electoral votes, 42.9% of the popular voteSenator James G. Blaine (Republican-Maine)/Former Collector of the Port of N.Y. Chester Alan Arthur (Republican-New York)0 electoral votes, 11.9%